Senate OKs steroid bill, rejects transgender concerns


Highlights

Bill’s Republican author says his intent is to ensure safe, fair play in high school sports.

Democratic opponents say the bill would unfairly target transgender students taking prescribed steroids.

Rejecting arguments that the bill was meant to target transgender student athletes, the Texas Senate gave initial approval Tuesday to legislation that would crack down on steroid use in high school.

Senate Bill 2095 would give the University Interscholastic League, which oversees public high school athletics, the power to declare students ineligible to compete based on steroid use, even if it is prescribed and administered by a physician.

“We need to make sure we have a safe and fair environment for our students to compete in athletic events,” said the bill’s author, Sen. Bob Hall, R-Edgewood.

Sen. Sylvia Garcia, D-Houston, accused Hall of dodging repeated questions about the bill’s true intent, which she said was to discriminate against transgender students who use prescribed steroids to transition to their male-identified gender.

“This would have a negative impact on transgender students who compete in some events. It seems to me, on its face, it has everything to do with that,” Garcia said. “All young people should have the ability to compete in UIL sports while having their personal dignity respected.”

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

Hall denied that SB 2095 had anything to do with transgender issues, at one point asking Garcia if she was trying to impugn his character when she rejected his explanations.

SB 2095 would let the UIL determine, on a case by case basis, whether the steroid use provided an unfair advantage, Hall said. “If, in their evaluation, they say what is being taken does not give the student an unfair advantage … then they could compete,” he said.

Sen. Jose Menéndez, D-San Antonio, said there was no established need to crack down on steroid use, noting that the Legislature stopped funding a testing program after only two of 2,633 students tested in 2013-14 were found to have used steroids.

Menéndez proposed an amendment to give the UIL the discretion to make exceptions for students who are transitioning, “providing equal opportunity for transgender students.”

That amendment, and a similar one from Garcia, was rejected on a 20-11 party-line vote.

The Senate followed by granting initial approval to SB 2095, requiring a final vote Wednesday before the bill can be sent to the House. All 20 Senate Republicans voted for the bill, as did four Democrats: Sens. Juan “Chuy” Hinojosa of McAllen, Eddie Lucio Jr. of Brownsville, Carlos Uresti of San Antonio and Royce West of Dallas.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Exonerated man sues Williamson County for not disclosing evidence
Exonerated man sues Williamson County for not disclosing evidence

For more than two decades, Troy Mansfield was a registered sex offender for a crime he did not commit. And all that time, the prosecutors’ case file notes in the Williamson County district attorney’s office raised doubts about his guilt and pointed to evidence that could exonerate him. After he and his attorney discovered that evidence...
BREAKING UPDATE: Man critically injured, crews searching for woman after boats crash on Lake Austin, officials say
BREAKING UPDATE: Man critically injured, crews searching for woman after boats crash on Lake Austin, officials say

8:45 p.m. update: A man in his 50s is critically injured after two boats crashed on Lake Austin on Tuesday night, Austin-Travis County EMS officials said. A woman is still unaccounted for after the boat crash near the Pennybacker Bridge, EMS officials said. Crews are currently searching for her, EMS said.  The man was flown to Dell Seton Medical...
Pressure rises to pull parkland as options for MLS stadium in Austin
Pressure rises to pull parkland as options for MLS stadium in Austin

Momentum is building to remove Precourt Sports Ventures’ preferred city parkland sites for a Major League Soccer stadium from consideration by the Austin City Council. Kathie Tovo, a critical swing vote on the council in the soccer saga, told the American-Statesman on Tuesday night that Butler Shores Metropolitan Park and Roy Guerrero Metropolitan...
Exonerated man sues Williamson County for not disclosing evidence
Exonerated man sues Williamson County for not disclosing evidence

For more than two decades, Troy Mansfield was a registered sex offender for a crime he did not commit. And all that time, the prosecutors’ case file notes in the Williamson County district attorney’s office raised doubts about his guilt and pointed to evidence that could exonerate him. After he and his attorney discovered that evidence...
Cornyn takes lead on effort to craft a Senate immigration bill
Cornyn takes lead on effort to craft a Senate immigration bill

U.S. Sen. John Cornyn said Tuesday he might want to borrow the Masai tribal “talking stick” that Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, used to ensure civility during pivotal negotiations that resulted in a short-term deal that ended the government shutdown Monday. Cornyn, the No. 2 Senate Republican, is riding herd over efforts to fashion a much...
More Stories