Viewpoints: City should define ‘affordable housing’ in CodeNext talks

Like its predecessor, the second draft of CodeNext — the city’s proposed overhaul of its land-use and zoning code — largely has been sold as a way of increasing affordable housing for residents who cannot find homes in Austin’s hot housing market.

But does it live up to its hype?

The answers are elusive in large part because the “affordable housing” label has morphed into a catch-all category that encompasses housing not just for service-sector employees, construction workers and others who earn below 80 percent of Austin’s median family income, but for young professionals and others, who need so-called “missing middle” homes. Those are homes or apartments that fall between low-income housing and market-rate homes.

CITY COUNCIL: Austin ‘downtown puzzle’ plan to be studied in pieces.

It would be wise for Mayor Steve Adler and the City Council to take a step back and analyze whether CodeNext realistically can deliver on city housing goals of 135,000 units over the next 10 years with as many as 65,000 being affordable through zoning changes that promote more density.

They also need to be frank about the limitations of the zoning code against market forces and the potential unintended consequences of that combination in shrinking Austin’s stock of affordable apartments and homes, rather than increasing that supply.

That starts with defining “affordable housing” and “missing middle housing” and acknowledging the shortcomings of any zoning code in slowing or stopping displacement, so real solutions can emerge.

“What I’m afraid of are the unintended consequences,” said Walter Moreau, executive director of Foundations Communities, a nonprofit that builds housing for low-income families. “We’ve lost a lot of affordable apartments that get torn down and replaced with expensive apartments. Will CodeNext accelerate that trend?”

PRESERVATION: Austin City Council to negotiate buying historic Montopolis Negro School.

It’s a good question — one without an answer so far, because the cost of housing is not solely determined by supply and demand, but by profitability, location and what the market will bear. Simply building more housing units won’t generate the kind of affordable housing Moreau and advocates are working to increase, such as two-bedroom apartments that go for $800 a month in locations with access to public transportation — not when renters are willing to pay $1,400 for such units, as they now are doing.

The city can start with defining “affordable homes” for lower-wage workers and “missing middle” homes for higher-wage city or state employees, artists and teachers. The public also needs greater clarity on which category of homes – affordable, missing middle or market-rate – CodeNext is likely to boost.

The city can lessen confusion by clarifying “affordable homes” as those aimed at serving people who earn no more than $65,100 annually for a family of four, which is 80 percent of Austin’s median family income. For one person, that income is $45,600.

By contrast, “missing-middle” homes could be defined as homes targeting people with incomes ranging from $65,100 to $97,680, the latter being for a family of four earning 120 percent of Austin’s median family income.

VIEWPOINTS: Council has chance to help homeless, give to preservation.

Too often in discussion about CodeNext, missing-middle homes are represented as affordable because they are less expensive than market-rate homes. Even so, they aren’t affordable for low-wage workers.

Clarifying the two and projecting how CodeNext will increase or decrease either category will help lessen confusion and provide greater transparency.

City staff and the council also should explore more deeply the unintended consequences of CodeNext. Already, density is having a negative impact on once-affordable East Austin neighborhoods, displacing many families who for generations have lived there, but no longer can afford to, as mortgages, rents and property taxes have skyrocketed.

Austin school district officials blame the city’s shortage of affordable housing as a key reason for its declining enrollment and empty classrooms in several East Austin schools. The district projects enrollment at 81,427 for this school year, a drop of 1,640 students from last year. In financial terms, the Austin district will lose about $12 million under the school funding formula.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.

With more development steered to east-central Austin than any other district under CodeNext, Council Member Ora Houston worries displacement of families there will accelerate as even more “land owned by Austinites of African and Mexican ancestry” is “acquired by speculators and developers.”

Moreau cites another problem with CodeNext that ignores zoning for special-needs housing, such as housing for the homeless or near homeless, called supportive housing, that is addressed under the current code.

“I am not sure under CodeNext how we deal with exceptions, such as special needs,” he told the editorial board, adding, “What will be the process for unintended consequences on such a massive rewrite of the code? There will be some.”

CodeNext also suffers from its name and topic regarding zoning. That can be daunting or a low-priority for residents working long hours while juggling the demands of family. Keep in mind that zoning determines the size, character and affordability of your neighborhood. It doesn’t get more personal than that.

Austin residents can’t afford a laissez faire approach on neighborhood zoning. Get involved. There still is plenty of time and a meeting in your neighborhood coming soon.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Viewpoints page brings the latest commentaries to your Facebook feed.

Upcoming CodeNext meetings

East Austin

Oct. 2: 6-8 p.m., Conley-Guerrero Senior Activity Center, 808 Nile St.

Southwest Austin

Oct. 9: 6-8p.m., Crockett High School, 5601 Manchaca Rd.

Northeast Austin

Oct. 11: 6-8 p.m., Hart Elementary School, 8301 Furness Dr.

Central Austin

Oct. 16: 6-8 p.m., Austin High School, 1715 Cesar Chavez St.

Northwest Austin

Oct. 23: 6-8 p.m., Anderson high school, 8403 Mesa Dr.

Southeast Austin

Oct. 28: 10 a.m.-12 p.m., Dove Springs Rec. Center, 5801 Ainez Dr.

More information at:

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Trump’s scary strategy on North Korea

On just the first day of a war between the United States and North Korea, according to a Stanford University assessment, 1 million people could be killed. Yet after my five-day visit to North Korea with three New York Times colleagues, such a nuclear war seems terrifyingly imaginable. In the North Korean capital, Pyongyang, it was clear that President...
Trump’s appeal to evangelicals is timely and welcomed

President Trump addressed this year’s annual Values Voters Summit in Washington, D.C. He is the first sitting U.S. president to do so. The Values Voters Summit is hosted by the Family Research Council, an organization whose mission is addressing public policy and culture from a Christian point of view. Its base is largely evangelical Christians...
INSIGHT: With ride-hailing apps, should Americans stop owning cars?
INSIGHT: With ride-hailing apps, should Americans stop owning cars?

Every day, there’s more news about the inevitable arrival of autonomous vehicles. At the same time, more people are using ride-hailing and ride-sharing apps — and the percentage of teens getting their driver’s license continues to decline. Given these technologies and social changes, it’s worth asking: Should Americans stop...
Commentary: How social media posts can hurt criminal investigations
Commentary: How social media posts can hurt criminal investigations

Law enforcement officials are facing a new set of challenges in the age of social media. One such challenge is becoming more common — and I feel compelled to call attention to it. The act of capturing video or photographs of crime scenes and posting those images to social media is harmful to law enforcement investigative efforts. This year, we&rsquo...
Commentary: What the U.S. will lose after its withdrawal from UNESCO
Commentary: What the U.S. will lose after its withdrawal from UNESCO

“Since wars begin in the minds of men, it is in the minds of men that the defenses of peace must be constructed.” So begins the preamble to the Constitution of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. They were words written in 1945 by the American poet and playwright Archibald MacLeish, who served on the organization&rsquo...
More Stories