TWO VIEWS: Austin sick-leave policy pushes entrepreneurs to suburbs


Once again, the Austin City Council is overreaching on an issue that was never intended to be governed at the municipal level. And, once again, Austin businesses will pay the price if they choose to keep their businesses here.

When the City Council decided to require Austin businesses to provide paid sick leave to all employees, it also further decided that Austin isn’t a place where businesses can be competitive on a regional, state or national level. No one will tell you that taking care of your employees is a bad idea; what is a bad idea is mandating issues like paid sick leave at the municipal level. Fourteen states — including neighboring Oklahoma and Louisiana — agree and have enacted statewide bans on similar local-level mandates. Why? Because they just don’t work.

UPDATE: Campaign launches effort to get paid sick leave for all Austin workers.

Try to find a legitimate study that favors locally enforced paid sick leave. They don’t exist. Among cities with similar mandates, San Francisco employers report being forced to pass along the cost by reducing benefits and labor hours and still experienced a significant decline in profit — by 12 to 23 percent. Most Seattle-based employers saw no measurable increase in areas like employee morale or predictability of employee absenteeism — areas the City Council cites as important reasons for the initiative. In fact, among five studies examining the effect of mandatory paid sick leave laws in cities nationwide, four found no reduction in the frequency of employees coming to work sick.

The Austin Technology Council has spoken out against the mandate, asserting that “tech and innovation companies and all businesses need to have flexible workplace policies that meet the needs of both employers and employees. A one-size-fits-all government-mandated sick leave policy does not work for most tech companies, and will inhibit [their] ability to create an environment and PTO policy that works best for [their businesses].”

I agree wholeheartedly. I’m a business owner with over 300 employees in the Austin area. I’ve estimated the City Council’s mandate will cost my company about $5,000 a week — just to meet a rigid policy that will not be in the best interest of most of my employees.

TWO VIEWS: Sick-leave policy lifts struggling workers, city’s economy.

Step outside Austin’s city limits into Round Rock, San Marcos and other fast-growing cities, and there is no such penalty for doing business. What would stop business owners from moving and starting businesses nearby just to gain that competitive advantage? What if those employees wishing they had an extra week’s worth of pay — or more — each year for time off find themselves without a job at all?

The City Council began its public forums intent on enacting a mandate without first hearing from the businesses it will deeply affect. They’ve instead jumped ahead, asking the public to help decide how it will be implemented. I’ll tell you now: There is no solution at the city level that is healthy for employees and businesses. The issue of paid sick leave does not belong in the hands of the City Council — period. Please join me in visiting the city’s Speakup Austin website to provide feedback against the proposal — and call your City Council representative to have your voice heard.

Turpin is founder and CEO of the HT Group, a consulting firm.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Viewpoints: Listen, America. Our kids have something to say about guns

The national gun debate has a new, youthful face. This time children are the grown-ups driving the discussion, and they have something to say. We should all listen. Who knows whether we will one day look on the students’ activism as a tipping point for seismic change? For now, there’s no denying their movement is extraordinary and is reverberating...
Commentary: Austin sick leave policy another cleanup for Legislature
Commentary: Austin sick leave policy another cleanup for Legislature

Once again, the Austin City Council has decided to run the city’s private businesses instead of the city of Austin. If it isn’t careful, it’s going to run those private businesses right out of town, like it did to Uber. Thankfully, the Texas Legislature stepped in on the ride-hailing issue. And while mandatory paid sick leave for...
Herman: Progressing toward a better way of picking judges?
Herman: Progressing toward a better way of picking judges?

It’s good that the Texas Legislature created a new and needed state district court for civil matters here in Travis County. Now comes the hard part: We, the voters, must pick a judge for the court. Admit it. We’re not always really good at that. It’s not that we don’t want to do our civic duty and do our homework and pick a...
Facebook comments: Feb. 25, 2018

As reported by the American-Statesman’s Nancy Flores, retired Judge Bob Perkins and his nonprofit group, Justice for Menchaca, got a step closer to its goal of changing street signs on Manchaca Road. Perkins says Texas Revolutionary captain José Antonio Menchaca is the true namesake of the road, and recently Austin City Council Member...
Austin author offers tips on how you can be a better writer
Austin author offers tips on how you can be a better writer

This month’s Statesman Selects is a little different. Usually, we highlight a work of fiction or nonfiction — something with some sort of narrative. This month’s Selects is, well, a textbook. An incredibly cool textbook. In “The Writer’s Field Guide to the Craft of Fiction,” Austin author (and program director for...
More Stories