State fire marshal discusses lessons learned a year after West fertilizer explosion


One year ago Thursday, a fire in a wood-frame building at the West Fertilizer Co. caused about 30 tons of ammonium nitrate to explode. The explosion killed 15 people in West, a farming town near Waco, and caused more than $100 million in property damage.

State Fire Marshal Chris Connealy has been leading the effort to try to prevent another deadly disaster like the one in West. He’s been meeting with owners of fertilizer businesses to discuss their handling of ammonium nitrate, and in December he began touring dozens of towns statewide with fertilizer facilities to preach “best practices” for safely storing ammonium nitrate.

We met with Connealy last week. Excerpts of our conversation, edited for length and clarity, follow:

American-Statesman: The anniversary of the West fertilizer explosion is upon us. What lessons did we learn from West?

Chris Connealy: We’ve got to keep fire from ammonium nitrate. The problem is, when you have ammonium nitrate in a combustible structure, you’re not going to keep it from fire unless you have fire sprinklers, or you make the ammonium nitrate storage bin out of concrete, masonry, metal, something that doesn’t burn.

Certainly when you talk about fire sprinklers, those are costly, and in many of these places that store ammonium nitrate, they don’t have a water distribution system. And these are businesses that operate on a very slim margin. You need to consider what is the least costly approach to still follow best practices. And to me building a concrete structure, say for example, is much more cost effective. And I’m not talking about the whole building. It’s just for the ammonium nitrate.

We’ve also done quite a bit of research to identify where ammonium nitrate is stored. Presently we’re at 96 facilities. Of the 96 facilities, 46 store ammonium nitrate in combustible construction — wood-frame structures that can catch fire.

What is the status of the investigation into the fire that caused the explosion?

The fire investigation is still ongoing. We’re still following leads. We still have three issues in play: the 120-volt electrical system, the battery-powered golf cart and incendiary.

Arson?

Yes.

Are you hopeful that you’ll find the cause of the fire?

I’m hopeful. I’m not guaranteeing that we’ll get there. We know where the fire originated, in the seed room. The fire traveled due to combustibles in the room — it was a wood-frame building and there were all types of wood products and paper that could catch fire. The fire traveled to the ammonium nitrate bin in the room. The bin was made out of plywood and lumber. That caught on fire. It made the ammonium nitrate unstable.

Then when the wood structure that supported the roof burned away — there actually were two explosions in West. We found this during our investigation. When the roof collapses into the pile of ammonium nitrate, that was a shock factor, basically like a detonator. When the roof collapsed, you see an explosion occurring, then milliseconds later you saw the big explosion.

Your office is limited in what it can do to enforce safety. So you’re relying on your powers of persuasion to get facilities to change voluntarily. How would you rate those powers so far?

It’s not from a lack of effort, but has anyone moved the ammonium nitrate to a noncombustible structure or put sprinklers in? No.

Do you think success will come?

Well, I think that’s what the Legislature is considering. We’re not trying to put these fertilizer facilities out of business. Just the opposite. We’re trying to keep them in business. The West fertilizer plant is gone. Those jobs are gone. The farmers are having to go much farther to get the fertilizer they need. So we’re trying to convince them this is self-preservation.

Do you have hope the Legislature will require some changes?

I feel very good that there’s going to be something coming out that is going to reduce the risk exposure significantly. That’s above my decision-making, though. That’s a policy issue. But we are being tasked along with other state agencies as a resource to help legislators formulate that public policy.

How concerned are you about the possibility of another West?

There are a number of potential Wests out there. Not to be alarmist, but because 46 facilities store ammonium nitrate in wood-frame construction, a similar construction that West had, if a fire were to happen inside that structure, it could travel to the ammonium nitrate bin and do the exact same thing. I think it’s very important that we find means of addressing that to prevent another West. That’s our sole mission here, to prevent another West.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Commentary: Helping immigrants should not mean denying them care
Commentary: Helping immigrants should not mean denying them care

The immigrant community is deeply committed to the values that this country works to uphold — values that brought many of us to this nation. The idea of the United States as a beacon for those fleeing persecution is deeply held by many communities, including many of those who come to the United States seeking a better life for themselves and...
Letters to the editor: Oct. 15, 2017

Re: Sept. 24 article, “Is Austin the landlocked surf capital of the world? Some say yes.” A recent Statesman article highlighted an inland surfing park in Austin that doesn’t rely on boats. It would be great if all the wake surfers on Lake Austin were to take their sport over to the surfing park. Wake surfing relies on really big...
Letters to the editor: Oct. 19, 2017

Re: Oct. 16 article, “CodeNext: Is Austin doing enough to reach out to non-English speakers?” Why translate? If anyone wants to live in the U.S., let them learn the talk of the country. Last I heard, here it was still English. If I moved to Mexico, do you think that they would print everything in English? Of course not. When my ancestors...
Commentary: Let’s build global consensus for reconnecting with nature
Commentary: Let’s build global consensus for reconnecting with nature

During the past few weeks, millions of people around the Gulf of Mexico have experienced the fury of Mother Nature. Four massive hurricanes and two earthquakes have devastated numerous communities. It is humbling to realize that despite enormous technical advancements, we are still as much at the mercy of nature’s wrath as the Teotihuacanos in...
Commentary: Why Hartnett White is dangerous for environmental council
Commentary: Why Hartnett White is dangerous for environmental council

With each new appointee to the Trump administration, it’s like the president is trolling us. Put someone who sued the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 14 times in charge of the agency? Check. Appoint a man who wanted to eliminate the Department of Energy as its head? Check. But you ain’t seen nothing yet. Trump’s newest choice...
More Stories