Commentary: Why the Kemp’s ridley turtle could lose more Gulf habitat


This spring, I worked with community volunteers to locate and protect the nests of Kemp’s ridley sea turtles. I got down on my hands and knees, dug out nests and held rare turtle eggs in my hands.

This species of sea turtle almost vanished forever. Due to their incidental capture in fishing gear, a commercial trade, and theft of eggs on nesting beaches, their population plummeted. We were so close to losing them — but through a binational effort this species was saved.

From beach protections to fishing closures, we gave the heart-shaped Kemp’s what it needed for this iconic Gulf species to fight back from the brink of extinction - a true success story.

PAM LEBLANC: Read about her adventure transplanting sea turtles at South Padre Island.

One thing our endangered Texas sea turtles do not need is a giant coastal wall interfering with their nesting. Sea turtles need our beaches to find places to nest. What will happen to our sandy beaches if the proposed Ike Dike is built? There is a limited amount of sand, making it impossible to artificially maintain this structure.

We recognize the real threats associated with sea level rise, storm surges and hurricanes to our coast. We also recognize the need for solutions. However, the Ike Dike is not the solution and its legacy in the end will be a project that creates unforeseen environmental and ecological damage and a tax bill for Texans of monumental size.

And that’s why Turtle Island Restoration Network opposes the Ike Dike and urges government officials to explore other options that are most cost-effective, defend the coast and protect our natural resources.

The Ike Dike, a giant unnatural barrier, will irreparably damage the coast. We will lose habitat for wildlife including endangered sea turtles like the Kemp’s ridley as well as shoreline birds. A giant sea wall will reduce the economic value of recreation activities and impact important tourist dollars.

Contrary to what its supporters are arguing, we believe the Ike Dike will fail to prevent damage from catastrophic events. It is not engineered based on worst-case scenario modeling and will not prevent chemical spills in the Houston Ship Channel. There are approximately 4600 above ground storage tanks, mostly with hazardous materials along the shores of the Houston Ship Channel, and the Ike Dike would not protect these tanks from a storm surge.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Viewpoints page brings the latest commentaries to your feed.

We also believe the Ike Dike will permanently change the natural functioning of our bays. Are we ready to face reduced circulation, decreased salinity and the impediment on fish and shellfish migration? The end result would be decreased shrimp and oyster stocks and the potential destruction of our excellent fishery in the bay system.

Maarten Ruijs at Deft University wrote his thesis on Galveston Bay and stated the following: “The amount and diversity of the living resources in the bay is on its turn dependent on the availability of habitats, water quality and other parameters. Disturbances in the food chain could result in the extinction or abundance of species, considering both flora and fauna”.

We believe that the costs of the Ike Dike have been grossly underestimated, both in terms of construction and ongoing maintenance. How much will it cost to manage and maintain? And who will foot these bills? Texans in the form of increased taxes and special fees.

Turtle Island believes in the need to simultaneously protect wildlife, natural resources, and communities from the risks associated with sea level rise, storm surges, and hurricanes. We believe that there are better and more cost effective ways to meet these needs.

We strongly urge Texans to explore other options to address sea level rise, storm surges, and hurricanes through natural defenses such as the Lone Star Recreation Area and living shorelines.

Joanie Steinhaus, of Galveston, is the Gulf Office director of Turtle Island Restoration Network.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

TWO VIEWS: Democracy? Bag it, say the Republicans
TWO VIEWS: Democracy? Bag it, say the Republicans

The urgent love Texas Republicans feel for plastic bags is a mystery. Let’s look, though. Maybe there’s a clue in the trail left by former Texas congressman Tom Loeffler all the way back in the 1980s. The game is afoot — literally. As a candidate for governor back in 1986, Loeffler confessed that he had worn plastic shower caps on...
Letters to the editor: Jan. 22, 2018

Re: Jan. 18 article, “Expo Center trimmed from PSV’s list of Austin MLS stadium sites.” The possibility of Butler Shores being decimated for a soccer stadium worries me. I am absolutely against such a move. These negotiations appear to be similar to the bullying of Austin that Uber and Lyft attempted. Butler Shores, at the confluence...
TWO VIEWS: Why Supreme Court should rule against bag ban
TWO VIEWS: Why Supreme Court should rule against bag ban

Shoppers might soon discover that the grocery store is less expensive and more convenient. Two weeks ago, the Texas Supreme Court heard oral arguments in a case questioning the legitimacy of municipal bans on plastic bags. If justices reaffirm an appellate court ruling, consumers will be unburdened from this clear example of government overreach. At...
Opinion: What is the real message of #MeToo?

The feminist website Babe published an account of a date gone bad. The pushback has been swift and sharp. I share some of the concerns of the critics, but I also think young women are sending a message that is being missed. The account by the anonymous “Grace” about a bad date with comedian Aziz Ansari was, if not “3,000 words of...
Lacking minorities, state boards are ill-prepared to serve all Texans
Lacking minorities, state boards are ill-prepared to serve all Texans

Gov. Greg Abbott should look at fairness, justice and best practices — along with qualifications — in making appointments to state boards and commissions. Given his record, that clearly is not happening. If those measures were used, Abbott’s appointments would better reflect the ethnic, racial and gender diversity of Texas. They don&rsquo...
More Stories