Commentary: Why congressional tax plans would crush scholarship funds


Today, U.S. government leaders have enormous decisions to make about tax reform. Their choices will affect the future of our students and our universities. If the proposed policies are put in place, the ability of Texas students — both now and in the future — to earn life-changing degrees will be compromised.

We are the presidents of two universities in Texas — one public, one private. Many students from both the University of Texas and Trinity University rely upon financial aid that is drawn from endowments.

Both the House and Senate bills that are now being resolved by a conference committee propose a 1.4-percent excise tax on certain private nonprofit university endowments. This puts the college educations of many current and prospective students at risk — and it jeopardizes the financial stability of many private universities. The recent Senate vote on the tax bill brought Congress one step closer to enacting this and other policy changes that will have dire impacts on affordability at all American universities.

POLITICS: What to know about the Senate tax bill overhaul.

At a time when we face increases in economic and scientific competition around the globe, lawmakers should work to expand access to higher education. An educated and highly skilled American workforce benefits everyone. It is our responsibility to ensure we maintain our global leadership role. Unfortunately, both the House and Senate tax bills counteract our national effort to do just that.

Endowments are a critical source of student financial aid. Universities across the U.S. provided $54.7 billion in grant aid to their students in 2015-16, much of it from endowment investment funds. In fact, the institutions affected by the proposed tax are among those providing the most-generous financial aid from their own resources, including endowment funds. At many of these schools, grant aid spending is 20 times the total amount that students receive from federal programs like Pell Grants, which are capped at $5,920 per award year.

Trinity University is one of these schools; it spends more than $50 million on student financial aid each year, with endowment funds supporting 95 percent of students. This aid is possible thanks to generous donations by private individuals who believe in the proven value of higher education. Trinity then invests those gifts and uses the returns to help low-income students finance higher education. If enacted, this tax would take away aid from more than 70 Trinity students each year — or, to echo the words of Vanderbilt University Chancellor Nicholas Zeppos, it would send, in effect, 70 need-based student scholarships directly to the federal government.

RELATED: UT seeking 2-percent increase in tuition in 2018, and again in 2019.

Beyond the direct impacts to students and their hardworking families, this tax would set a dangerous precedent in nonprofit tax policy. Public universities such as UT are rightfully concerned.

Every year, UT relies on the generosity of private donors to fund scholarships for thousands of students in a wide range of schools and colleges. These are transformative gifts that reshape the academic experience on our campus. This kind of giving is made possible through proper investment of endowment funds. If the new tax on private nonprofit universities were levied on public nonprofit universities, many UT scholarship programs and others like them would decrease dramatically or disappear completely.

Taxing private university endowments will harm students throughout Texas by making college less accessible and less affordable.

Higher education has brought our nation to the forefront of scientific discovery, propelled our economy and made the U.S. the flourishing country it is today. America’s high-quality pre-eminent private universities — part of the lifeblood of a strong economy — should be celebrated and championed for their contributions to America’s scientific and economic health, not punished with debilitating government taxation.

We urge House and Senate lawmakers to consider the long-term consequences of their policies as they make final edits to this important tax bill. The future of students in Texas and across the U.S. depends on it.

Fenves is the president of the University of Texas. Anderson is the president of Trinity University.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

TWO VIEWS: Democracy? Bag it, say the Republicans
TWO VIEWS: Democracy? Bag it, say the Republicans

The urgent love Texas Republicans feel for plastic bags is a mystery. Let’s look, though. Maybe there’s a clue in the trail left by former Texas congressman Tom Loeffler all the way back in the 1980s. The game is afoot — literally. As a candidate for governor back in 1986, Loeffler confessed that he had worn plastic shower caps on...
Letters to the editor: Jan. 22, 2018

Re: Jan. 18 article, “Expo Center trimmed from PSV’s list of Austin MLS stadium sites.” The possibility of Butler Shores being decimated for a soccer stadium worries me. I am absolutely against such a move. These negotiations appear to be similar to the bullying of Austin that Uber and Lyft attempted. Butler Shores, at the confluence...
TWO VIEWS: Why Supreme Court should rule against bag ban
TWO VIEWS: Why Supreme Court should rule against bag ban

Shoppers might soon discover that the grocery store is less expensive and more convenient. Two weeks ago, the Texas Supreme Court heard oral arguments in a case questioning the legitimacy of municipal bans on plastic bags. If justices reaffirm an appellate court ruling, consumers will be unburdened from this clear example of government overreach. At...
Opinion: What is the real message of #MeToo?

The feminist website Babe published an account of a date gone bad. The pushback has been swift and sharp. I share some of the concerns of the critics, but I also think young women are sending a message that is being missed. The account by the anonymous “Grace” about a bad date with comedian Aziz Ansari was, if not “3,000 words of...
Lacking minorities, state boards are ill-prepared to serve all Texans
Lacking minorities, state boards are ill-prepared to serve all Texans

Gov. Greg Abbott should look at fairness, justice and best practices — along with qualifications — in making appointments to state boards and commissions. Given his record, that clearly is not happening. If those measures were used, Abbott’s appointments would better reflect the ethnic, racial and gender diversity of Texas. They don&rsquo...
More Stories