Commentary: Why America’s health can’t afford any budget cuts to CDC


Why are President Trump’s proposed cuts to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention such a bad idea? One big reason is that they are on the forefront of what Dr. Tom Frieden, former CDC director, rightly called “one of our most serious health threats” — killer antibiotic-resistant bacteria.

A 2013 CDC report found that antibiotic-resistant bacteria, aka “superbugs,” infect millions of Americans per year and kill at least 23,000 of us annually. Four years later, experts say those numbers have likely grown.

Losing effective antibiotics as a tool in medicine — a somber reality in some cases already — means common infections will once again kill. Medical advancements like cancer treatment, routine surgeries and organ transplants become much more dangerous.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Viewpoints page brings the latest commentaries to your feed.

So, the CDC should, if anything, increase spending to address the “superbug” crisis, yet the president’s proposed budget would result in a 17-percent cut.

The CDC uses its funding in three key ways to address antibiotic resistance: detecting and responding quickly to superbug outbreaks; implementing better protocols to prevent infections from superbugs; and improving antibiotic stewardship to keep the bugs from becoming “super” in the first place.

Much of the funding at stake goes to state-specific initiatives that help prevent a local or statewide disease outbreak from becoming a national epidemic.

In Fiscal Year 2016, Texas received $3.7 million from the CDC through its initiatives on antibiotic resistance to fund rapid response units tasked with protecting Texans from fast-moving and deadly superbugs.

Identifying and containing a disease outbreak has serious implications for public health. MRSA is an antibiotic-resistant bacteria that can have lethal consequences, especially for patients with weakened immune systems. Last April, the LA Times reported on a MRSA outbreak at the UC Irvine Medical Center. As doctors struggled to find the source of the infections, the outbreak continued to spread, eventually infecting 10 infants who were already seriously ill.

In a different case, a Nevada woman recently died from an infection that health experts have deemed the “nightmare bacteria,” known in shorthand as CRE. That’s because this particular form of bacteria was resistant to every antibiotic available in the U.S.

Whether it’s a MRSA infection or the “nightmare bacteria,” it is critical for health authorities to be able to identify the particular type of bacteria causing the illness so that they can properly treat it, if possible, and contain its spread.

The CDC’s programs give state and regional health departments the kind of state-of-the-art technology needed to detect, track and contain a superbug. Without it, they’d be flying blind in responding to an outbreak, which would put more lives at risk.

VIEWPOINTS: The Statesman’s editorial board tackles local and national issues.

Perhaps more important than containing a dangerous outbreak is getting at the root cause of what fuels drug-resistant bacteria. The overuse of antibiotics in any setting makes the drugs less effective. CDC’s programs include efforts to track antibiotic use in health care settings and cut down on inappropriate use that may be breeding drug-resistant bacteria. Funding cuts to antibiotic stewardship efforts will be a major setback in preventing the spread of superbugs.

As Trump and budget negotiators in the House and Senate move forward with the budget process, they should keep in mind that what’s at stake is the health and safety of our loved ones.

We certainly cannot afford to lose any resources in the fight to combat antibiotic resistance. A wiser course would be to invest more in the fight to keep our antibiotics working.

Scoggin is the state director of the Texas Public Interest Research Group.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Letters to the editor: Jan. 20, 2018

It is appalling the disrespect being shown to President Trump. The left, liberals and Democrats have turned a blind eye to the corrupt leadership shown during the eight years of Obama and the Democrats. President Trump has done very well so far. It is very apparent that the Democratic party’s leadership does not want Trump to succeed and they...
Affordable credit is essential to a growing middle class
Affordable credit is essential to a growing middle class

U.S. Rep. Henry Cuellar, a Democrat who represents deep southern Texas, understands what it means to live paycheck to paycheck. His parents were migrant workers who sometimes traveled from Laredo to Idaho for jobs. He also understands the value of hard work. With a master’s, J.D., and Ph.D., he’s “the most degreed member of Congress...
Commentary: Where will technology take the arts?
Commentary: Where will technology take the arts?

Every new technology changes how we find and experience art and entertainment, for better and worse. Today, as streaming becomes the dominant delivery mode for creative content, a new world of instant, global, direct connection between artists and their fans is at hand. The potential is glorious — ease of access, openness, a search for new content...
Herman: The Kiddie Acres carousel spins again
Herman: The Kiddie Acres carousel spins again

Back in July I told you that after about four decades and countless birthday parties, Joe and Marina Herring were retiring and closing their Kiddie Acres, a small North Austin amusement park that has a special place in the our town’s collective memory bank. I told you the rides were being auctioned. And in September, I told you that ...
Facebook comments: Jan. 19, 2018

As reported by the American-Statesman’s Jonathan Tilove, Gov. Greg Abbott has unveiled the centerpiece of his re-election campaign: His property tax reform plan. It would cap revenue increases for local taxing entities at 2.5 percent a year. “Under the plan I am announcing today, Texas will take action to limit property tax growth, secure...
More Stories