Commentary: Keep Texas economy strong by updating — not replacing — NAFTA


You may have heard the adage, “As Texas goes, so goes the nation.”

It often refers to the state’s ability to set the national agenda thanks to our size, unique way of doing business and bold politics. However, this saying might now serve as a cautionary tale as our nation’s leaders test the important relationship we share with Mexico.

In recent months, harsh rhetoric in Washington, D.C., has painted Mexico as a competitor rather than an ally — a trade foe rather than a partner. These characterizations are wrong and threaten Texas and national interests.

GUEST COMMENTARY: Without globalization, adios ‘Texas miracle.’

The financial ties that connect us with Mexico are symbiotic, not parasitic. After all, Mexico is Texas’ top trading partner with about $173 billion in trade a year. Additionally, trade with Mexico supports about 463,000 jobs and thousands of small businesses and manufacturers in Texas.

We not only sell to each other, we build things together. Roughly 40 percent of all goods imported from Mexico consist of parts that originated in the United States. By comparison, only 4 percent of products imported from China have U.S. origin.

Studies show that when U.S. companies grow their workforce in Mexico, they also grow their American workforce, increase their exports and spend more domestically on research and development. For those of us who live, work and do business along the U.S.-Mexico border, we see these benefits firsthand.

These realities are often lost in less-nuanced political rhetoric. Short-term thinking on U.S.-Mexico relations will lead to long-term negative consequences for American workers and businesses. The recent pivoting on the North America Free Trade Agreement by President Donald Trump exemplifies the importance of our economic relationship with Mexico.

While Trump has called NAFTA the worst trade deal in history, we must acknowledge the benefits it has brought to states like Texas and the nation as a whole. NAFTA supports 5 million jobs across the U.S. — and by one economist’s estimate, it enriches the U.S. by $127 billion anually. Texas’ exports to Mexico have grown by 354 percent since NAFTA, far outpacing export growth in other states and the nation as a whole. Texas also enjoys a $12 billion trade surplus with Mexico.

VIEWPOINTS: The Statesman’s editorial writers and columnists tackle local and national issues.

There are certainly ways in which NAFTA could be updated — the original agreement predated much of the technological advances of the last quarter century — but this should be done in the spirit of cooperation, not antagonism. In fact, if we focus on the growing energy and technology markets as a region, we could become stronger competitors in the global economy.

The administration’s latest signaling not to terminate NAFTA is a move in the right direction and an opportunity for business and elected leaders in Texas. Our state sees the benefits of collaborating with our southern neighbor by building regional supply chains and innovating together to compete globally. We can shape the national agenda once again by influencing the outcomes of an updated trade agreement and how we define our economic relationship with Mexico.

Barela is chief executive officer of the Borderplex Alliance, a binational economic development agency promoting the economic growth of El Paso, Ciudad Juarez and Southern New Mexico.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Herman: Mars’ role in the future of Texas public education
Herman: Mars’ role in the future of Texas public education

Mars, people. The solution to what is always the biggest challenge our state faces will come from Mars. Or, says a leading state lawmaker, from people who make believe they’re from Mars. The suggestion came in inspiring and instructive remarks made late Tuesday by state Sen. John Whitmire, D-Houston, as the special legislative session approached...
Commentary: Why the Nazis came to Charlottesville
Commentary: Why the Nazis came to Charlottesville

“Should we go downtown?” my wife asked over breakfast on Thursday. “Remember, after the election, when we said we would stand with our neighbors when they were threatened? Are we being true to our commitments?” For weeks, we had read reports from white supremacist groups that they were coming here by the hundreds or thousands...
Opinion: Heaven comes with blisters, poison ivy and mosquitos

ON THE PACIFIC CREST TRAIL, Calif. — This will make me sound grouchy and misanthropic, but I sometimes wonder if what makes America great isn’t so much its people as its trees and mountains. In contrast to many advanced countries, we have a vast and spectacular publicly owned wilderness, mostly free and available to all. The affluent have...
Letters to the editor: Aug. 17, 2017

Officer William DeWayne Jones Sr. was shot and killed on Robert E. Lee Road while performing a routine traffic stop. He gave up his life for the residents of Austin. The person who shot him had an arrest warrant for sexual assault. Jones served with dignity, courage and honor; an African-American who wore the badge, he was a real Texas hero. I ask...
Commentary: Undoing racism is uncomfortable. Suing colleges won’t help
Commentary: Undoing racism is uncomfortable. Suing colleges won’t help

The Supreme Court ruled last summer that colleges and universities can use race as one factor among many in making admissions decisions. The court determined that such policies helped further an institution’s mission to attain the educational benefits of diversity. The Trump administration may be considering a “project” to direct...
More Stories