Commentary: GOP must be smart on how to roll back federal regulations


It seems clear that in the coming years of Republican control many federal regulatory protections will be rolled back. No doubt some Americans voted for Donald Trump because of his broad, nonspecific campaign promises to relieve companies of the burden of complying with federal regulations.

But his supporters may be in for a surprise.

Take, for example, the April 17, 2013, fire at the West Fertilizer Co.’s fertilizer blending and distribution facility in West. The fire led to an enormous explosion that killed 15 people, hospitalized 260 others, destroyed the plant and damaged 150 nearby buildings.

The fuel for the blast was 40 to 60 tons of highly explosive fertilizer-grade ammonium nitrate stored at the facility.

The explosion had many causes, but one contributor was the government’s failure to protect Texans from the huge bomb that was primed to explode in the middle of McLennan County.

A comprehensive investigation of the explosion by the U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board concluded that the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s (OSHA) efforts to oversee facilities that stored and handled ammonium nitrate prior to the explosion “fell short.”

OSHA could have prevented the tragedy if its standards for explosives and blasting agents had been clearer and if it had not inadvertently omitted ammonium nitrate from the list of chemicals covered by its Process Safety Management standards.

And it would have helped if agency inspectors had visited the facility more frequently than the one time that they inspected it nearly 30 years ago — in 1985.

President Barack Obama responded to the tragedy with an August 2013 executive order requiring OSHA, the Department of Homeland Security and the Environmental Protection Agency to come up with a plan to improve safety and security regulations for facilities that manufacture, store and distribute explosive chemicals.

OSHA then summarized its regulations on its blog and told its inspectors that fertilizer facilities storing ammonium nitrate were in fact covered by the regulation. It added that bins made of wood are acceptable — so long as the wood is treated with an impermeable coating.

Earlier this year, the Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board recommended that the agency go further to include ammonium nitrate in its stringent Process Safety Management regulations, or that it amend its explosives and blasting standard to clarify that it applies to agricultural chemical facilities, requires storage bins to be composed of noncombustible material and requires sprinkler systems in all such facilities.

But here is where the rubber meets the road.

The anti-regulation agenda that Trump and other Republicans promised, and that many McLennan County voters seem to favor, will probably block these kinds of safety rules needed to protect against future disasters.

Any attempt to make the regulations more protective would also encounter a firestorm of opposition from the fertilizer industry and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, which would argue that more protective regulations will put small companies out of business and destroy jobs.

In the meantime, the president-elect has already promised to revoke President Obama’s chemical safety executive order. And it is highly unlikely that the new Congress will appropriate more funds for OSHA enforcement.

OSHA is also reluctant to implement the recommendation because it would require a yearslong rulemaking process that has become so cumbersome and expensive that the agency avoids it whenever possible. It would have to prepare an extensive cost-benefit analysis that would have to be approved by the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs before it could publish regulations for public comment.

In truth, the proposed recommendations are quite modest as regulatory protections go, and compliance would not be especially burdensome for local fertilizer blending and distribution facilities like the one in West. An OSHA regulation implementing those recommendations would not be an example of regulatory overreach or a “bureaucracy run amok.” It would be a sensible response to a serious problem that has slipped through the cracks.

Rural Americans need to tell the incoming administration that when they voted for change, they did not vote to roll back health, safety and environmental laws that protect them from explosions and other hazards that threaten their communities.

McGarity is a professor in the School of Law at the University of Texas.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Celeste Ng’s second novel strikingly illuminates life in America
Celeste Ng’s second novel strikingly illuminates life in America

Celeste Ng’s “Little Fires Everywhere” is an incandescent portrait of suburbia and family, creativity, and consumerism burns bright. It’s not for nothing that Ng (“Everything I Never Told You,” 2014) begins her second novel, about the events leading to the burning of the home of an outwardly perfect-seeming family...
Why Longmire doesn’t — and wouldn’t — carry a cellphone
Why Longmire doesn’t — and wouldn’t — carry a cellphone

People ask me why my protagonist, Walt Longmire, doesn’t carry a cellphone, and my immediate response is: Have you ever been to Wyoming? With more than 97,000 square miles, the state is divided into 23 counties, some of them as large as Maryland but none of them named Absaroka. Taking a cue from Faulkner, I decided to go with a fictional county...
Letters to the editor: Sept. 24, 2017

Re: Sept. 17 commentary, “Sanders’ drug plan puts Texas patients, companies in peril.” I read the commentary by Russell Withers. Typical dialog of big pharma, a group of corporations who seem to think they can pick prices out of the air. Oh yes, the free market will solve this. My question is how? The doctor writes a prescription...
Ken Follett’s new release dominates best-sellers lists
Ken Follett’s new release dominates best-sellers lists

NEW YORK TIMES BEST-SELLERS FICTION 1. ‘A Column of Fire,’ Ken Follett 2. ‘The Girl Who Takes an Eye for an Eye,’ David Lagercrantz 3. ‘Enemy of the State,’ Kyle Mills 4. ‘The Romanov Ransom,’ Clive Cussler and Robin Burcell 5. ‘A Legacy of Spies,’ John le Carré 6. ‘Secrets in...
Commentary: Congress must reauthorize proven family support program
Commentary: Congress must reauthorize proven family support program

This summer, throughout Houston and Texas’ Gulf Coast, many families struggled. They were in a desperate situation, isolated, not knowing where to find relief, needing someone to throw them a lifeline. And that was before Hurricane Harvey. Following the storm, the previously precarious existence of these Texans is now exponentially worsened by...
More Stories