Commentary: End Texas’ long history of abusing juveniles in detention


Ten years ago, I published a commentary in this newspaper on the physical and sexual abuse of youth in Texas’ juvenile correctional facilities. Noting that adult officials had participated in or sanctioned the abuse of youth placed in their care, I warned that the state had traveled this path several times before. Today’s reports sadly echo the lurid inventory of abuses that has characterized juvenile correctional facilities in Texas over the past century.

Indeed, the Gainesville State School has a checkered history. Founded in 1915 to serve delinquent girls, Gainesville has been investigated by state authorities repeatedly since its inception. A series of abuse scandals in the late 1930s culminated in the firing of the superintendent amid allegations of physical abuse, “deplorable” living conditions, and a “non-existent” educational program. In 1952, a 16-year-old girl from Houston escaped from Gainesville having “cracked from the strain” of serving nearly 200 consecutive days in solitary confinement.

HOW WE GOT HERE: Gov. Abbott says Rangers to investigate sex abuse reports in youth lockup.

Most notoriously, during the discovery phase of a class-action lawsuit in the 1970s, investigators discovered the use of part-time mental health professionals, overuse of psychotropic drugs, and punishments meted out disproportionately against black and Latina inmates. At the largest state facility for boys, staff routinely staged fights between inmates for their own amusement, a practice that has resurfaced in today’s allegations. The 1970s lawsuit also uncovered how prison-like institutions could frustrate the intentions of even well-trained, well-meaning professional staff, forcing them to focus on control and order rather than education and treatment.

That lawsuit, Morales v. Turman, transformed juvenile corrections in Texas for a generation. Thousands of youth were returned to their communities — and the two largest juvenile facilities were shut down. More fundamentally, Texas began to support community-based diversion and rehabilitation programs for the first time. The revolution, however, was unfinished because it left some large, prison-like, remotely located facilities intact.

As a result, when a national panic over so-called “superpredators” erupted a generation later, politicians could point to the need to build more “youth prisons” as a solution. We now know that the cure was far worse than the disease. Violent youth crime, predicted to increase, instead dropped precipitously by the early 2000s, while episodes of abuse in juvenile facilities once again began to skyrocket.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest insight on current events.

In 2007, the public confronted the painful results of a long history of failed or half-completed policy choices. Once again, as in the 1970s, officials sought to shutter the facilities that had served as incubators of abuse. And once again, they ran into opposition from local populations and their elected representatives who worried about the economic impact and about mass layoffs of staff. As a result, some facilities, such as the notorious Victory Field boot camp and the older Corsicana facility, were shut down in the face of local protest, while others, such as Gainesville, were left untouched.

Politicians have halted attempts to shut down notorious juvenile facilities repeatedly since at least the 1940s. Indeed, the core principle in such decisions was best captured by a citizens group during the 1947 legislative session, when they offered to speak out “any time the best interest of the institution was at stake” – a revealing play on the founding principle of juvenile justice, which places “the best interests of the child” at its center.

It is long past time for our leaders to stop putting the best interests of abusive and failing institutions over the needs of our children and youth. The historical evidence is overwhelming and incontrovertible. We can, and must, do better.

Bush is an associate professor of history at Texas A&M University-San Antonio.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Trump, meet a hero whom you maligned

In 1885, a poor, uneducated 16-year-old boy arrived in our country from Germany at a time when immigrants were often looked down on by affluent Americans. This boy was ambitious and entrepreneurial, and, despite language problems, he earned some money and then traveled up to the Klondike during the gold rush to operate a hotel that became notorious...
Herman: Your governor needs even more money
Herman: Your governor needs even more money

Today, it is my sad duty to come to you with a tale of greed, avarice and Possibly Everything That’s Wrong With America. It comes in the form of two emails that hit my inbox within hours of each other. One came from our governor and the other came on behalf of our governor, a man with an insatiable desire to get some money out of your pocket...
ANALYSIS: Trump doesn’t understand Haiti, immigration nor U.S. history
ANALYSIS: Trump doesn’t understand Haiti, immigration nor U.S. history

Donald Trump’s denigrating comments about Haiti during a recent congressional meeting shocked people around the globe, but given his track record of disrespecting immigrants, they were not actually that surprising. Despite campaign promises that Trump would be Haiti’s “biggest champion,” his administration had...
Opinion: Republicans must lead in upcoming abortion debate

This year, as every year, I will be joining the hundreds of thousands who will be arriving in Washington, D.C., for the March for Life, noting the anniversary of the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision, which legalized abortion on demand in our country. The event has taken place every year since 1973 and will continue to take place every year until this disastrous...
John Young: Real meaning for that red ball cap
John Young: Real meaning for that red ball cap

Wherever he resides in the afterlife, George Carlin is having a bleeping good time. One of the comedian’s “seven words you can’t say on TV” is being said on TV over and over again – starts with “sh” and features “it” — and getting bleeped, or someone is attempting a weak euphemism. The thing...
More Stories