Close: Future of Black Friday is a hybrid; call it ‘Black Weekend’

Black Friday got its name because it historically has been the day when many retailers’ accounting books have gone from “the red,” or losses, to “the black,” or profits. But we may as well start calling it Black Weekend these days as Black Friday increasingly merges with Cyber Monday.

Black Friday traditionally has been a day of mostly in-person shopping. In fact, Black Friday is the biggest in-person spending day of the year; Cyber Monday is the biggest online spending day of the year. In-person spending clearly trumps online spending on Black Friday. Last year, consumers spent $50.9 billion in-store on Black Friday, while spending $1.5 billion online. Yet, Cyber Monday, the Monday after Black Friday, reached $2 billion in 2014, which was up 17 percent from the previous year.

Why do these numbers matter? Because the future of Black Friday, or rather Black Weekend, will be a hybrid. It will blend consumers’ online and offline shopping experiences.

Black Friday will remain a vibrant day in American shopping, but it will be different and almost unrecognizable. It will become a hybrid in different ways: It will blend with Cyber Monday, and it will become Black Weekend due to the “holiday creep.”

In the future, consumer behavior will be blended between online or mobile environments and in-store environments. Retailers and storefronts will have more kiosks and tablet/mobile-based online shopping platforms to help the consumer. These technological advances will coincide along with the role of the retail salesperson. Smart stores will give the consumer an option of interacting with a salesperson, technology or both.

“Holiday creep” refers to merchandise and advertising for a holiday starting a bit earlier each year. I documented this phenomenon in a five-year study of Valentine’s Day, which showed that consumers will resist an entire market when they feel that a holiday consumption tradition is forced and market-constructed to a point where commercialism outshines the purpose of a tradition.

Holiday creep does produce some consumer resistance, and shoppers could back off of spending as a result. If the holiday creep continues with Black Weekend, it may breed an environment that advertisers and retailers should note as ripe for ensuing market resistance, which is not beneficial for our economy in terms of sales and jobs.

There is also another dark side to Black Friday: Online deals sell out and website traffic can cause a site to slow or crash. Online browsing and spending by consumers also will continue to creep in to the in-person store experience. Even with $50.9 billion of in-store sales last year, there are issues with store crowding. An extreme-yet-sensationalized storyline involves injuries suffered as mobs of consumers fight over products. Stores can be too packed, and the crowds are not worth fighting.

Some see Black Friday as the day when people need to rise early to get good deals, but the analytics show that most consumers actually spend the most in stores around 1:30 p.m. and online around 9 p.m. on Cyber Monday.

A threat to Black Weekend is the proliferation of other shopping promotions and daily deal websites. When there is an influx of promotions, the traditional big sales promotions days become diluted. This is called promotion creep. Why wait for Black Weekend when marketers launch deals daily? Our consumer studies on daily deal websites show that consumers embrace daily deals yearround — just as consumers prefer small acts of love year-round rather than one market-constructed day like Valentine’s Day.

But there is a bright side that I think is underappreciated: Events bring people together, and isn’t that togetherness and community the essence of holidays in America?

The future of Black Friday will be a hybrid, a Black Weekend full of online and in-store events, and in-store events with online technology. To stay ahead, companies need to offer deals that are great, not good. They must give consumers an incentive that goes beyond the new norm of daily deals.

Angeline Close Scheinbaum is an associate professor in the Stan Richards School of Advertising and Public Relations at the University of Texas.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Commentary: Texas-size signage fuels duel among businesses, gun groups
Commentary: Texas-size signage fuels duel among businesses, gun groups

Gun extremists appear to have developed a pattern of targeting small businesses in Texas that legally elect to prohibit guns on their property. Bee Cave patisserie Baguette et Chocolat legally opted out of Texas’ concealed and open handgun carry laws by posting visible and compliant signage prohibiting the open and concealed carry of handguns...
Letters to the editor: Sept. 22, 2017

Re: Sept. 16 article, “Round Rock boy selling soap to help Hurricane Harvey survivors.” What an inspirational young man Ezekiel is! In the midst of hurricane tragedy, I hope that survivors will hear the story about Ezekiel’s compassion for them and how it led him to selfless action on their behalf. They aren’t just getting soap...
Commentary: Let’s debunk falsehoods about school choice and special ed
Commentary: Let’s debunk falsehoods about school choice and special ed

As kids begin a new school year, it’s deeply unfortunate that some of the most disadvantaged students in Texas still lack access to a quality education. When the special session for the Texas Legislature abruptly ended, the move killed two bills that would have created a tax-credit scholarship program for students with special needs. This common-sense...
Commentary: Senate health care plan creates ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’
Commentary: Senate health care plan creates ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’

Sixteen words from my doctor changed my life: “What worries me is that I think you are in the early stages of Parkinson’s disease.” I was 48 years old. Recently, I stopped by my local Walgreen’s pharmacy to pick up my Parkinson’s medication. As I waited in line, a woman told the pharmacy tech, “I absolutely have...
Opinion: Who truly imperils our free society?

“The Barbarian cannot make … he can befog and destroy but … he cannot sustain; and of every Barbarian in the decline or peril of every civilization exactly that has been true.” Hilaire Belloc’s depiction of the barbarian is recalled to mind as the statues honoring the history and heroes of the Republic and of the West...
More Stories