You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks


Welcome to

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on

Borders: Kitchen recall effort is what real democracy looks like

If you’re an elected official, be wary. The effort to recall Austin City Council Member Ann Kitchen is just the beginning. We’ve entered a new era of accountability, and, like it or not, this is what democracy looks like.

Austinites who have signed petition for Kitchen’s recall have decided the price of her paternalism is simply too high. They concluded that:

  • They want the convenience and availability ride-hailing currently offers.
  • Given the rarity of offenses by ride-hailing drivers, Kitchen’s regulations are overzealous.
  • GPS tracking and online identity protects riders better than zealous regulatory regimes — and better than taxis.
  • Onerous regulations, such as fingerprinting and its fees, raise the cost and reduce the availability of these services.
  • No one requires strangers who go home together from bars to be fingerprinted; people who use ride-hailing services are no different.
  • People who think — mistakenly — that regulated taxis are safer still have the option of taking regulated taxis.
  • Taxis have enjoyed an anti-competitive regulatory cartel for decades; that time is up.
  • The public benefits from ride-hailing services, which result in reduced incidents of drunk driving, alone far outweigh risks that drivers might present a danger to passengers.

Kitchen has argued that shadowy outside groups have organized against her and have gathered recall signatures through deception. Others claim that a recall is too costly and that policy disagreements should not be expressed through such extreme measures.

But I am not an outside group. I am a resident of Austin. Thousands like me didn’t sign the recall petition because they were duped. A successful recall will send a message to would-be municipal nannies that the people are in charge.

There was a time when democracy was a system we participated in once a year or so. Whatever came after was the best possible outcome until the next election.

Meanwhile, behind the scenes, special interest groups would woo public officials, just as they did with Kitchen.

“Campaign finance reports show (Lone Star Cab CEO Solomon Kassa) bundled $4,000 worth of campaign donations from five cab drivers and a few other people,” writes Brent Wistrom at Austin Inno, “And (he) gave it to Kitchen just days before the election in which she beat out six other candidates with 54 percent of the vote and avoided a runoff contest.”

These used to be the sorts of deals that shaped elected officials’ decisions in office, with little consequence.

At one time, the costs of such decisions would be dispersed among the people. Benefits would be concentrated on the elected officials and special interests. The politician would get elected. The special interest would get the anti-competitive regulation.

These concentrated benefits and dispersed costs made change especially difficult for citizens. Political collusion yielded big returns for political cronies.

But now the tables are turning.

“Contributions are not about favors, at all,” said Kitchen. “My responsibility is protecting the public safety of the community.”

That’s what they all say. Despite the protestations of officials like Kitchen, who claim it’s all for the public good, there are always people looking to game regulations.

It’s true that sometimes voters are not terribly well-informed about the issues that affect them. And in the past, they’ve had far less power to organize against City Hall.

Thanks to technology, citizens are now in a position to decide just how much they want to be protected — and what price they’re prepared to pay for such protection. And they’re not willing to wait out an entire election cycle to register their displeasure.

This is digital democracy.

Citizens not only feel it more acutely when politicians threaten the products and services they love, it’s simpler than ever to organize. Those who think recalls are too costly might want to think twice about asking citizens to accept costly policies.

Today, powerful constituencies of people armed with mobiles and cameras are waiting to hold police accountable and pounce on officials like Kitchen who — in the eyes of some voters — overstepped her mandate to be a steward of the public’s business.

Put another way. When we’re networked we are stronger. Networking not only helps us acquire information more readily, but to respond more easily. Public servants are now more accountable to the citizens of Austin. There is no turning back.

Borders is an advisor to the political action committee Austin4All.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Herman: 'My Cousin Vinny' and the race for State Bar president
Herman: 'My Cousin Vinny' and the race for State Bar president

Let us count the ways that it’s well worth your time and trouble to become a lawyer. You get to help people and make a living wage doing it — perhaps even enough to live in Austin. And you get to stand up in court and say cool stuff like, “I object!” And you get to star on cloying daytime TV ads hunting for people who have been...
Bestsellers, 4/30/17
Bestsellers, 4/30/17

NEW YORK TIMES BEST-SELLERS FICTION 1. ‘The Fix,’ David Baldacci 2. ‘The Black Book,’ James Patterson and David Ellis 3. ‘Fast and Loose,’ Stuart Woods 4. ‘Thrawn,’ Timothy Zahn 5. ‘All By Myself, Alone,” Marry Higgins Clark 6. ‘Norse Mythology,’ Neil Gaiman 7. ‘The Women...
Commentary: How the Legislature is choking the Texas film industry
Commentary: How the Legislature is choking the Texas film industry

AMC Network recently premiered 10 episodes of “The Son,” a series based on the celebrated novel spanning generations of Texans written by Austin novelist Philipp Meyer. Reviews highlighted that it was filmed on location here in Texas, with the landscape giving the series an epic heft. And if the Texas Legislature eliminates the Texas Moving...
A look at how laws promoted discrimination
A look at how laws promoted discrimination

Recommended reading “The Color of Law: A Forgotten History of How Our Government Segregated America” by Richard Rothstein (Liveright). Legal scholar and housing expert Richard Rothstein examines one of the ugliest aspects of the American century and makes the argument that it was laws themselves, rather than the actions of private citizens...
Opinion: The day Bill O’Reilly got fired

On the day Bill O’Reilly was fired, Serena Williams announced she was 20 weeks pregnant. Fans did the math and concluded Williams must have had a baby on board in January when she won her 23rd Grand Slam singles title in dominating fashion. That, said TV tennis analyst Pam Shriver, made Williams’ win “even more spectacular.&rdquo...
More Stories