Open carry controversy started with a bang but shooting blanks so far


Open carry’s critics thought the law would usher in a modern-day Wild West, but no charges have been filed.

Supporters reminisced about two decades ago, when similar outcry accompanied concealed carry laws in Texas.

Fifty days into the open carry era in Texas, things in the Austin metro area have been conspicuously calm.

The policy’s critics thought the law allowing gun license holders to openly carry handguns would usher in a modern-day Wild West, but the American-Statesman found only two 911 calls have been made to Austin area police since the law took effect Jan. 1. Neither case resulted in criminal charges or any violence.

The placid denouement after all the fervor surrounding the law’s adoption had its supporters reminiscing about the period two decades ago when similar outcry accompanied the passage of concealed gun carry laws in Texas.

“It’s kind of funny, and it was hard for me to not chuckle when I heard the same stupid arguments I heard years and years ago,” said Suzanna Hupp, a former Texas House member who was at the forefront of the movement to pass concealed carry laws in 1995.

As with open carry, Hupp said police chiefs across Texas testified at the Capitol that concealed handguns would be harmful to police. Backed by an association representing chiefs across Texas, Austin’s Chief Art Acevedo fought strongly to defeat the open carry bill as it made its way through the legislature last year.

“We always knew their fears and rhetoric would be proven false,” said CJ Grisham, president of Open Carry Texas. “I guess it boggles my mind, every time Texas debates a new gun law they predict doom and gloom, and they’re wrong.”

Austin police focused on educating their department about the law, according to police Cmdr. Andy Michael, who trains officers. Call takers at the 911 center received training on what to ask callers who report a person openly carrying a gun, such as finding out whether it was holstered. They were to explain the law to the callers and dispatch an officer, if the caller requested it.

“It turns out that bit wasn’t even all that necessary, because the calls aren’t coming in,” Michael said.

One 911 call did come in on Jan. 10 when a man told police he felt threatened by a man openly carrying a gun inside the La Tapatia restaurant at Anderson Mill and U.S. 183 in Northwest Austin. The two men exchanged heated words in which the weapon carrier asked the other man to take things outside.

Officers came to the restaurant, took a statement from the armed man (who never brandished or even touched the gun) and left, police said.

One other 911 call involving open carry occurred Jan. 3 in Round Rock and came from a staff member at the H-E-B on U.S. 79 near A.W. Grimes Boulevard. The grocery store chain has banned open carry at all of its locations.

In that instance, a man walked into the store with a weapon. The store security staff called the police, as is the retailer’s standard practice, according to the 911 call.

Michael said he has yet to see a person openly carrying a weapon.

Mike Cox, a Driftwood rancher who teaches a concealed handgun license course, said he supports open carry, but would only do it off his property when it makes sense, like when he gets his mail or rides his tractor down the road.

“It’s just going to invite conversations with morons,” Cox said. “I’m not trying to talk them into my perspective on this one. I would never open carry just because I don’t want to deal with that.”

The next step for proponents of open carry is constitutional carry, essentially open carry of guns without the requirement for any handgun license. Grisham said he will push for that in next year’s legislative session. In several states, it is already the law.

“Vermont has had this for years,” Hupp said. “The Yankees have had this for years. You think Texas constituents are less trustworthy than the Yankees in Vermont?”

Reader Comments

Next Up in News

All clear at Joint Base Andrews after active shooter report
All clear at Joint Base Andrews after active shooter report
Joint Base Andrews was placed on lockdown Thursday morning after a report of an active shooter. The notice was posted shortly after 9 a.
Why does cookie dough make you sick?
Why does cookie dough make you sick?
If you are in the “life is uncertain, eat dessert first” camp, then the news from the FDA that people should never eat cookie dough is...
Roger Williams probed by U.S. House Ethics Committee
Roger Williams probed by U.S. House Ethics Committee
The U.S. House Ethics Committee announced this week it has launched a review of U.S. Rep. Roger Williams, a car-dealer who is accused of having a...
140 Central Texas students receive MexAustin scholarships
140 Central Texas students receive MexAustin scholarships
The Consulate General of Mexico in Austin and Foundation Communities awarded the first annual MexAustin scholarships to 140 Central Texas students...
Judge: City must pay fired officer’s attorney fees in cactus juice case
Judge: City must pay fired officer’s attorney fees in cactus juice case
A Williamson County district court ruled this week that the city of Georgetown must pay about $44,700 in attorneys’ fees and appellate costs for a...
More Stories

You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of free premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


Welcome to

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on