Why the flu shot worked less than half the time during last year’s flu season


As the temperatures drop, many are bundling up in coats and hats to stay warm and healthy. Folks are also getting their flu shots to ward off illness, but a new report reveals doctors are concerned about the strength of these vaccinations. 

>> Read more trending news

During the 2014-2015 season, flu vaccine effectiveness was just 19 percent, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and it rose to 47 percent during the 2015-2016 season.

While it worked 42 percent of the time last season, it was only 34 percent effective against H3N2, the viruses that were most prevalent last year. 

Why is that?

recent study by researchers from the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai found the low performance was due to a mutation in the influenza A vaccine strain, which was likely caused by the egg-based manufacturing process most commonly used today to quickly produce large quantities of the vaccine. 

To determine these findings, analysts examined the seed strains, created in chicken eggs, that are distributed to vaccine makers. 

>> Related: 7 ways to stop the spread of the flu

When they aligned the strains of the vaccines with the circulating viruses, which can evolve over time, they noticed the mutation did not allow the antibodies in humans and animals to bind to the flu viruses. In other words, there was a mismatch between the current virus and current vaccine. 

“Influenza vaccine effectiveness can be low when there is a mismatch between vaccine strains and circulating strains,” the authors said. “Viral antigens included in influenza vaccines are routinely updated in an attempt to avoid antigenic mismatches.” But this isn’t always possible to dodge. 

Furthermore, when scientists compared egg-based vaccines with cell-based vaccines formed by insects or mammalian cells, they discovered both humans and animals with the cell-based vaccine responded significantly better to the circulating viruses. 

>> Related: Here is what you need to know about this year's flu vaccine

Scientists now have their eyes on the current season. “The 2017–2018 recommended H3N2 component is the same as 2016–2017,” the study read, which could unfortunately cause another mismatch. 

That’s why they hope to take on further investigations that “address whether egg-adapted mutations constitute another form of antigenic mismatch that alters vaccine effectiveness in other influenza virus seasons,” the authors said. 

But despite the recent findings, researchers noted last year’s vaccine wasn’t an overall fail. It prevented nearly 30 percent of hospitalizations, and it reduced outpatient visits by 42 percent. 

>> Related: What is the flu? 17 things to know about flu symptoms, flu shot side effects and more

Want to learn more about the experiment? Take a look here


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation & World

Extra cinnamon may be the secret to weight loss this holiday season
Extra cinnamon may be the secret to weight loss this holiday season

If you're looking to shed a few pounds, you may want to go heavier on the cinnamon this holiday season. New research from scientists at the University of Michigan (or U of M) revealed that cinnamaldehyde, an essential oil that gives the spice its flavor, appears to have an anti-obesity effect, Newsweek reported. The study follows previous research...
Reporter finds black widow spider nestled in Christmas tree at grocery store
Reporter finds black widow spider nestled in Christmas tree at grocery store

A news reporter in San Antonio made a potentially dangerous discovery in a Christmas tree at a local grocery store: a black widow spider. San Antonio-Express reporter Paul Stephen was shopping at an HEB grocery store Tuesday when he picked up a small Christmas tree and noticed the venomous arachnid, according to the newspaper. "I saw the...
Young woman vanishes after online date, family fears the worst
Young woman vanishes after online date, family fears the worst

A 24-year-old Lincoln, Nebraska, woman has been missing for several days following a date with someone she met online, and now police are calling the circumstance surrounding her disappearance “concerning.” Lincoln Police Chief Jeff Jeff Bliemeister spoke to local media Tuesday and urged residents to continue looking for Sydney Loofe as...
Black Friday 2017: Walmart, Best Buy, Amazon deals, store hours, ads and more
Black Friday 2017: Walmart, Best Buy, Amazon deals, store hours, ads and more

  It’s almost go time. Sure, you have a turkey and all the fixins’ to fix, family to visit with and football to watch, but you also have sales to attend, deals to get and shopping to get over with. With holiday shopping barking at the door like a pack of wolves, here's a quick guide to the best deals, store hours, ads and shopping...
Jimmy Fallon, Maroon 5 pull street performing prank in NYC subway station
Jimmy Fallon, Maroon 5 pull street performing prank in NYC subway station

An oddly familiar-looking band of street musicians treated New York subway commuters to a jam session, and it turns out it was made up of Maroon 5’s Adam Levine and James Valentine and “The Tonight Show” host Jimmy Fallon in disguise. Disguised as buskers -- people who perform in public for donations -- the trio performed a rousing...
More Stories