IN THEIR WORDS: Council explains secrecy on city manager candidates

We asked all of the City Council members why they voted in favor of complete secrecy for hiring the city’s top job.

Mayor Steve Adler: “The advice we were getting is that we would have the best and widest, deepest applicant pool if candidates knew their identities would not be mentioned.”

Council Member Ora Houston: “I’ve lived in Austin long enough to know that if you give the city a list of people, they will pick them apart. That’s not what this should be about.”

Council Member Delia Garza: “I didn’t understand it as waiting to the end and then only releasing one name… That being said, it was recommended by the (search firm) that it could affect the pool and, at the end of the day, I wanted the best pool.”

RELATED: A year after Ott, Austin city manager interviews to begin in secret

Council Member Sabino “Pio” Renteria: “We thought there might be some kind of negative effect, if they were to announce out in the open, (and) we wouldn’t get as many qualified candidates. That’s what our consultant appraised us.”

Council Member Greg Casar: “We, as a group, believed that qualified candidates would not apply if it could put their jobs at risk. Council had to make a tough decision and we decided we wanted to have the best candidates.”

Council Member Ann Kitchen: Declined to discuss her vote, but said: “It’s important to recognize that we have the broadest, most qualified group to interview that we possibly can. That involves some level of discretion at the beginning of the process. I will support more community engagement at the end.”

Council Member Jimmy Flannigan: “It’s very common practice, especially in the private sector, that when you’re seeking candidates for an executive position, there are people who are good at their jobs and may be excellent at it, but they don’t want to burn any bridges where they are. It gives us a stronger slate of candidates.”

THE BACK STORY: Austin will keep city manager search a secret

Council Member Leslie Pool: “Maybe from the dais (it was unanimous) but we had long conversations… I wanted to have input from the public, from residents. I wanted to see those interactions. That was not a majority opinion at that point and I thought it was more important that we have a (unanimous) vote.”

Council Member Ellen Troxclair: “The advice we received from the professionals was that a lot of people who are going to be the best candidates are people who already have really great jobs… They might be less likely to apply if they’re going to risk their current jobs.”

Council Member Kathie Tovo: “The council decided to have the process be confidential so excellent candidates would not fear applying… It would be ideal if, at the end of the process, the final candidates have an option to do a public presentation. That’s not what we agreed to, but I hope we can revisit it.”

Council Member Alison Alter: Declined to discuss her vote, but said: “I actually don’t think it’s realistic (to maintain secrecy) when we get down to three. I’m not interested in hiring someone who can’t talk to the staff.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Motorcyclist died in crash Monday near Travis, Hays county line
Motorcyclist died in crash Monday near Travis, Hays county line

A motorcyclist died in a crash with a tow truck Monday near the Travis and Hays county line, the Department of Public Safety said. Mackenzie Aloysius Gmitter, 26, died at St. David’s South Austin Medical Center less than an hour after the crash was reported, DPS officials said. Officials responded to the Hays County crash on FM 1626 at 4:25 p...
Democrat Lupe Valdez talks guns, immigration, spending
Democrat Lupe Valdez talks guns, immigration, spending

Democrat Lupe Valdez, six weeks into her run for Texas governor, took exception to Republican handling of immigration, gun laws and the state’s rainy day fund during a wide-ranging discussion Thursday in Austin. Valdez also defended lackluster fundraising numbers after her campaign collected only $46,000 in the last 3½ weeks of December...
Austin wants to go paperless. Here’s how you can help.
Austin wants to go paperless. Here’s how you can help.

Think for a moment about the most cumbersome paperwork you’ve ever submitted to the city of Austin. City officials want to hear all about it. Mayor Steve Adler announced the city’s partnership Thursday with Austin Tech Alliance to launch a “paper census” to identify outdated paper-based processes and suggest digital alternatives...
TEXAS DIGEST: Some school districts cancel classes due to flu

PUBLIC HEALTH Some school districts cancel classes due to flu Some Texas school districts have canceled classes because of high numbers of students and staff experiencing illnesses including the flu. Gunter Independent School District, located north of Dallas, announced Wednesday that it would close beginning Thursday after about 30 percent of its...
Advocates: Immigrant who said guard assaulted her attempted suicide
Advocates: Immigrant who said guard assaulted her attempted suicide

A woman in custody at an immigration detention center in Taylor who has accused a guard of sexually assaulting her recently tried to commit suicide, advocates said this week. Laura Monterrosa, a woman from El Salvador who has been held at the T. Don Hutto immigrant detention center since May, tried to kill herself on Jan. 11, according to the Austin-based...
More Stories