Some Austin leaders uneasy after commission demands informant identity


Will whistleblowers go silent at Austin City Hall if they know their names could come out?

The Austin City Council is revisiting the power it granted the Ethics Review Commission six months ago to issue subpoenas, as the panel’s use of the newfound power could unmask an informant who confidentially reported apparent wrongdoing.

Though they’re waiting to get the details from city lawyers, some council members are concerned. Council Member Kathie Tovo said she wants to have an environment where city employees feel comfortable reporting wrongdoing.

“It does concern me that in giving the Ethics Review Commission subpoena power, we may have created an environment where people are afraid to come forward,” she said. “I have to give some thought to whether that’s an appropriate power.”

The commission, which doles out low-level sanctions or recommending prosecution for violations of city rules, used its subpoena power last month to demand that investigative auditor Nathan Wiebe turn over notes and records of his meetings with an informant related to a misuse of city resources investigation of former police monitor Margo Frasier.

The 6-2 vote, with two abstentions and one absence, came after Frasier’s attorney requested the information. Frasier is accused of occasionally using city time, and her city laptop, to perform private law enforcement consulting work.

RELATED: Evidence heard in former police monitor’s ethics case

Auditors immediately pushed back, arguing that being unable to promise confidentiality to employees and members of the public concerned about retaliation would gut their ability to investigate wrongdoing within the city.

Auditors have complied with the subpoena and turned over the information to the commission, but it is still in the hands of city officials who can keep it confidential. Corrie Stokes, Austin city auditor, worries about the impact if the commission publicly considers it or turns it over to Frasier’s lawyers.

Stokes said the commission’s move could have “a chilling effect” on people being willing to talk to her office. She noted that her office is the first stop for complaints that fall into many different categories, from misuse of city resources to harassment and discrimination. She added that the information presented to the commission is based on Wiebe’s investigation, not the word of the initial informant.

Most members of the commission did not return phone calls to comment, but member Donna Beth McCormick said she had no qualms about demanding information about the Frasier informant.

“If we have subpoena power, we need to get everything that’s there,” she said, adding: “We’re not the CIA…If (whistleblowers) are that worried about their career, they need to get some legal advice.”

ALSO READ: Ex-Austin Energy worker, advisory board members face ethics complaints

The commission’s subpoena powers were part of a broader ordinance the City Council approved earlier this year aimed at strengthening the city’s ethics rules.

The council’s early discussions about the ordinance didn’t touch on why subpoena powers were being added. But the Ethics Review Commission has expressed frustration when an official refused to cooperate.

In 2015, several commissioners said they were disappointed when then-Council Member Don Zimmerman didn’t attend a hearing on complaints over his campaign finance reports. Then-chairman Austin Kaplan said Zimmerman’s absence was demeaning to the commission and hamstrung its ability to get to the bottom of the ethics allegations.

Since the new ethics ordinance went into effect June 1, the commission has used its subpoena power only one other time: to call for former city music manager Don Pitts to appear at a hearing scrutinizing a fake invoicing scheme involving him and a subordinate. He couldn’t make it to the meeting and the commission said it would refer his no-show for prosecution, though, as of last week, Pitts said no citations have been filed against him.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Statesman City Hall page brings local government news to your Facebook feed

The council is set to discuss the subpoena in the Frasier case, and possibly take some action, Thursday.

“I know what my gut is telling me,” said Council Member Leslie Pool. “I do not feel that unveiling a whistleblower in this context, which is quasi-judicial, is appropriate.”

She added that she was surprised the Frasier complaint, essentially alleging some non-work-related computer use, rose to the level of the commission taking that action.

Council Member Greg Casar said he is waiting to get more information, but wants to weigh dueling concerns that whistleblowers could be unveiled with the possibility that some complaints may be politically motivated.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

George P. Bush outraises GOP primary opponent Patterson
George P. Bush outraises GOP primary opponent Patterson

Texas Land Commissioner George P. Bush, facing a Republican primary challenge from Jerry Patterson, the man who formerly held his post, significantly outraised his opponent in the last half of 2017, campaign finance reports filed this week show. Bush’s campaign raised $1 million, leaving him with almost $3.4 million in the bank at the end of...
We knew this already: Buc-ee’s is officially the best gas station 
We knew this already: Buc-ee’s is officially the best gas station 

Huge, super-clean bathrooms. Fresh sandwiches. Pajama pants covered in little beavers. Home decor. Awesome snacks. Really big car washes. Texans know where it’s at when it comes to gas stations, and Buc-ee’s is the best of the best. We knew this already. This is nothing new.  But now it’s official. GasBuddy listed Buc-ee&rsquo...
Are you the cutest couple in Austin? Enter the 2018 Cutest Couples Contest
Are you the cutest couple in Austin? Enter the 2018 Cutest Couples Contest

Are your friends constantly telling you how cute you and your significant other are? Do they say, “Oh, gross” when you smooch at brunch? Do they tell you to “get a room” when you gaze at each other lovingly over happy hour beers? Do you think you’re pretty cute, too?  Let’s put it to the test. We&rsquo...
Austin grows up: Statesman graphic from the 80s details ‘skyscraper boom’
Austin grows up: Statesman graphic from the 80s details ‘skyscraper boom’

People have been yelling “When did that get there?!” in Austin longer than you’d think. Reddit user Meetybeefy posted a graphic to the news aggregation site, which is stamped as having been printed in the Statesman on Oct. 21, 1984, that shows the planned downtown projects set to “stretch [the] skyline.” And even...
Slaughter Lane overpass in South Austin reopens early after deadly crash
Slaughter Lane overpass in South Austin reopens early after deadly crash

Austin police have reopened an elevated portion of Slaughter Lane in South Austin ahead of schedule after a fatal crash on Tuesday evening. Police shut down all traffic in the 1500 block of West Slaughter Lane after a pickup tumbled off a roughly 30-foot high bridge just east of Manchaca Road on Tuesday evening. Authorities at the time of the incident...
More Stories