UT: Lawsuit challenging use of race in admissions is ‘retread’ of Fisher


A lawsuit challenging race-conscious admissions at the University of Texas amounts to a “retread” from a U.S. Supreme Court case that upheld the university’s program and should be thrown out, according to a UT court filing.

Students for Fair Admissions “should not be able to re-litigate this or any other aspect of UT’s admissions policy by dressing up the challenge with state law theories they failed to advance the first time around,” the university argued in papers filed Monday with state district court in Travis County.

The group, which sued the university in June, “attempts to revisit the same set of underlying issues, while totally ignoring the outcome of the prior litigation,” UT added.

Students for Fair Admissions contends that the use of racial and ethnic preferences in admissions at UT violates state law and the Texas Constitution. It says the state’s Bill of Rights provides “more expansive protection against discrimination” than the U.S. Constitution.

Edward Blum, president of the group, also lined up the federal case, Fisher v. UT; in that case, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the university’s use of affirmative action by a 4-3 vote in June 2016. Blum and his allies “cannot accept that each court in their prior litigation ruled against them and determined that UT may lawfully consider race as one of many factors,” the university’s lawyers wrote.

“UT’s pursuit of excellence is grounded in the university’s public mission to provide the highest quality education for every student,” UT President Gregory L. Fenves said in a statement. “The educational benefits of diversity are essential to carry out that mission and prepare students to work in a competitive, global marketplace.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Mother accused of using kids to steal from Macy’s at Domain, police say
Mother accused of using kids to steal from Macy’s at Domain, police say

Austin police are looking for a woman who they say stole merchandise from a Macy’s department store with the help of another woman and four children no older than 10 years old. Investigators are looking for 27-year-old Martha Monique Lopez, who is charged with robbery by assault, according to an arrest affidavit filed against her this week. On...
Here are the Austin theaters showing Pixar’s ‘Coco’ dubbed into Spanish
Here are the Austin theaters showing Pixar’s ‘Coco’ dubbed into Spanish

“Coco,” the new film from Disney Pixar, concerns young Miguel Rivera, a Mexican boy from a family of shoemakers who loves music, contrary to his family’s dislike of the stuff. Naturally, he ends up in the land of the dead to address the problem at hand. (And yes, there’s more plot than that.) Already the all-time highest...
COMMUNITY NEWS: Austin nonprofit heads up Giving Tuesday campaign

CENTRAL TEXAS Nonprofit heads up Giving Tuesday campaign The Austin nonprofit I Live Here, I Give Here will be the Central Texas official community leader for Giving Tuesday, an annual global event that takes place on the Tuesday after Thanksgiving. The organization is participating in the campaign by kicking off the year-end giving season through...
Court upholds conviction in SXSW crash that killed 4 in 2014
Court upholds conviction in SXSW crash that killed 4 in 2014

A state appeals court Wednesday upheld the capital murder conviction of Rashad Owens in a series of automobile crashes that killed four during the 2014 South by Southwest music festival in downtown Austin. Owens, who is serving a life sentence without the possibility of parole, asked the 3rd Court of Appeals to overturn his conviction, arguing that...
Pay raises, hiring initiatives usher in Texas CPS improvements
Pay raises, hiring initiatives usher in Texas CPS improvements

More caseworkers are staying on the job and workloads have plummeted almost a year after state officials provided $12,000 pay raises to employees in the Texas child welfare system, which had been plagued by child deaths and delays in visiting children in reported abusive homes. After the raises went into effect in January, the percentage of staff leaving...
More Stories