You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks


Welcome to

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on

Herman: Texas Electoral College member to quit over Donald Trump vote

In a decision detailed in an intriguing 2,667-word explanation, East Texas welding supply salesman Art Sisneros says he’ll resign from the Electoral College rather than become a “faithless elector” who cannot cast his ballot for Donald Trump, whom he likens to Skittles.

I wrote last week about how Sisneros, selected at this year’s state Republican convention as his congressional district’s member of the Electoral College, was morally and politically conflicted because he had signed an oath to back the party’s nominee as an elector but could not bring himself to back the man the party selected.

Sisneros, who lives about 40 miles northeast of Houston in Dayton, cast a write-in vote for Tom Hoefling of Iowa after posting a lengthy, religion-based explanation of why he could not back Trump. After being very public about the dilemma he would face when the Electoral College meets Dec. 19 at the Capitol to cast its 38 votes, Sisneros fielded much pressure — some of it vitriolic — about his upcoming decision.

He called the explanation of that decision “Conflicted Elector in a Corrupt College.”

“When running for the presidential elector nominee some six months ago, I had no idea the conflict that would ensue both from without and within,” he began.

I encourage you to read his full posting. It’s thoughtful, touching on important concepts such as the difference between a republic and a “pure democracy” and how the Founding Fathers, with “the wisdom we lack,” opted for the former.

“The essence of a republic is that the authority rests in elected representatives, not in the people directly,” Sisneros wrote, adding that Electoral College members are supposed to vote as they see fit, even if it differs from the collective will of a plurality of the people.

That’s a core question I’ve long pondered to no conclusion about legislators: Are they supposed to do what they think is right or what they perceive the people they represent want them to do?

Sisneros offered what he called a “limited analogy” to another situation.

“Parents are the representative heads of their kids,” he wrote. “When parents make a decision for the family, they do so on behalf of everyone they represent. Good parents act in the best interest of their children. At times, this may even be contrary to the desire of the children.

“In most homes, kids do not have the right to vote to eat Skittles for dinner. It is not in their best interest. The parents have a delegated authority to protect those under their jurisdiction. (Alexander) Hamilton, in a similar way, saw the role of the body of electors as a protection for the nation.”

That’s pretty bold stuff in so far as it likens voters to children.

For Sisneros, the bottom line is the Electoral College “was corrupted from its original intent once states started dictating the votes of the electors.” And he now believes, as a Christian, he sinned when he signed the required Texas GOP oath vowing to back the party’s nominee — assuming that person carried the state — when the time came to cast his electoral vote. It is, he wrote, “an immoral, unlawful pledge.”

“I was wrong in signing this pledge and not communicating to the body when I ran that my conscience would not be bound by it,” Sisneros wrote.

Unwilling to break the pledge, he has opted to resign from the Electoral College, a move that will allow the other electors to select a replacement, one very likely to have no trouble backing Trump, something Sisneros still cannot bring himself to do.

“I do not see how Donald Trump is biblically qualified to serve in the office of the presidency,” he wrote. “Of the hundreds of angry messages that I have received, not one has made a convincing case from scripture otherwise.”

He acknowledged that his decision will have no effect on the outcome. “Trump will be our president,” he wrote. And, barring the unforeseen, Texas will not have its first-ever faithless elector.

“Many are furious that I am willing to have this discussion publicly,” Sisneros wrote. “Personally, I wish more civil officers would be honest about their convictions. Assuming a Trump presidency is their ultimate goal, they will get that. The problem is, that isn’t what they want. They want a democracy.”

So he will resign.

“The people will get their vote. They will get their Skittles for dinner. I will sleep well at night knowing I neither gave in to their demands nor caved to my convictions. I will also mourn the loss of our republic.”

State GOP Chairman Tom Mechler issued a low-key response to Sisneros’ decision, saying, “We respect Mr. Sisneros’ decision and appreciate his willingness to step down from his position as a presidential elector in Texas.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Texas cracks top 10 of most dangerous places to cross the street
Texas cracks top 10 of most dangerous places to cross the street

Crossing the street can seem like such a simple thing. But there was some logic behind Mom telling you to look both ways first — an average of 13 people are struck and killed by a car while walking every day, according to the fourth edition of the Dangerous by Design report.  That same report (issued by Smart Growth America’s...
Rove to Trump: Lose the pettiness, stop whining, think big
Rove to Trump: Lose the pettiness, stop whining, think big

GEORGETOWN — For a full hour Monday night, Karl Rove regaled some 450 people at the Williamson Country Republican Party Reagan Dinner at the Sheraton Georgetown with tales of William McKinley and his extraordinary but little-remembered success as a Republican candidate for president and occupant of the White House. And then Rove brought the lessons...
AFD makes quick work of apartment complex laundry fire in North Austin
AFD makes quick work of apartment complex laundry fire in North Austin

6:50 a.m. update: Austin fire crews made quick work of a fire that broke out in an apartment complex in North Austin on Tuesday morning. Firefighters were called out to the Highland Heights apartment complex in the 800 block of Tirado Street just after 6 a.m. They arrived within a few minutes and found flames shooting out of at least one unit...
Sunny skies expected in Austin through the rest of the week
Sunny skies expected in Austin through the rest of the week

Tuesday forecast for Austin: Forecasters are expecting sunny skies in Austin through the rest of the week after storms that battered the region on Monday cleared out of the area. According to the National Weather Service, the temperature in the Austin metro area was sitting at 55 degrees at 6 a.m., and no hazardous weather conditions that could affect...
Police search for teenagers after South Austin chase, crash

Austin Police said they are searching for teenagers who ran away after a car chase and a crash Monday night in South Austin. Police said the vehicle was stolen. Police on the scene could not give an exact time and location that the incident took place, but said it took place in the area of Southridge Drive and Bannister Lane. Police have established...
More Stories