Herman: Abortion ruling doesn’t justify 2013 TX Senate gallery outburst


Let’s be clear here. Monday’s U.S. Supreme Court ruling striking down Texas’ onerous abortion restriction law was a major victory for the politics — not the tactics — of the obnoxious protesters who screamed the Texas Senate into temporary shutdown three years ago.

In a ruling that agreed with the protesters’ protestations that the law went way too far, the high court threw out the statute that effectively closed some Texas abortion clinics by setting standards they could not meet.

But we err if we in any way view this as vindication or justification for the childish protest mounted by folks who didn’t seem to understand how our system works.

Those with the most votes win — at least temporarily — no matter how loud or long you yell to try to prevent the votes from being cast. Absolutely having the votes, of course, does not mean absolute power. A Constitution prevails and courts interpret the Constitution. That’s what happened Monday in the proper process — as opposed to the 2013 Senate gallery protest — available to those who believe they are aggrieved, even if they are in the minority.

I believed in 2013 that the Senate gallery protest was a low point in my more than 35 years of watching the Texas Legislature. The protesters were way out of line, then-GOP Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst screwed up in letting it get out of hand and Democratic senators on the floor acted unconscionably in waving their arms to further rouse the rabble in the gallery.

WATCH: Click here for video of gallery response to Wendy Davis’ 2013 filibuster

And the screamers, it turned out, couldn’t have been more wrong in predicting their nonsense would be s a landmark turning point that would change the course of Texas political history.

Democratic state Sen. Wendy Davis of Fort Worth, the performer of a vote-stalling filibuster — silly stunts of endurance not equally available to all senators — used the attention to launch her 2014 gubernatorial campaign amid Democratic optimism unseen in Texas in many years.

She, of course, wound up losing to Republican Greg Abbott by a wider margin than Democrat Bill White lost to Republican Rick Perry four years earlier. So much for Democratic optimism.

Anybody have a possible 2018 Democratic gubernatorial nominee with a chance of winning?

I thought about that terrible night for representative democracy in Texas when Democrats in the U.S House sought to stand up for gun control by sitting down on the chamber floor last week. So moving. So unprecedented. And, like the 2013 filibuster in the Texas Senate, so silly and nonproductive.

Like the Texas Senate Democrats, the Democrats in the U.S. House didn’t have the votes to get what they wanted. You can’t always get what you want. In fact, when you don’t have the votes, you pretty much never can. And you shouldn’t, save for — as in the important Texas abortion case — when the courts rule the majority out of line.

Lawyers and reasoned argument — not screamers and unreasonable demands — are the minority’s best weapon. It doesn’t guarantee victory, but it does skip over the screaming embarrassment of fruitless protest.

So let’s be clear. The protesters were right that the Texas abortion law was wrong. And they were right in predicting it would not withstand court scrutiny. But they remain wrong in interfering with the legislative process.

That process — the very heart of how we make law — must always remain more important than anything it produces.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Police seeking identity of man hit by train in New Braunfels on Friday
Police seeking identity of man hit by train in New Braunfels on Friday

New Braunfels police are trying to identify a man who was critically injured after being hit by a train on Friday morning. First responders were called to the 500 block of North Hidalgo Avenue around 2:45 a.m. after receiving reports of a crash involving a train and a pedestrian. Authorities arrived and found a man in his 40s suffering from life-threatening...
Judge denies motion to toss out key evidence in Judge Kocurek shooting
Judge denies motion to toss out key evidence in Judge Kocurek shooting

Federal prosecutors will be able to use incriminating cellphone records in this spring’s trial of the primary suspect in the shooting of Travis County state District Judge Julie Kocurek. A defense motion to suppress the records, which authorities say place defendant Chimene Onyeri and two associates in Austin around the time of the November 2015...
In Austin-area House race, candidates’ party loyalties at question
In Austin-area House race, candidates’ party loyalties at question

State Rep. Paul Workman, R-Austin, has more than $143,000 in his campaign coffers and the endorsement of major conservative organizations, from Texas Alliance for Life to the National Rifle Association. Yet another leg-up for the District 47 lawmaker, Gov. Greg Abbott cast his early voting ballot on Tuesday alongside Workman, praising him as someone...
Black History Month at UT: Remembering three Longhorns sports pioneers
Black History Month at UT: Remembering three Longhorns sports pioneers

On Jan. 4, 2006, on a fourth-and-5 at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, Calif., Vince Young ran into the end zone and Longhorns lore. Young’s touchdown that won the national championship is perhaps the most famous play in the history of UT sports. It also was just one of many athletic achievements attributed to a black athlete at Texas. The jerseys...
Early Austin minority neighborhood remembered
Early Austin minority neighborhood remembered

Tucked behind a burgeoning commercial district off of West Sixth Street near Lamar Boulevard sits a little-known part of Austin history. After the Civil War, a community of formerly enslaved African-Americans settled on the northern half of Wood Street near the west bank of Shoal Creek. Over the decades, the enclave experienced a cultural shift as...
More Stories