Federal hearing may answer questions in deadly Lockhart balloon crash


National Transportation Safety Board to hold public hearing Friday in Washington, D.C.

Officials expected to release investigative documents, including witness statements and interview transcripts.

Hearing will also focus on safety issues within the commercial hot air balloon industry.

On a cloudy, foggy Saturday morning in August, pilot Alfred “Skip” Nichols tried to land a hot air balloon holding 15 sightseers when he flew into high tension power lines outside of Lockhart. The resulting fireball killed everyone on board, including at least two couples celebrating their wedding anniversaries.

It’s still unclear exactly how and why Nichols, an experienced balloon pilot with a criminal history involving drugs and alcohol, ended up striking the power lines.

LIVE COVERAGE: Congressional hearing

But answers could come Friday as the National Transportation Safety Board holds a public investigative hearing in Washington, D.C., that will focus on weather conditions at the time of the crash, issues of pilot decision-making and training, and the level of safety oversight in the commercial ballooning industry.

The investigation is expected to be finished in early 2017, safety board spokesman Eric Weiss said.

Among those scheduled to testify are the head of Kubicek Balloons, the Czech company that manufactured the balloon that crashed, and officials with industry advocacy group Balloon Federation of America.

Representatives with Nichols’ company, Heart of Texas Hot Air Balloon Rides, aren’t scheduled to testify, though safety officials will release documents related to their investigation, including witness statements, transcripts of interviews and photos, according to Weiss.

State Rep. John Cyrier, a licensed pilot who represents the Lockhart area, said weather conditions quickly emerged as a factor in the crash. “It was pretty apparent the visibility wasn’t good,” said Cyrier, who visited the crash site. “There was a low cloud deck and even ground fog.”

Officials familiar with the investigation told The Wall Street Journal that the crash might have occurred after Nichols tried to quickly descend through clouds without noticing the power lines. According to the officials, Nichols had been flying above a low-hanging cloud bank in violation of safety rules that require pilots to stay clear of clouds.

According to safety board member Robert Sumwalt, Nichols sent up two test balloons to gauge the wind before deciding to fly.

Sumwalt said in the week after the crash that investigators didn’t believe the balloon had any mechanical problems before takeoff. Federal officials say current inspection records and maintenance logs might have been on board at the time of the crash.

While hot air balloons don’t have a black box like airplanes or helicopters, investigators are focusing on cellphones and cameras recovered in the crash, which might provide clues to the balloon’s final moments.

INTERACTIVE: The 16 Lockhart balloon crash victims

Cyrier, a Republican who had called previously for a public hearing into the crash, said he hopes Friday’s session illuminates the current levels of safety oversight on hot air balloons and what he called the minimal requirements for pilots who operate commercial balloon flights. “We owe this to the families,” he said. “We owe this level of scrutiny on this activity.”

The hearing comes nearly three years after the National Transportation Safety Board called on the Federal Aviation Administration to regulate commercial balloon operators much as it does helicopter and airplane tour operators, predicting mass fatalities if the agency took no action.

Calls for strengthened oversight of hot air balloons have grown louder since the crash, with U.S. Rep. Lloyd Doggett, the Democrat representing the Lockhart area, calling on the FAA to adopt the safety board’s recommendation to require balloon pilots to provide letters of authorization to local FAA offices. Such letters, the safety board said, would trigger “periodic surveillance checks” to make sure equipment is maintained properly, safety checklists are used, safety briefings are given and appropriate flight planning is conducted.

Cyrier said he also supports greater safety oversight of the balloon industry. “I do suggest that it needs to be looked into,” he said. “People just expect this level of safety.”

So far, the FAA has rebuffed calls for enhanced regulation, preferring to embrace a series of balloon industry-developed safety suggestions, including rating operators based on safety performance, background checks and insurance information. In a letter to Doggett in September, FAA Administrator Michael Huerta said the agency would wait until the safety board’s investigation is concluded before considering any recommendations from its sister agency.

In the crash’s aftermath, attention also focused on Nichols’ lengthy criminal record, which included at least four drunken driving charges and two prison stints in Missouri related to drunken driving and drug distribution convictions. Nichols moved to Central Texas after he was released from prison in 2012.

Missouri authorities had stripped Nichols of his driver’s license, but he never lost his balloon operator’s license, and it’s unclear if Nichols informed the FAA of his alcohol- and drug-related convictions as required. However, critics have pointed to lax licensing requirements for balloon pilots compared with airplane pilots, who must get regular medical screenings that include alcohol and drug checks.

A former girlfriend of Nichols’ told the American-Statesman that he was a recovering alcoholic who had been sober for at least four years.

A Statesman analysis of each of the 71 fatal balloon accidents investigated by the safety board since 1964 found that nearly 70 percent of cases involved some form of pilot error. The crashes, which resulted in 135 deaths, also revealed a series of safety issues, ranging from improperly modified equipment and lack of helmets for passengers to inadequate safety briefings and ill-advised trips in poor weather.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

East Austin group emerges to help change Confederate school names
East Austin group emerges to help change Confederate school names

Days after the only black member of the Austin school board was criticized for publicly calling out his peers for delaying a vote on changing school names with ties to the Confederacy, more than a dozen parents, educators, lawyers and community leaders have formed a work group to push the changes forward. The group of 15, formed by the East Austin...
12 flu outbreaks reported in Williamson County since Jan. 10
12 flu outbreaks reported in Williamson County since Jan. 10

The Williamson County and Cities Health District has investigated 12 outbreaks of flu this week, according to a news release. Ten of those outbreaks were at long-term care facilities such as nursing homes and two were at day care facilities, according to the release. The first outbreak was Jan. 10 and the last one was reported Monday, said Deb Strahler...
AISD makes this surprise announcement benefiting Garcia boys school
AISD makes this surprise announcement benefiting Garcia boys school

The Austin school district now will offer transportation to any middle school student who wants to attend Garcia Young Men’s Leadership Academy. The move could boost student enrollment for the school of 400, which is well below capacity. “It’s a different opportunity to get more students in to this amazing school,” said Superintendent...
Deputies: 2 arrested after 3-month-old child, 51 pounds of heroin, found in SUV
Deputies: 2 arrested after 3-month-old child, 51 pounds of heroin, found in SUV

Deputies in Mississippi arrested two women Monday night on suspicion of drug trafficking after authorities said they found 51 pounds of heroin and a 3-month-old child in an SUV the women were driving. A deputy pulled over a Ford SUV on Interstate 20 in Rankin County on Monday night for an unspecified traffic violation. Authorities said that during...
TRAFFIC UPDATE: Lanes cleared on I-35 near Oltorf following crash
TRAFFIC UPDATE: Lanes cleared on I-35 near Oltorf following crash

3:08 p.m. update: All lanes have been cleared, according to city officials. Earlier: A crash on Interstate 35 has blocked two southbound lanes near Woodward Street, according to the Texas Department of Transportation. The agency says to expect delays, as traffic is backed up to Holly Street.
More Stories