Commuter rail plan sputters as Union Pacific ends negotiations


The dream of passenger rail between Georgetown and San Antonio, already a long shot because of lack of funding, was dealt a severe and possibly fatal blow this week when Union Pacific pulled out of negotiations for use of its track paralleling Interstate 35 through South and Central Texas.

The company, which has been talking for at least a decade to officials with the project’s developer, the Lone Star Rail District, told the district in a letter Tuesday that it is terminating agreements reached in 2009 and 2010 to formalize those discussions.

“We decided now is the time to cut the ties,” Union Pacific spokesman Jeff DeGraff said.

Jerry Wilmoth, Union Pacific’s general manager of network infrastructure, explained the company needs to get on with the business of improving its track and operations without the uncertainty caused by the lingering discussions with Lone Star.

“It has become apparent that the desired track alignments and infrastructure requirements necessary to support the efficient and reliable commingling of freight and commuter passenger rail are unattainable,” Wilmoth wrote. “(Union Pacific) can no longer, in good faith, constrain its growth by the conceptual discussion or previous expression of interest between the parties.”

Despite those stern words, Lone Star’s outside counsel, Austin attorney Bill Bingham, said the project remains viable. He said the district was talking to Union Pacific before it reached agreement on a feasibility study in 2009 and a memorandum of understanding in 2010, and it hopes to continue those discussions.

“It certainly was a disappointment when we got the letter on Tuesday,” Bingham said. “But we’ll continue on, and we’ll keep talking to Union Pacific. I think we’ll get this project done. I don’t know when or how.”

The San Marcos-based rail district, which has two full-time employees and shares its director with another organization, had its beginnings in 1997 legislation passed by then-state Sen. Gonzalo Barrientos, an Austin Democrat. The district formed about five years later, and ever since it has been studying the possibility of installing a commuter rail service on Union Pacific’s line as it passes from Williamson County through the heart of Austin, San Marcos, New Braunfels and San Antonio.

But the project has never been able to advance beyond paper and computer screens. The 1997 legislation gives the agency little taxation power — primarily the ability, with the local jurisdictions’ permission, to tax small areas near train stations — and no permission to run on the logical route, Union Pacific’s track.

Union Pacific’s position has always been that it might be amenable to sharing its tracks, but only if a parallel set of tracks was built well to the east of the I-35 corridor.

And, most significantly, Union Pacific — which, when the economy is humming, runs two to three dozen freight trains a day in that corridor — said the cost of that alternate track would fall to the district. That would be more than $2 billion.

Lone Star, which is in the midst of a federal environmental study of a system, has existed through the years primarily on federal grants and $49,500 a year payments by most of its member cities, counties, transit districts and other local governments. The city of Austin, Travis County, Capital Metro and Austin Community College are among the members.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

FORECAST: Unseasonably warm temps to reach 76; give thanks for sunshine all week
FORECAST: Unseasonably warm temps to reach 76; give thanks for sunshine all week

Tuesday forecast for Austin: Daily temperatures are expected to become unseasonably high before winds shift and push them back down to a more autumnal levels for the rest of the week. The National Weather Service outlook calls for mostly sunny skies on Tuesday coupled with warm south-southwest winds that will help boost temperatures to a high near...
Lakeway City Council discusses citizen engagement measures
Lakeway City Council discusses citizen engagement measures

A couple city council members want the city of Lakeway to up its efforts at engaging the community, and are proposing several measures to accomplish this. During the Nov. 20 council meeting, Councilwoman Jean Hennagin made a presentation for a Lakeway “engagement committee,” and put forward ideas brainstormed along with Councilman Keith...
Transgender Day of Remembrance held outside Austin City Hall
Transgender Day of Remembrance held outside Austin City Hall

The tone of the Transgender Day of Remembrance event held outside Austin City Hall on Monday evening was, as always, a bittersweet mix of hope and sadness as organizers and attendees proclaimed their pride to be transgender and mourned the loss of transgender individuals who were killed this year. For years, Austin has participated in the international...
EAST AUSTIN FIRE: Mobile home blaze in Bastrop Highway under control, officials say
EAST AUSTIN FIRE: Mobile home blaze in Bastrop Highway under control, officials say

A fire at a mobile home located in East Austin near U.S. 183 is now under control, Austin fire officials said Monday night.  The structure at the 500 block of Bastrop Highway was heavily involved when the fire was reported about 10 p.m., officials said. The mobile home was abandoned and no one was injured, officials said. 
U.S. 183, I-35 projects waver after Abbott, Patrick trash tolls
U.S. 183, I-35 projects waver after Abbott, Patrick trash tolls

Several key Central Texas highway projects — including expansions of U.S. 183 in North Austin, U.S. 290 in Southwest Austin and Interstate 35 through the heart of the area — are once again in limbo after Gov. Greg Abbott and Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick last week staked out firm anti-toll positions. “Right now there’s a billion dollars...
More Stories