You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks


Welcome to

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on

Austin supported living center keeps Medicaid money

Earlier this year, state investigators sent a clear message to Austin’s institution for people with disabilities: Stop violating federal rules by June 17 or risk lose millions in federal money.

June 17 came. The center partially complied. And it didn’t lose its money.

It was a typical response to a routine threat. Since 2009, investigators have issued that same warning to Texas’ 13 state supported living centers more than 50 times, giving them 90 days to fix problems. They have not pulled the trigger once.

Living center critics suggest that’s because those institutions are both operated and regulated by the Texas Department of Aging and Disability Services, creating a conflict of interest that keeps the state from punishing itself for inadequate treatment at the centers, even when it leads to patient deaths or severe injuries. In February, a man died at the Austin center after staffers ignored his worsening medical condition.

“They’re policing themselves,” said Dennis Borel, executive director for the Coalition of Texans with Disabilities. “There’s not enough independence.”

Aging and Disability Services spokeswoman Cecilia Cavuto says the agency, which receives money from the federal government to regulate Medicaid standards at the living centers, has “firewalls” that prevent conflicts of interest.

The regulatory division is separate from the operational side, and long-established protocols forbid those groups from collaborating during investigations and inspections. Investigators make unannounced visits to the centers. The identities of whistle-blowers must be kept anonymous, and all Medicaid-related disciplinary actions are approved by the regulatory division’s commissioner.

Ultimately, both divisions answer to the same boss: Aging and Disability Services Commissioner Jon Weizenbaum. Weizenbaum was not available for comment because he was in Washington, D.C., at a previously scheduled meeting. Cavuto says the commissioner plays no role in the enforcement decisions.

The state Health and Human Services Commission — which oversees Aging and Disability Services — says it will be exploring “the appropriateness of our agencies regulating our own facilities” during an organizational review scheduled for 2014-2015.

“We’ll be looking to see if we can do even more to ensure our facilities meet the highest standards possible,” said spokeswoman Stephanie Goodman.

Although the Austin center’s federal money is safe, regulators have decided to put the center on a “system improvement agreement,” a contract in which the state agrees to make specific changes within predetermined timeframes, Cavuto said. Independent monitors will assess that progress, and there will be penalties if the living center doesn’t reach its milestones, she said. The details of that agreement have not yet been worked out.

State regulators almost never pull its money from intermediate care facilities, which not only include the living centers, but small community homes as well. Since 2009, state regulators have conducted 176 investigations that resulted in 90-day termination warnings. Of the facilities investigated, 115 were privately owned. None lost their Medicaid certification.

Federal investigations are not supposed to be punitive, Cavuto said. Instead, they are used to help facilities ensure residents are safe.

By June 17, the Austin center had managed to resolve most of its latest problems, including client safety and protection issues. But it didn’t correct its lack of “active treatment,” such as teaching residents how to get dressed, brush their teeth or control aggression.

Losing its Medicaid certification would be a blow to the Austin living center, as the $29 million in federal funding it receives makes up almost 60 percent of its budget. To get that money back, the facility would have to reapply for certification, a process that could take years.

States across the country handle their Medicaid oversight in different ways. While some operate and regulate their own developmental facilities, others divide those duties among separate agencies. California, for example, uses its Department of Developmental Services to run its facilities and the Department of Public Health to enforce Medicaid violations.

Recently, those agencies went head to head over poor care at the Sonoma Developmental Center. Sonoma voluntarily gave up its certification at four of its 10 on-campus residences and agreed to overhaul the facility.

State investigators’ latest threat to the Austin center — the seventh since 2009 — came after they discovered problems they said endangered all 300 residents. Late last year, one patient was seriously burned while being bathed by a staffer. In April, a woman who was supposed to be closely supervised hurt her eye so badly that it had to be surgically removed.

Agency officials say they’ve been trying to get the Austin center on track for years. Since 2010, it has removed three directors and recently hired its fourth.

Former director Charles Bratcher, who resigned under pressure last month, said the staff always took Medicaid investigations seriously and he was grateful to keep that federal money, even when problems persisted. But he also suspects the facility would lose its certification if regulators were not housed at Aging and Disability Services.

“The whole thing that you learn is that it doesn’t matter what they say because, in the end, somebody will come bail you out,” he said. “Why are we wasting our time if they’re going to do that?”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

FORECAST: After near-record heat, humidity Friday, storms likely overnight Saturday
FORECAST: After near-record heat, humidity Friday, storms likely overnight Saturday

Friday forecast for Austin: The day will feel more like June than April as heat and humidity combine to make the projected high of 92 degrees feel more like 98, as Central Texas sweats under mostly clear skies. Daily temperatures in Austin are expected to come within 2 degrees of the heat record for April 28 – 94 degrees, set in 1955. That weather...
Dog recovering after eating nails wrapped in hot dogs
Dog recovering after eating nails wrapped in hot dogs

The owners of a 4-year-old Yorkshire terrier mix are trying to understand why someone left nails wrapped in hot dogs at their Wisconsin apartment complex. >> Read more trending news Tom Deakin and his girlfriend, Jennifer Ramos, are the owners of Clarice, the dog that is recovering after eating the hot dogs, WISC reported. The dog ate six...
7 things to know now: Trump says job is tough; United passenger settles; Warren slams Obama
7 things to know now: Trump says job is tough; United passenger settles; Warren slams Obama

Here's a roundup of news trending across the nation and world today. 1. Not that easy: In an interview in advance of his 100th day in office, President Donald Trump said he imagined the job as president would be easier than it has turned out to be. In the interview with Reuters, Trump said he missed his life before he took office. "I loved my...
Black woman stands vigil at Jefferson Davis statue in New Orleans
Black woman stands vigil at Jefferson Davis statue in New Orleans

Arlene Barnum said her race has nothing to do with her support of the Confederacy and the statues in New Orleans that preserve its memory. >> Read more trending news  “It’s about being on the right side of history,” said Barnum, a black woman from Oklahoma who grew up in Louisiana. Barnum was at Thursday night’s protest...
Florida elementary school janitor accused of sexting teen
Florida elementary school janitor accused of sexting teen

A Florida elementary school janitor has been suspended after allegedly exchanging explicit photos and texts with a 15-year-old boy, deputies said.  >> Read more trending news Matthew Benedict, 29, of Lake County reportedly gave the teen a cellphone and sexted him, WESH reported.  Even though Benedict worked in the school district...
More Stories