Austin asks judge to toss ‘sanctuary cities’ suit


City lawyers claim Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s suit should be dismissed because it was filed too early.

The city is preparing its own lawsuit against the state over Senate Bill 4.

City argues suit should be tossed because state can’t prove a violation of a law that hasn’t yet taken effect.

The city of Austin has asked a federal judge to toss Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s lawsuit over the Senate Bill 4 ban on so-called sanctuary cities from the courts.

In a motion filed Wednesday, attorneys representing the city said Paxton’s lawsuit violates the Constitution and that it is out of bounds because SB 4 hasn’t yet taken effect.

“The city has been consistent in expressing our concerns with SB 4,” a statement from the city said. “As the state’s lawsuit inappropriately seeks to preemptively punish the city for raising what we believe are legitimate constitutional issues with the law, we have asked the court to dismiss the suit against the city, mayor, city council and city manager.”

Paxton’s office didn’t respond to a request for comment.

Paxton sued Austin and the City Council on May 7 in what was widely interpreted as a pre-emptive strike by his office to have SB 4 declared constitutional. Travis County and Sheriff Sally Hernandez have since been added as defendants in the case.

The city itself is readying its own lawsuit against the state regarding SB 4 after being directed to do so by the council last week. The border city of El Cenizo, Maverick County and El Paso County have sued the state over the law.

The motion says the state cannot show Austin has violated SB 4 because the measure isn’t quite yet a law. It will take effect on Sept. 1.

The suit states the court has no jurisdiction in the matter because Paxton’s suit addresses only hypothetical violations of SB 4.

“Given that the governor announced his signing online via ‘Facebook Live,’ Sunday evening, May 7, 2017, and given that the AG filed suit at midnight that same evening, it is not surprising that the state cannot identify a single objectionable act during the relevant time period,” the suit states.

Meanwhile, Paxton’s office on Wednesday filed a motion seeking to have all lawsuits regarding SB 4 consolidated into his suit against Austin and Travis County. That filing says his office expects to see other cities file suit against the state.

The law would make it a criminal offense for any government official to put a policy in place prohibiting cooperation with federal detention requests placed on jail inmates suspected of being in the country illegally. It also empowers law enforcement officers to inquire about a person’s immigration status during routine police interactions, such as traffic stops.

Critics have argued that so-called immigration detainers are unconstitutional and that by requiring local officials to enforce them, the state has improperly created an immigration law reserved for the federal government.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Austin City Council to hold special meeting Monday on city manager finalists
Austin City Council to hold special meeting Monday on city manager finalists

Austin City Council will convene a special meeting Monday at 8:45 a.m. to interview finalists to be hired as the city’s permanent city manager. According to a statement from the city, the meeting will start in the Boards and Commissions Room at City Hall, 301 W. Second Street, before moving to executive session for discussions on legal and personnel...
FORECAST: Cool, crisp, sunny Monday in 60s; clear skies all Thanksgiving week
FORECAST: Cool, crisp, sunny Monday in 60s; clear skies all Thanksgiving week

Monday forecast for Austin: With family and loved ones in town and schoolchildren in Austin taking the week off, the week couldn’t be nicer for everyone to enjoy autumn in Central Texas. The National Weather Service outlook for Monday calls for sunshine with temperatures climbing to a mild 68 degrees. Nighttime temperatures will slip to around...
Community news: H-E-B hosts Feast of Sharing on Tuesday

TRAVIS COUNTY SOUTH AUSTIN Feast of Sharing on Tuesday H-E-B will host its 28th annual Feast of Sharing dinner from 4 to 8 p.m. Tuesday at the Palmer Events Center, 900 Barton Springs Road. The free event will include live entertainment and a children’s area. The meal will include turkey, mashed potatoes, a vegetable medley, pies, dinner rolls...
Traffic report for Monday, Nov. 20, 2017

Interstate 35 (Travis County): The outside lane on the southbound access road will be closed as needed between Oltorf Street and St. Edwards Drive from 9 a.m. until 3:30 p.m. Monday and Tuesday. The outside lane on the northbound access road will be closed just north of Stassney Lane from 9 a.m. until 3 p.m. Tuesday. Variable closures on the northbound...
Threat cleared at Williamson County apartments, sheriff says
Threat cleared at Williamson County apartments, sheriff says

7:45 p.m. update: Authorities say residents are now able to move safely in and out of the Preserve at Rolling Oaks Apartments in Williamson County after law enforcement cleared a threat made earlier at the complex. “A specific threat was made in the area & after searching with multiple agencies we feel confident area is clear. Though nothing...
More Stories