Attorney general: City manager candidates not a competitive secret


Nor is the information a trade secret or “highly intimate and embarrassing,” attorney general’s office says.

The city of Austin refused to release information Statesman requested under Texas Public Information Act.

The city of Austin cannot withhold records showing who applied for its city manager position by claiming the information would harm the city competitively in a search for qualified applicants, the Texas attorney general’s office says.

Nor is the information a trade secret, a matter that would harm the search firm competitively or “highly intimate and embarrassing,” Matthew Taylor, an assistant attorney general in the open records division, wrote in his opinion.

The opinion says that the city and its executive search firm, Russell Reynolds, must turn over the bulk of the information the American-Statesman requested related to the search for a new city manager, including candidate applications. Austin may withhold only attorney-client privileged emails and some personal email addresses and cellphone numbers.

Diversions and disguises: Behind Austin’s city manager search

The opinion comes after Austin refused to release information the Statesman requested under the Texas Public Information Act. The city requested permission to deny the request to the attorney general, claiming its release would hurt Austin competitively. It also comes a month after the City Council voted to hire Minneapolis City Coordinator Spencer Cronk.

The opinion could provide some parameters to Boeing v. Paxton, the 2015 Texas Supreme Court ruling that Austin relied on in its arguments, which found that lease provisions between Boeing and the San Antonio Port Authority could be kept confidential because they could hurt the aerospace giant competitively. Texas cities since then have used the ruling to block release of everything from taxpayer spending on entertainment to contracts to feed schoolchildren.

Capital Metro also cited similar arguments last month in denying the Statesman’s records requests for information about applicants for the transit agency’s top job.

But the attorney general’s office rejected Austin’s claim that it was competing with even tiny cities such as Watauga and Sachse for qualified candidates and said competition for public employees is not a “competitive situation” under the law.

AUSTIN VS. WATAUGA? City claims competition to keep candidates secret

The Statesman sued the city for not releasing the information and, later, for leaving the location of a posted public meeting to try to avoid reporters while interviewing city manager candidates.

It’s unclear how the city will respond. Austin city spokesman David Green said only, “We are aware of the ruling and are evaluating next steps.” If the city still refuses to comply with the public information requests, it will have to sue the attorney general.

Statesman Executive Editor Debbie Hiott said it was encouraging that the attorney general’s office would not go along with the city’s “overly broad interpretation of competitive concerns” in releasing public information.

“Hopefully given this ruling the city staff will recognize the need for greater transparency going forward, and won’t allow themselves to be led by consultants into making decisions contrary to the public interest,” Hiott said.

The City Council last year voted unanimously to keep information about the city manager candidates secret until picking a finalist, upon the recommendation of search firm Russell Reynolds. The private-sector firm had never conducted a search for a city manager. The council later reversed itself and released six finalists’ names, after a bizarre episode in which council members raced away in vans to an airport terminal to try to stop Statesman reporters from staking out interviews.

WHAT HAPPENED? A van getaway, a maybe-illegal meeting, secret manager candidates

In addition to rejecting Austin’s Boeing argument, this week’s attorney general opinion also rejected arguments that application information was a Russell Reynolds trade secret or an intimate nonpublic matter.

Even some portions of information that might have been confidential will have to be released after the city included redactions in the information it sent to the attorney general for his opinion. The office said it couldn’t tell what the redactions had blacked out, thus, whatever it was is now presumed public.

The attorney general gave Austin permission to withhold information related to a U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration agent, but it’s unclear whether that person was a candidate for city manager or had some other relevance.

IN THEIR WORDS: Council members explain secrecy on city manager candidates

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Man arrested after road rage shooting involving Austin police officer, officials say
Man arrested after road rage shooting involving Austin police officer, officials say

Austin police have arrested a suspect who a Cottonwood Shores man said shot at his family and an off-duty Austin police officer in an apparent road rage incident in Burnet County. An off-duty Austin police officer stopped along RM 1431 during the November incident and intervened at the time, shooting and wounding the gunman, Austin police...
Texan gets panel’s nod for federal judge post over Democrats’ objections
Texan gets panel’s nod for federal judge post over Democrats’ objections

It has become a familiar scene at the Senate Judiciary Committee: A Texas nominee for a federal judicial post gets blasted by Democrats before being approved on a party-line vote. On Thursday, the committee, which includes both Texas GOP Sens. John Cornyn and Ted Cruz, considered the nomination of Matthew Kacsmaryk for a district judgeship in Amarillo...
Police: Man was racing when he crashed and killed 2 boys in Cedar Park
Police: Man was racing when he crashed and killed 2 boys in Cedar Park

An 18-year-old man arrested in the deaths of two young stepbrothers in a car crash last week in Cedar Park was racing when the wreck happened, police said Thursday. Hayden Michael Hammer was arrested and charged Thursday with two counts of racing on a highway causing death, a second-degree felony, Cedar Park police Cmdr. Bryan Wukasch said Thursday...
Anti-CodeNext PACs spend thousands to force vote
Anti-CodeNext PACs spend thousands to force vote

Campaign finance reports filed in Austin this week show that groups trying to put CodeNext on the ballot are raising and spending tens of thousands of dollars. Two special political action committees that are by and large against the city’s current revamping of the entire land use code, calling the effort “CodeWreck,” have spent roughly...
Mother, 8-month-old baby found dead in Taylor house after fire, officials say
Mother, 8-month-old baby found dead in Taylor house after fire, officials say

A mother and her 8-month-old baby were found dead Thursday inside their Taylor house after it caught fire, Taylor police officials said. Taylor police said they are investigating this as a suspicious death. Taylor firefighters were responding to an unrelated medical call when they saw smoke coming from the home at 2006 Brewer’s Place. Firefighters...
More Stories