What does overturn of ride-hailing rules mean for Austin?


Highlights

With state measure poised to override Austin’s ride-hailing rules, Lyft is already signing up drivers in city.

Nonprofit RideAustin says it will continue to comply with city rule on fingerprint-based background checks.

Uber and Lyft are set to return to Austin in the wake of state legislation passed Wednesday that nukes Austin’s ride-hailing regulations, but will Austinites vote with their wallets the way they did in an election last year to make the companies play by local rules?

Austinites who rely on cellphone apps to hail rides have endured a rocky two years of fighting over the city regulations, a failed election to overturn them, brief chaos after the two ride-hailing giants left last May and the ultimate rise of homegrown competitors.

Both Uber and Lyft left the city after refusing to comply with fingerprint-based criminal background checks for drivers, among other city regulations overturned by the Legislature’s newly passed bill. Representatives of both companies indicated they would restart Austin operations as soon as the bill is signed — which Gov. Greg Abbott indicated on Twitter will be “soon.”

RELATED: With Austin rules gone, Lyft drivers set to get back behind the wheel

Kirill Evdakov, co-founder and CEO of Fasten, said that asking whether his company will compete as well against Uber and Lyft is the wrong question.

“The right question is, ‘How will Uber and Lyft win back drivers and customers after leaving them high and dry last year?’” Evdakov said in an emailed statement. “We hope everyone will vote with their dollars for the ride hailing companies that have stepped up and provided safe, affordable and efficient mobility for the last year.”

Andy Tryba, CEO of Austin’s nonprofit ride-hailing service, RideAustin, said the organization would continue to operate under Austin’s current ride-hailing guidelines, including fingerprinting drivers, “because we feel it’s important to continue to honor the wishes of Austin’s voters.”

RideAustin will have to maintain an average pace of at least 20,000 rides per week to keep from shutting down, Tryba said. It currently averages 50,000 to 70,000 rides per week.

Mayor Steve Adler said Thursday, “My biggest disappointment is that the state government chose to override a local vote.”

“That said,” Adler added, “My goal from two years ago was to create a system where fingerprinting would be available in the marketplace so that people would have a material choice. I’m encouraged that some of the folks in the market now have expressed an intent to maintain that. It’ll be interesting to see if that gives them a competitive advantage.”

HOW WE GOT HERE: An interactive timeline on Austin’s ride-hailing election

The state bill leaves a gap between standards that apply to ride-hail operators and standards that apply to taxi cab companies, which are still subject to various city regulations.

Among other requirements, Austin taxi drivers still must undergo fingerprint-based background checks, and drivers are disqualified if they have ever been convicted of homicide, sexual assault, kidnapping or other serious crimes. State regulations will allow Lyft and Uber to instead use the name- and document-based background checks they prefer, and the only drivers who would be disqualified are registered sex offenders or people who have been convicted of certain crimes within the past seven years.

City transportation staff members refused to answer questions Thursday about what the bill, once signed, will mean for the city, including what Austin’s role will be in collecting ride-hailing data and how much revenue the city will lose from fees it previously charged for permits.

Adler said Austin will change its ride-hailing ordinance to conform to state law — though it will be overruled by state law — to eliminate confusion. He would also support looking at possible changes to city taxi regulations, but said it was too soon to tell which regulations the council might support eliminating.

“The intent was to treat everyone the same, but I don’t know,” he said. “I haven’t had any conversations about that.”

The state legislation still allows airports to regulate and permit drivers for ride-hailing services, and Austin-Bergstrom International Airport will continue to do so, spokesman Jim Halbrook said, though the airport will evaluate its requirements and fees. Once Abbott signs the bill, the airport will issue permits to any ride-hailing firms that receive valid state permits, he said.

RELATED: Adler open-minded, cab company skeptical about deregulation pitch

Adler noted that the city in general has been moving towards partially deregulating the taxi industry in the city. A staff memo last year suggested the city remove restrictions on the number of cabs and regulation of their fares, but still mandate the fingerprint-based background checks that Uber and Lyft fought against.

Ron Means, general manager of Austin Cab, shrugged off the Legislature’s actions on ride-hailing companies, saying it’s beyond his control and he considers ride-hailing companies different from taxis anyway. His only wish was that the Legislature would have taken a statewide ax to local taxi regulations, too, he said.

Means decried Austin’s regulations on things like how many taxis each company can operate. But he doesn’t support deregulation of fares, which he said would lead to chaos.

“Right now we have very peaceful operations, cab drivers not jumping out, shooting each other, hassling customers,” he said. “Do they want a fare war?”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Trump tweets approval after health care stocks ‘plunged’
Trump tweets approval after health care stocks ‘plunged’

It is unlike President Donald Trump to cheer when stocks fall, but early on Saturday he did just that.  “Health insurance stocks, which have gone through the roof during the ObamaCare years, plunged yesterday after I ended their Dems windfall!” he tweeted.  On Thursday, the administration announced it would stop paying subsidies...
Trump to meet Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte during Asian visit
Trump to meet Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte during Asian visit

President Donald Trump will meet with Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte during a marathon trip to Asia next month, the White House announced Monday.  "The President's travel will underscore his commitment to long-standing United States alliances and partnerships, and reaffirm United States leadership in promoting a free and open Indo-Pacific...
Bannon’s war on GOP could push tax overhaul over finish line
Bannon’s war on GOP could push tax overhaul over finish line

Here's a snapshot of the Republican Party's crisis of leadership: On Saturday, former White House adviser Stephen Bannon took the stage at the Values Voter Summit in Washington and exhorted conservative activists to join him in a war against Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., in order to unlock President Donald Trump's agenda. Also on Saturday...
Trump’s re-election campaign paid his son’s Russia-probe law firm $238,000
Trump’s re-election campaign paid his son’s Russia-probe law firm $238,000

President Donald Trump's re-election committee paid almost $238,000 in the third quarter to the law firm representing Donald Trump Jr. in connection with ongoing investigations of Russian interference in the 2016 election, according campaign finance disclosures.  Trump's campaign made two payments — one in mid July, the other in early August...
Trump campaign legal bills topped $1 million last quarter
Trump campaign legal bills topped $1 million last quarter

President Donald Trump's reelection committee spent more than $1 million on legal bills last quarter as investigations into Russian meddling in the 2016 election pressed on through the summer, according to a disclosure filed Sunday with the Federal Election Commission.  The filing shows the committee's "legal consulting" expenditures...
More Stories