Burnet County judge apologizes for ‘time for a tree and a rope’ comment


The top elected official in Burnet County commented on Facebook that it is “time for a tree and a rope” in a post about the African-American man accused of killing San Antonio police Det. Benjamin Marconi this weekend. County Judge James Oakley apologized for the comment Wednesday.

Oakley appears to have posted the comment Monday, after Otis Tyrone McKane was arrested and charged with killing Marconi. James Walker, a former reporter for the Burnet Bulletin who now works for the Weatherford Democrat newspaper outside Fort Worth, said he saw Oakley’s comment, took a screenshot of it and shared it Tuesday morning. The post no longer appears on Facebook.

Oakley said his comment was “off the cuff” and “indeed curt and harsh.”

“It is for that reason that I deleted it soon after posting and apologize for not being more thoughtful and comprehensive in my expression,” Oakley told the American-Statesman in an email. “What I should have posted, if anything, is a comment that more clearly reflects my opinion on the cowardly crime of the senseless murder of a law enforcement officer.”

His view of McKane “is the same regardless of ethnicity,” Oakley said.

“To be clear, I advocate due process,” Oakley said. “I also support the death penalty in cases where the ultimate crime has been committed and there is clear and complete evidence and where all steps of the judicial process have been respected. I would also point out that I am an administrative judge and do not preside over criminal court.”

In addition to presiding over a five-member commissioner’s court in Burnet County, Oakley is also on the Capital Area Metropolitan Planning Organization’s executive committee and on the boards of the Texas Commission on Law Enforcement and the Pedernales Electric Cooperative.

The PEC issued a statement Wednesday about Oakley’s comment, saying that the utility “does not condone any type of offensive language. Comments such as these are not a reflection of our cooperative values. We proudly welcome and serve all members.”

The blog PEC Truthwatch, run by Larry Landaker, who previously served on the Pedernales Electric Cooperative’s board, blogged about Oakley’s “tree and a rope” comment.

“What Mr. Oakley suggested was racist,” the blog post read. “A sitting County Judge in Texas has suggested that a black man accused of a crime … should be lynched. … There is no place on the PEC board of directors for an open racist. This is not political correctness. It is racism in its rawest form.”

Landaker has been an opponent of Oakley’s. In June, he argued in his blog that Oakley should not be re-elected to the PEC board.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Susan Steeg faces Democratic challenger in justice of the peace race
Susan Steeg faces Democratic challenger in justice of the peace race

Handling traffic citations, eviction or debt collection cases might not sound like the sexiest job on the ballot this March, but both Democratic Precinct 3 justice of the peace candidates said the job offers a unique chance to help residents. “Most people overlook JP court,” said Sylvia Holmes, associate director at the University of Texas&rsquo...
Four Republicans compete for Williamson County commissioner seat
Four Republicans compete for Williamson County commissioner seat

Four Republicans are competing for the chance to be Williamson County’s next Precinct 4 commissioner in the primary in March. Vying to face off against Democrat Carlos Salinas in November are Russ Boles, a commercial broker; David Marek, a truck driver for Williamson County’s Road and Bridge Division; Heather Peal, a managing partner of...
Court-at-Law No. 3 judge faces Democratic challenger
Court-at-Law No. 3 judge faces Democratic challenger

As Travis County faces racial disparities in its jails, both Democratic judicial candidates for Court-at-Law No. 3 said tackling the issue will be among the biggest challenges for the winner. This summer, the civil rights organization Grassroots Leadership revealed that, according to an analysis of 2015 jail booking data, African-Americans on average...
Austin’s paid sick leave ordinance a first in Texas
Austin’s paid sick leave ordinance a first in Texas

Just before 1 a.m. Friday, the Austin City Council voted in what could be described as the most progressive labor policy for the entire state and possibly the American South. At the behest of Council Member Greg Casar, the council made Austin the first city in Texas to require private employers to provide paid sick leave, a move that quickly garnered...
City Council approves plan to replace security boxes after burglaries

The Austin City Council approved a plan Thursday to replace the locks on security boxes in apartments and commercial buildings across the city, months after police investigators said one of the master keys first responders use for emergencies was likely stolen and used in burglaries. Per the council’s direction, the overhaul is not to exceed...
More Stories