Austin will keep city manager search a secret


Highlights

City Council members agreed not to release applicants, even finalists, until they’ve picked a favorite.

In the past Austin, and other peer cities, have allowed the public to weigh in on finalists.

Austin City Council members will not allow the public to know whom they are considering for a new city manager — even the finalists — until a final pick is named.

Under a process the council unanimously approved Thursday, search firm Russell Reynolds Associates will solicit public input early on what criteria it should look for in a successor to Marc Ott, who left the city in October.

The search firm will then recruit applicants and whittle down the list to five or 10 finalists. Council members will pick finalists and hold interviews behind closed doors.

The process is expected to take three to six months. Only when there is a single finalist will his or her name become public, as Russell Reynolds representative Stephen Newton recommended.

“On balance, what is absolutely critical for our city is to obtain the best, most innovative, forward-thinking city manager,” Council Member Ann Kitchen said. “The process for doing that would be best served by the recommendation.”

STAY ON TOP OF THE NEWS: Click here to sign up for our Breaking News emails

City manager is Austin’s most powerful position: This person oversees daily operations of all city departments and fulfills roles often designated to mayors in cities without a manager form of government. Elaine Hart, the city’s chief financial officer, is serving as interim city manager until Ott’s replacement is hired.

It’s common for cities searching for a new city manager to outsource the job to a search firm that keeps confidential information that would otherwise be public.

But it’s less common for cities to keep the entire process a secret. Dallas announced five finalists for its city manager job in November, before bringing them to the city individually to meet with council members and citizens. Fort Worth, likewise, named several finalists when it selected a new city manager in 2014. Other large Texas cities have done the same.

Before Austin hired Ott as city manager in 2008, city leaders released a list of eight semifinalists and held public forums with two finalists. Even then, the council faced criticism for the process being too secretive.

A couple of recent police chief and superintendent searches — including the Houston search that nabbed Police Chief Art Acevedo from Austin — have remained totally confidential. But Newton wasn’t aware of cities that have done the same thing for a manager.

Still, he defended the secrecy recommendation, saying it would draw a wider range of candidates because some people might not want their current employers to know they’re looking elsewhere.

Council members “don’t want us to be narrow in our focus,” he said. “It could be public servants from other types of organizations, be it city, state, county, federal. It could be any number of different backgrounds who have the qualifications.”

RELATED: Should city manager search seek government or corporate types?

Terrell Blodgett, a former University of Texas government professor, said he is concerned Austin isn’t being more open. Dallas and Amarillo both recently allowed public input on manager finalists with no indication it affected the quality of the candidates, he said.

“The council has taken months and years soliciting public input on CodeNext. They take weeks to decide a zoning case,” he told the Statesman. “I don’t know why they wouldn’t take public input on a manager.”

He noted that a city manager is likely to outlast most of the council members doing the hiring.

“It may be a council decision, but it ought to be a community consensus,” Blodgett said. “I wouldn’t call it a consensus if it’s a 21-day gun to the (public’s) head with a single candidate,” he said, referring to the time period between the announcement of the finalist and the official hiring offer.

Other local activists advocated for the secrecy provisions, arguing that the city should be trying to attract high-level business executives rather than career public servants.

“Let’s say you’re a $250,000 executive, and you’re happy where you are,” said Mike Levy, Texas Monthly’s former publisher, who advocates on city issues. “You’re not going to want anyone to know you’re looking.”

He argued public input on finalists adds nothing to the process.

“Ultimately, the council is going to go into executive session and hire who they think is best,” he said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Trial begins for six charged with rioting during Trump inauguration
Trial begins for six charged with rioting during Trump inauguration

During the opening minutes of the trial of six people charged with rioting during President Donald Trump's inauguration, a Washington, D.C., prosecutor described the scene as storefronts were smashed and a car set afire.  Assistant U.S. Attorney Jennifer Kerkhoff told jurors about a cafe owner whose shop windows were shattered by rocks, forcing...
ANALYSIS: From Charlie Rose to Donald Trump: 7 thorny questions for Washington on sexual harassment
ANALYSIS: From Charlie Rose to Donald Trump: 7 thorny questions for Washington on sexual harassment

Mega-journalist Charlie Rose. The New York Times' Glenn Thrush. Sen. Al Franken, D-Minn., again. The floodgates are open as (mostly) women are emboldened in this post-Harvey Weinstein era to share their stories of powerful men in politics, entertainment and elsewhere leveraging their power for sex.  Since Washington is supposed to set the tone...
White House: Trump didn’t mean what he said about leaving UCLA players in jail in China
White House: Trump didn’t mean what he said about leaving UCLA players in jail in China

At a briefing Monday, White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders said President Donald Trump was merely making a "rhetorical response to a criticism" by LaVar Ball when he tweeted of Ball's son LiAngelo and two UCLA teammates that he "should have left them in jail" in China. Sanders repeatedly claimed that Trump was "...
Billionaire Steyer light ups Times Square with ads seeking Trump impeachment
Billionaire Steyer light ups Times Square with ads seeking Trump impeachment

Tom Steyer, the billionaire environmentalist and Democratic mega-donor, said he's heading to the heart of New York City for the next step of his $20 million ad campaign urging the impeachment of President Donald Trump.  "We're putting a couple of large billboards in Times Square calling for the impeachment of the president," Steyer said...
Will your taxes go up or down? The five biggest questions on the GOP plan
Will your taxes go up or down? The five biggest questions on the GOP plan

The No. 1 question I get from readers lately is: How likely is the Republican tax plan to become law?  Compass Point, a research firm, puts the odds of the tax-cut bill making it to President Donald Trump's desk at 65 percent. Goldman Sachs, the investment bank that has a lot of alums in the White House, is telling clients the odds are now at...
More Stories