Austin police predict up to $30M hit if council won’t approve contract


Up to 300 veteran officers could retire if council doesn’t approve police contract, police officials say

Officers stand to lose up to 1,700 hours of accrued sick time if labor agreement isn’t approved.

With a looming Austin City Council vote, police officials have begun preparing for the possibility that dozens of officers could retire by the end of the year, bringing an unexpected financial burden of millions of dollars.

Council members will vote next Wednesday on whether to approve the new labor agreement with officers that would continue an often-debated benefit under which officers are paid for up to 1,700 hours in unused sick time — the equivalent of about nine months’ pay.

If they do not approve the agreement, interim Police Chief Brian Manley and union officials say they fear officers eligible to retire will do so before the current agreement expires Dec. 29 so they may receive the sick leave pay, which could be lost if they continue working for the city without a labor agreement.

The City Council could also ask city officials to extend the current police contract and go back to the negotiating table. Union officials said they believe that’s an unlikely scenario, but the council took that route this year when Austin-Travis County Emergency Medical Services’ contract negotiations came to an impasse.

In a worst-case scenario, up to 300 officers with more than 20 years of service would retire, and the total payout would be about $30 million.

“My concern is that if the contract is not ratified and we do see a good portion of those officers eligible to retire take that option, we lose a lot of ground we have made up this year in terms of our staffing challenges,” Manley told the American-Statesman and KVUE-TV on Wednesday.

Contract critics say discussions about the possibility of retirements is part of a police strategy to incite fear to sway council votes.

READ: Critics pan police union contracts

Unlike previous contracts that have passed with few objections from council leaders and community groups, the current proposal has drawn questions and scrutiny about whether citizens benefit enough from the agreement, raising the possibility that it might fail in next week’s vote. Last week, the city’s public safety commission, which makes recommendations to the council, voted in favor of the contract.

Some groups, including the Austin Justice Coalition, contend that the agreement does not provide enough oversight of police, that it does not provide for greater transparency and that officers are already the highest paid in the state.

However, police union and some city officials say that under such contracts, a civilian oversight group has unprecedented access to records in police shootings and that it gives the department greater flexibility in hiring to promote diversity.

If the contract fails, the department would operate under state civil service law, with officers hired and promoted based solely on written exams. The City Council would dictate how much officers are paid.

“Even though there is a large pool of retirees, I don’t think that pool is going to do this mass exodus,” said Chas Moore, the coalition’s director. “I don’t see that even being a real thing, and even if it is, I think that is just part of the process of trying something new. Growing pains come with not doing the same thing, but at the end of the day, I don’t see that happening.”

Ken Casaday, the Austin police union president, said the possibility of officers retiring before year’s end should be enough reason for the council to support the contract.

“The right thing is to pass this contract,” he said.

THE LATEST: Public Safety Commission endorses police contract

According to Manley, 149 officers across all ranks have 23 or more years of service, which means they are eligible to retire. If all of them retired before the end of the contract, the estimated costs for their “terminal pay,” including sick time payouts, would reach $16.2 million.

In addition, Manley said 158 more officers have 20 years of service and could pay to become eligible for retirement. If all of them did, that cost would reach $15.6 million, he said.

The department has about 1,900 sworn officers.

“These are the extremes,” Manley said. “You just don’t know where it falls within the range of the 149 who are eligible, how many of them would in fact leave.”

Manley said depending on the number of departures, the department might have to add to its patrols by reassigning detectives to the street. The department has implemented that strategy during staffing shortages in the past, including earlier this year before the graduation of a new cadet class.

“We realize that we do not have then number of detectives needed to adequately handle the current case load,” he said. “When we redeploy them to patrol, those cases sit idle waiting for them to return to their assigned duties.”

Manley said it also is possible that the department could have to pay officers overtime to ensure enough are on the street.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Politics

Eckhardt, Shea draw no challengers as local 2018 races come into focus
Eckhardt, Shea draw no challengers as local 2018 races come into focus

Travis County Judge Sarah Eckhardt, Commissioner Brigid Shea and a handful of other county officials essentially clinched new terms this week after no one filed to run against them in the 2018 elections. District Clerk Velva Price, County Clerk Dana DeBeauvoir and County Treasurer Dolores Ortega Carter also drew no challengers before the filing deadline...
Lawmakers call for investigation into Trump sexual misconduct allegations
Lawmakers call for investigation into Trump sexual misconduct allegations

More than 100 Democratic lawmakers are calling on the House Oversight Committee to investigate allegations of sexual misconduct levied against President Donald Trump, a group of female U.S. representatives said at a news conference Tuesday. More than a dozen women have accused the president of forced kissing, unwanted groping and making inappropriate...
Trump vows Americans will return to the moon. The question is how?
Trump vows Americans will return to the moon. The question is how?

Once again, the Trump administration has pledged to restore America’s leadership in space by teaming with the private sector and returning to the moon. Speaking at a White House ceremony Monday, President Donald Trump offered high ambitions, but few specifics in signing a new space policy directive that had no timeline and promised no funding...
Alabama dad criticizes Roy Moore in memory of his gay daughter
Alabama dad criticizes Roy Moore in memory of his gay daughter

An Alabama father who said that his daughter took her life because “she didn’t want to be gay anymore” stood outside Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore’s rally in Midland City on Monday to urge people not to vote for the former judge. Photos from the rally showed peanut farmer and Midland City native Nathan Mathis holding a...
Roy Moore would be a ‘threat’ to teenage pages at the Capitol, congresswoman says
Roy Moore would be a ‘threat’ to teenage pages at the Capitol, congresswoman says

Controversial Alabama judge and U.S. Senate hopeful Roy Moore would pose a threat to the teenagers who work as pages in the Senate if he is elected, a congresswoman said.  The unusual warning about a potential incoming senator was revealed Monday in a letter sent Friday by Rep. Gwen Moore, D-Wis., to the administrative body that runs the Senate...
More Stories