You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to myStatesman.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks

X

Welcome to myStatesman.com

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on myStatesman.com.

Statesman analysis: Texas A-F school grades give boost to charters


Highlights

Many traditional public schools said the A-F accountability system is too vague and stigmatizes them.

A lower percentage of charter schools earned a failing grade than their traditional public school peers.

Under current accountability system, charters more likely to have at least 1 failing mark than public schools.

Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, an ardent school choice supporter, said that the A-F system is here to stay.

Critics of the new A-F grading system for Texas schools have long warned that the state’s letter grades would give an undeserved boost to charter schools.

An American-Statesman analysis of the advisory A-F grades issued this month shows that charter schools did fare better compared with their traditional public school peers under the letter grade system than they did under the state’s old ratings.

The advisory grades show how schools and districts would have performed for the 2015-16 school year if the A-F rating system already had been in place. Under the existing accountability system, charter schools that year were slightly more likely to have at least one failing mark than traditional public schools.

But traditional schools — not charters — were more likely to fail under the new letter grades, even though data from the same year were used to calculate them, the Statesman analysis shows.

Just as defenders of traditional public schools had feared, the results of the advisory grades have emboldened those who support school choice — a blanket term for efforts to use public dollars to pay for alternatives to traditional public schools.

“Public education is at a crossroads. There are active people trying to truly dismantle the public education system in order to encourage privatization of our public schools, therefore incorporate charters or vouchers. Do I think it’s part of a larger dynamic of harming our public schools? Definitely,” said state Rep. Mary González, D-Socorro, who has proposed legislation to repeal the A-F system.

The letter grades released this month are a snapshot to give schools and the public a taste of how the new A-F system will work when it’s finalized next year. The letter grades aren’t punitive or official, and the accountability ratings released in August still stand.

While many charter schools aren’t opposing the A-F system, traditional public schools for months have complained that the plan should be repealed, arguing that the letter grades provide little meaningful information to guide student learning and are meant to make traditional public schools look bad.

Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, who has named passing school choice legislation one of his top priorities during the legislative session, said Wednesday that the A-F system is here to stay and this month’s grades show why school choice is so important.

“We will not repeal A to F. We finally have an accountability system, and, boy, are they running for the hills,” Patrick said during an event hosted by the right-leaning Texas Public Policy Foundation think tank.

The A-F system, passed by the Legislature in 2015, is based largely — 55 percent — on state standardized test performance. The Texas Education Agency is expected to make some tweaks to the system before it’s put into official use, but as it stands now, schools and districts are graded in four areas:

• How students perform on the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness.

• How students improve on the STAAR year over year.

• How well students are prepared for careers and college after high school

• How campuses and school districts close performance gaps between low-income and higher-income students.

At least 16 other states have adopted similar letter grade rating systems, but there’s been considerable pushback from Texas school districts. At least 150 school districts, including Austin, Bastrop and Dripping Springs, have passed resolutions calling on lawmakers to trash the letter grade rating system.

It’s not clear why charter schools did better under the A-F system than the current system, but traditional public school advocates said that charter schools tend to “cherry pick” the students they admit and focus their coursework on doing well on standardized tests.

David Dunn, head of the Texas Charter Schools Association, says that’s not the case, pointing out that many charter schools also performed poorly in the A-F advisory ratings.

“We’re encouraged by the fact that there are fewer campuses compared to traditional ISDs at the D or F level,” Dunn said. “But stepping back, bigger picture, none of us can be terribly pleased with the results. This rating system shows that the education system in Texas — writ large, whether you’re in a charter or in a traditional school district, there’s a lot of room for improvement, and we’ve all got a lot of work to do.”

IDEA charter school campuses in Austin did fairly well, achieving two A’s and no failing grades. Executive Director Larkin Tackett said that while the new system might be imperfect, it meets the bar for how all decisions should be made, which is by determining what is best for students and their families. The state’s results track with IDEA’s internal benchmarking, he said.

“This is telling us we can do better and we need to develop better strategies, not that the system is rigged or is so bad that we’re going to ignore it,” Tackett said.

The charter KIPP Austin Public Schools for years had strong marks under the state’s systems, but didn’t fare as well under A-F, receiving eight unacceptable grades at its nine schools. But Executive Director Steven Epstein said overall, KIPP welcomes such measures that help provide accountability and transparency to the public.

“Communities and families deserve to have as much information as possible to make the best possible choices for their students’ education,” Epstein said. “We use state accountability as well as other indicators to inform our work and accomplish our mission of getting students to and through college.”

Statesman data reporter Dan Hill contributed to this story.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Bill would give residents final say in whether they’re annexed
Bill would give residents final say in whether they’re annexed

Tim Mattox, an 18-year resident of River Place and member of the homeowners association board, dreads the day that he and his neighbors in the master-planned community near Northwest Austin will be officially absorbed into the city and begin receiving its hefty tax bills. Despite pushback over the past decade from residents like Mattox — who...
Storms bring cooler weather to Austin, destruction to North Texas
Storms bring cooler weather to Austin, destruction to North Texas

At least five people were killed when a violent storm raced across North Texas Saturday night, however the Austin metro area was mostly spared with only some slight rain and hail that brought significantly cooler temperatures Sunday morning followed by sunny skies. The National Weather Service has confirmed that three tornadoes touched down around...
Community news: Recycling research to be shared May 8

TRAVIS COUNTY EAST AUSTIN Recycling research shared The public is invited to an interactive presentation of the city of Austin’s new recycling tools from 6:30 to 8 p.m. May 8 at the Carver Branch Library at 1161 Angelina St. The presentation is being done by Austin’s Design, Technology and Innovation Fellows, in partnership with Austin...
Education nonprofit pushes entrepreneurship programs to older students
Education nonprofit pushes entrepreneurship programs to older students

Junior Achievement, the 98-year old nonprofit that teaches students about the economy and business, is having a rebirth in Central Texas schools with the goal of preparing more young people for Austin’s entrepreneurial culture. “When we relaunched two years ago, we knew we had to focus on what this community needed the most,” said...
Latest numbers show rising use of Austin-area toll roads
Latest numbers show rising use of Austin-area toll roads

The four toll roads in the Austin area operated by the Texas Department of Transportation, after having sparse traffic when they first opened a decade ago, have seen steadily increasing use. Based on figures from the first six months of the 2016-17 fiscal year, here are five things to know about the growing revenue of the Central Texas Turnpike System...
More Stories