You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to myStatesman.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks

X

Welcome to myStatesman.com

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on myStatesman.com.

Greg Abbott in tussle over ‘sexting’ ruling


Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott has asked the state’s highest criminal court to reconsider an October ruling that tossed out a law banning sexually explicit cyberchats between adults and minors — a move that ignited a legal turf war over one of Abbott’s signature issues in office.

Abbott argued that his office hadn’t been notified, as required by state law, that a state law had been challenged as unconstitutional. The oversight deprived Abbott of the opportunity to defend the law, a key responsibility of the office, he said.

But Lisa McMinn, the state prosecuting attorney, asked the Court of Criminal Appeals to disregard Abbott’s request, arguing that there was no obligation to notify Abbott about a case he was powerless to join.

McMinn told the court that only local prosecutors and her office, created in 1923 to handle criminal appellate matters for Texas, may represent the state in appeals involving criminal cases. Abbott, who represents Texas in civil court matters, cannot intervene in an ongoing criminal case unless invited by a local prosecutor — and Abbott received no such offer in the case, she said.

Beyond objecting to Abbott’s intervention, however, McMinn didn’t comment on the merits of the attorney general’s request.

Abbott, who has made protecting children from cyberexploitation a focus of his time in office and a key issue in his campaign for Texas governor, told the court that its ruling endangered 20 cases his office had prosecuted or is prosecuting under the voided 2005 law. Spokesman Jerry Strickland said two of those cases, in which North Texas men solicited minors online, had to be dropped recently because of the decision.

“These are troubling cases with suspects that pose a danger to children and communities, however, due to the Court of Criminal Appeals ruling, these two cases could not be prosecuted,” he said.

The cases make up a fraction of the 340 arrests for child sex crimes — predominantly child pornography or solicitation of a minor — that Abbott’s office said it has taken part in since 2003.

The law prohibited adults from engaging minors in sexually explicit online communication with the intent of sexual gratification, often called “sexting.” The third-degree felony was punishable by up to 10 years in prison until the Court of Criminal Appeals declared, in a 9-0 decision on Oct. 30, that the law violated free-speech protections because it wasn’t narrowly written to meet its goals.

Texas children are protected from online predators by other laws, including statutes banning solicitation, obscenity, harassment and the distribution of harmful materials to minors, the court ruled. What’s more, the law went too far by encompassing “a whole cornucopia” of titillating talk — including sexually explicit literature such as “Lolita,” “50 Shades of Grey” and Shakespeare’s “Troilus and Cressida,” the court said.

The ruling dismissed an indictment against John Christopher Lo, who was arrested in January 2010 and accused of sending sexually explicit text messages to a student he met while serving as choir director in the Clear Creek school district in suburban Houston.

Lo, 49 when he was arrested, had exchanged texts eliciting details of the 15-year-old boy’s sexual exploits, prosecutors allege.

Abbott responded with a motion for rehearing — a formal request for the court’s nine judges to reconsider their decision.

Such requests are routinely denied and, when granted, tend to result in the court clarifying — but not changing — its original ruling.

Still, the Harris County district attorney’s office also requested a rehearing, arguing that the court was mistaken when it said adults could be prosecuted under similar laws. No criminal law covers sexting, titillating electronic messages that don’t include photos, Harris County District Attorney Devon Anderson told the court.

“This court’s opinion will be construed to hold that (sexting) is now constitutionally protected speech. Is that what this court intended?” Anderson said.

Mark Bennett, Lo’s lawyer, opposed reopening the appeal.

In a brief to the court, Bennett said Lo’s challenge to the law was no secret. The 1st Court of Appeals in Houston issued a public opinion denying Lo’s challenge in 2011, and the Court of Criminal Appeals announced in early 2013 that it would review Lo’s case, he said.

A new hearing should be denied, Bennett argued, because Abbott was either aware of the case but declined to act, or he displayed a “lack of diligence” in keeping abreast of important court matters.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Austin Fire Department video shows lieutenant getting pie in the face

The Austin Fire Department had some fun with a well-known prankster at one of its fire stations recently. While Austin fire Lt. Jerry Cohen gave an on-camera interview for the 100 Club of Central Texas, a firefighter sneaked up behind him and hit him square in the face with a pie tray full of shaving cream. AFD posted a video of the prank to its ...
Woman arrested on disorderly charge at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago
Woman arrested on disorderly charge at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago

Police arrested a Florida woman Friday on a disorderly intoxication charge at Mar-a-Lago after Palm Beach police said she tried to rush toward a Secret Service-restricted zone inside the club and was talking to empty cars. Amanda Ayres Kerwin, 37, is charged with disorderly intoxication and resisting arrest without violence, both misdemeanors, according...
Man stabbed during fight over loud music, police say
Man stabbed during fight over loud music, police say

 An Ohio man has been accused of stabbing his roommate after an alleged fight over loud music. Wayne Skaggs, 53 of Springfield, appeared in Clark County Municipal Court on Monday on a felonious assault charge. He pleaded not guilty. Police alleged he stabbed Doug Vance, also of Springfield, on March 16. According to court records, Skaggs allegedly...
Senate sends abortion insurance bill to House

Voting 21-10, the Texas Senate on Monday approved a bill to ban insurance coverage for abortions in the state. Senate Bill 20 by state Sen. Larry Taylor, R-Friendswood, would prohibit abortion coverage in private plans, under the Affordable Care Act and in state-issued insurance plans, except for medical emergencies. Those interested in abortion coverage...
JUST IN: Officials ID toddler killed after being hit in Northeast Austin neighborhood
JUST IN: Officials ID toddler killed after being hit in Northeast Austin neighborhood

Officials have identified the toddler who police say was hit and killed by a van driver in Northeast Austin on Saturday afternoon. The girl, 14-month-old Alyssa Nicol Juarez-Ruiz, died soon after she was taken to Dell Children’s Medical Center, the Travis County medical examiner’s office said. She died from blunt force trauma...
More Stories