Fate of Texas abortion law now in judge’s hands


State law promotes respect for fetal life, Texas lawyer says.

Abortion providers argue that the law subjects women to untested, unnecessary and risky procedures.

The fate of a Texas law regulating second-trimester abortions is in a federal judge’s hands after a five-day trial in Austin ended Wednesday evening with sharp disagreement over the law’s impact.

A lawyer for Texas argued that the law, passed by the Legislature in May as part of Senate Bill 8, merely requires abortion doctors to ensure fetal demise before starting a second trimester abortion procedure known as dilation and evacuation, or D&E, in which “forceps are used to tear apart the baby.”

“The state has a legitimate interest in banning the living dismemberment of an unborn child,” said Darren McCarty with the Texas attorney general’s office. “All SB 8 does is regulate the moment of death, the moment of fetal termination, and nothing more.”

A lawyer for several Texas abortion providers disagreed, arguing Wednesday that the law places doctors in the untenable position of subjecting patients to untested, invasive and risky procedures to attempt fetal demise or face going to prison for violating the law.

RELATED: Texas abortion law targets ‘brutal’ procedure, doctor testifies

Injecting toxins into the fetus via a four-inch needle inserted through the abdomen or vagina raises the risk of infection, bleeding and other health problems and can fail to cause fetal demise in some cases, requiring additional risky steps, lawyer Janet Crepps said.

“SB 8 will turn back the clock on advances in medical care that have made D&E abortions the safest, most common second-trimester procedure,” Crepps said. “The state can’t regulate abortion by making a procedure less safe for the woman.”

In addition, Crepps said, D&E abortions take place after the 15th week of pregnancy, but injected toxins are not used earlier than the 18th week, leaving doctors to use untested methods of fetal demise.

Doctors should not act without controlled scientific studies to assess the risks and benefits of the injections, she said, but Texas is instead requiring “physicians to proceed into uncharted territory and hope for the best.”

Crepps urged U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel to toss out the law as unconstitutional.

Yeakel, given hundreds of pages of exhibits to wade through, did not indicate when he would issue a written opinion but acknowledged that “these are hard cases for the court to consider.”

During closing arguments Wednesday, Yeakel pressed the lawyers to focus on whether the law creates an “undue burden” on access to abortion.

“When we deal with cases with political ramifications, it can be difficult to get through beliefs and get down to the legal issues,” he said.

RELATED: Texas abortion law adds risk for patients, doctors testify

McCarty disputed abortion providers’ claims that the methods of fetal demise were risky and difficult to administer, adding that laws making abortions more costly or difficult to get do not impose an undue burden on access for women.

The Supreme Court has long said that states can impose regulations that protect the health of women and “promote respect for life, including the life of the unborn,” as long as access to abortion is not improperly limited, he said.

“The question is: Can Texas require that a fully formed and nearly viable human child be accorded a more humane manner of death?” McCarty said.

Crepps said the law requiring fetal demise would force doctors to stop providing D&E abortions or severely limit the procedure, hampering access for patients after 15 weeks of pregnancy. The requirement also would raise costs and require an extra office visit, making it “difficult if not impossible” for low-income women to afford the procedure, take time off work and find child care, she said.

The risks far outweigh the benefits — the definition of undue burden, Crepps said.

At the urging of abortion providers, Yeakel temporarily blocked the Texas law on Aug. 31, one day before it was to take effect, and set a follow-up hearing for mid-September.

Both sides agreed to wait until this month so a full-scale trial could be held. As part of the agreement, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton said the regulation will not be enforced until Nov. 22 to give Yeakel time to issue a written opinion.

No matter how Yeakel rules, the losing side will appeal, creating the possibility for a precedent-setting ruling by the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals — which oversees Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi — and possibly the Supreme Court.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Truck driver behind viral anti-Trump bumper sticker adds one more
Truck driver behind viral anti-Trump bumper sticker adds one more

The Texas driver of a truck sporting a large anti-Trump window decal has made room for one more. As KHOU reports, the truck’s owner, Karen Fonseca, added a second decal to her truck, which reads, “(EXPLETIVE) TROY NEHLS AND (EXPLETIVE) YOU FOR VOTING FOR HIM.” Nehls serves as the sheriff for Fort Bend County and earlier this...
BREAKING: AISD moves to sell headquarters to developer, Baker Center to Alamo Drafthouse
BREAKING: AISD moves to sell headquarters to developer, Baker Center to Alamo Drafthouse

Austin school leaders are moving forward with the high-profile sales of district headquarters, the Baker Center and the Millett Opera House (home of the Austin Club), among other surplus properties. The school board on Nov. 27 is scheduled to vote on the sales of the following properties: • the Carruth Center, the 2.7 acre district headquarters...
Carter ‘shocked, outraged’ after Statesman report on Temple VA abuses
Carter ‘shocked, outraged’ after Statesman report on Temple VA abuses

U.S. Rep. John Carter sent a letter to Department of Veterans Affairs Director David Shulkin on Monday demanding answers regarding findings of abuse of veterans, equipment theft, abuse of power and potential financial crimes at the VA’s Temple campus. On Sunday, the American-Statesman detailed the results of an internal investigation into issues...
Austin student to dance in Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade performance
Austin student to dance in Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade performance

A charter school student from Austin will share his passion for dance in front of millions of viewers nationwide at the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. Eli Hernandez, a 17-year-old junior at East Austin College Prep, was selected to perform as a one of four male dancers with Spirit of America Productions at this year’s parade through the...
COMMUNITY NEWS: ‘Be a Santa to a Senior’ program seeks donations

CENTRAL TEXAS Santa program for seniors seeks donors The Home Instead Senior Care office, serving North Austin, Round Rock and Sun City, is seeking donations that will be provided to seniors through its Be a Santa to a Senior program. Trees for the program will be on display through Dec. 15 at Walmart locations at 1548 FM 685, Pflugerville; 4700 E...
More Stories