With millions in precious metals missing in Austin, a mother steps up


When tens of millions of dollars’ worth of gold and silver bullion were discovered to be missing from a downtown Austin vault last summer, suspicion quickly fell on the owner of Bullion Direct, the company investors thought was keeping their precious metals safe. It appeared that Charles McAllister had either absconded with or misused their treasure for his own financial gain.

Now, as his company seeks to emerge from bankruptcy court a year later, an unusual last-ditch plan to repay the creditors is underway. McAllister’s mother has offered to purchase her son’s old company and turn over most of any future profits to creditors.

Attorneys involved in the case acknowledge the arrangement is peculiar. After all, McAllister apparently remains under federal investigation in connection with the missing metal and cash, now estimated at $25 million, at least.

But, the lawyers say, the deal is the best — and perhaps only — hope for creditors to recover any of their lost money. And the parents “are trying to do something right,” said Duane Brescia, the Austin attorney representing Cheryl Huseman and her husband, Jack Murph.

Still, the close family connection has raised suspicions. Many of those whose glittering savings vanished continue to believe McAllister has their metal stashed somewhere.

“I think a lot of people walked off with a lot of bullion,” said Ron Barbala, a Phoenix investor whose 437 ounces of gold, silver, palladium and platinum seem to have evaporated from Bullion Direct’s safe.

If McAllister’s mother “succeeds and does as well as she hopes, creditors will get millions of dollars,” said Joshua Gibbons, whose website, about.ag, has closely tracked the case. (Ag is the chemical designation for silver.) “But,” he noted, “so will she.”

Joe Martinec, hired to shepherd Bullion Direct through the bankruptcy, said some of the 550 creditors have questioned whether it might even be possible that McAllister’s parents were buying the company with the money he is alleged to have taken.

Both he and Brescia dispute that, however, saying the parents mortgaged their house to raise $200,000. Half of that is to go into a trust account for creditors. The other half will be used to purchase software McAllister developed to use on his website as a trading platform for precious metals. It allows buyers and sellers to connect online to trade their gold and silver.

According to the terms of the arrangement, the new company, Platform Universe LLC, will earn money from transaction fees, similar to eBay. At first, 80 percent of the proceeds would go to repaying the creditors. Later, that percentage would drop to 50 percent.

Over the years, Bullion Direct boasted an estimated 60,000 customers, and the company’s trustee, Dan Bensimon, has described the trading platform as a viable business. Brescia and Martinec both say McAllister’s parents won’t manage the new company at all. Charles McAllister’s lawyer, Randy Leavitt, said his client will have no involvement in the new business, either. Creditors are scheduled to vote on the plan next month.

News of Bullion Direct’s missing metal arrived suddenly last July. Investors from across the country who’d purchased precious metal, primarily gold and silver, and thought it was being stored in a safe on the 14th floor of an Austin office tower logged onto Bullion Direct’s website only to see an announcement that the company had declared bankruptcy.

When they scrambled to recover their treasure, it was gone. By the time auditors and lawyers got access to the company’s offices, there were only a handful of gold and silver coins in an office safe.

In court filings, McAllister has claimed he told investors that their precious metals might not actually exist in his safe, although their value was kept on his books. He said he had permission to use money from the metal sales to invest in his company and to pay for business expenses.

(One expense rankling those who lost money with Bullion Direct: McAllister’s salary. Court documents show he paid himself more than $300,000 a year — not including a $36,000 severance package he awarded himself only weeks before filing for bankruptcy protection.)

Martinec said permission to use investors’ money might have appeared in the small print of a disclaimer posted somewhere. Yet it also seems unlikely that those keeping their wealth in metals would have willingly agreed to such an arrangement. That clashes with the philosophy of many gold and silver bugs, who depend on the precious metals’ physicality to protect them against an economy they believe stands on an unsteady scaffolding of paper and hope.

“I certainly understand how defrauded they feel,” he said. “If you went to your account, you would have reasonably believed the gold listed there was in a vault some place.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

What Central Texas has learned since devastating 2011 wildfire season
What Central Texas has learned since devastating 2011 wildfire season

Looking on as wildfires razed hundreds of thousands of acres in Northern California last month, Central Texas fire officials, no strangers to such disasters, said they remain ready for the next big, inevitable blaze. After all, Texas had its own wake-up call in 2011 after the Bastrop Complex Fire burned more than 34,000 acres and destroyed...
Court rejects defense lawyer Adam Reposa’s bid for early jail release
Court rejects defense lawyer Adam Reposa’s bid for early jail release

Denied bail as he serves six months in jail for contempt of court, Austin defense lawyer Adam Reposa could stay behind bars for most — if not all — of his sentence before he gets the chance to tell an appeals court that a judge botched his case. Reposa’s lawyer, Keith Hampton, said his client has been treated “uniquely&rdquo...
JUST IN: Small fire chars Iron Works barbecue joint; no injuries reported
JUST IN: Small fire chars Iron Works barbecue joint; no injuries reported

Austin fire officials said a heat source being too close to combustible materials caused a small fire at the Iron Works barbecue restaurant in downtown Austin on Friday. Firefighters initially reported a small fire in the wall of the restaurant, located at 100 Red River St., around 11:30 a.m., the Austin Fire Department said. Although the restaurant...
COMMUNITY NEWS: Georgetown to break ground on new civic campus Tuesday
COMMUNITY NEWS: Georgetown to break ground on new civic campus Tuesday

TRAVIS COUNTY AUSTIN Parks department presents Christmas play The Austin Parks and Recreation Department will present “People of Color Christmas,” an original, comedic play written by Vietnamese-American playwright Christine Hoang and directed by Rudy Ramirez. Showtimes will be at 8 p.m. Dec. 1-2 at the Asian American Resource Center, 8401...
2 men wounded in overnight shooting in North Austin, police say
2 men wounded in overnight shooting in North Austin, police say

Austin police responded to a shooting in North Austin early Friday that wounded two men. The shooting occurred in the 9600 block of North Lamar Boulevard, just north of Rundberg Lane sometime before 12:30 a.m. Friday, which was when Austin police said via Twitter that officers were at the scene. One of the men had injuries not considered to be life-threatening...
More Stories