breaking news

Senate leaders agree on plan to reopen government

Sharp-tongued federal Judge Sam Sparks steps back, takes senior status


Judge Robert Pitman replaces Sparks in Austin, creating vacancy in San Antonio that President Trump must fill.

Sparks once invited lawyers to a ‘kindergarten party’ for basic legal education over their improper subpoenas.

Longtime U.S. District Judge Sam Sparks, who has built a career with policy-forming decisions and colorful barbs from the bench, has dialed back his caseload by taking senior status, a member of his staff told the American-Statesman on Wednesday.

The transition became effective on Sunday, creating a vacancy in Austin that will be filled by Robert Pitman, appointed in 2014, who had been splitting his time between Austin and San Antonio.

As a result of the shift, President Donald Trump must appoint a judge to the bench in San Antonio.

“Judge Sparks is and will continue to be an integral member of the federal judiciary in Austin,” Pitman said in a statement. “Senior status will simply give him more control over the caseload he takes, and the ability to focus on things other than his work for a change.”

READ: Adler blasts ICE director’s threat to jail local elected officials

Sparks, 78, has presided over federal criminal and civil cases in Austin since his 1991 appointment by President George H.W. Bush. Last year, he ruled on a battle over a state abortion law in which he blocked Texas from requiring that fetal remains be buried or cremated. In August, he tossed out a lawsuit against Austin and Travis County over Senate Bill 4, which penalizes cities and counties that decline to help enforce federal immigration laws, siding against Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton who had tried to get the law declared constitutional before it was set to go into effect in September. That case is pending in the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Known for his no-nonsense approach, Sparks’ razor tongue has bruised the egos of many lawyers who openly fear being viewed by the judge as unprepared for court. In 2007, he invited lawyers who had served improper subpoenas to what he called a “kindergarten party,” ripping them for being unable to practice law “at the level of a first-year law student.”

But Sparks’ abrasiveness extends to others who step into his courtroom. At a Title IX hearing last year on a lawsuit brought by a University of Texas student, Sparks delivered choice words for university President Gregory L. Fenves, calling it “absurd” to suggest, like Fenves had in a UT decision, that intoxication equals incapacitation. The lawsuit was settled when UT agreed to let the student back into school. At a different 2017 hearing, Sparks told Temple police officers to “grow up” when they requested jail time for a fellow officer who had tipped off a suspect about a drug bust. Sparks sentenced the officer to probation.

READ: Herman: Appeals Judge Willett to take colleagues’ ‘Twitter temperature’

In a 2015 survey of Austin bar members, 118 lawyers were quizzed on Sparks’ temperament, with 47 percent saying it needs improvement. It was the second-lowest score of the 44 judges on the survey. But the same group of lawyers praised his work ethic, with 72 percent giving it an excellent grade and 20 percent an acceptable grade.

Travis County prosecutor Keith Henneke, who was a law clerk for Sparks from 2007 to 2009, said the judge took time out of his day to train clerks to be better lawyers.

“He made a great impact on the law, not only in Austin and in Texas, but nationally,” Henneke said. “He is the epitome of a judge, someone who required attorneys to do their best and who appreciated good attorneys and who always tried to follow the law and do what was right and fair even if he didn’t agree personally with the outcome. He’s known as very tough and gruff on the bench, but working for him in chambers was a delight.”

Sparks declined, through a staff member, to comment for this story.

In his new role, Sparks is expected to handle about 15 percent of the courts’ workload annually. Two other U.S. district judges, Pitman and Lee Yeakel, will handle the bulk of the work.

Sparks will keep his annual salary of $205,100.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Florida man wrestles, wrangles gator outside his home
Florida man wrestles, wrangles gator outside his home

What does a southwest Florida man do when a gator gets too close to his home? He wrangles it. Michael Stauffer, of Bokeelia, told Fox 4 that when an alligator got too comfy crawling around his backyard, he grabbed a broom and towel, jumped on its back and wrangled it. He wrapped the towel around its snout and duct-taped it shut.  He then...
Killing of Alabama housewife reveals secret life on internet
Killing of Alabama housewife reveals secret life on internet

The killing of an Alabama housewife outside her suburban home on Jan. 13 revealed signs of a double life on the internet, several news outlets have reported. The body of 42-year-old Kathleen Dawn West was found outside her Calera, Alabama, home, WTVT reported. Calera Police Chief Sean Lemley said his department is treating the case as a homicide...
Michigan doctor who came to US in 1979 detained by ICE
Michigan doctor who came to US in 1979 detained by ICE

A Michigan doctor who came to the United States nearly 40 years ago has been detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, WXMI reported. Lukasz Niec, who works at Bronson Healthcare in Kalamazoo, came to the United States from Poland with his parents in 1979. His family said Niec had a green card and permanent legal resident status...
Body found burned in Bastrop County last week
Body found burned in Bastrop County last week

The Bastrop County sheriff’s office is investigating a suspicious death after a body was found burned on the side of the road Thursday, authorities said. Donald Ray Davis, 23, of Austin was found dead around 6 a.m. on Jan. 18 on the north end of North Pope Bend Road, Bastrop County Sheriff Maurice Cook said. His body was burned, however Cook...
UPDATE: 15-year-old girl injured during shooting at Italy, Texas high school

10:40 a.m. update: An official with the Ellis County Sheriff's Office says a 15-year-old girl was injured in the shooting at Italy High School. Sgt. Joe Fitzgerald says the student, who suffered a gunshot wound, was airlifted to a hospital in Dallas. There was no information on the girl's condition, or on the identity of the 16-year-old shooting suspect...
More Stories