One felony charge dropped in Dukes’ corruption case as deadline looms


Highlights

DPS crime analyst examined an incorrect date when looking into Rep. Dawnna Dukes’ cellphone activity.

Prosecutors have until Oct. 30 to decide whether to take 12 felony charges to trial.

Dukes’ attorneys dispute allegations that Dukes failed to turn over her cellphone to investigators.

The erosion of the criminal corruption case against state Rep. Dawnna Dukes is continuing ahead of an Oct. 30 deadline, as prosecutors acknowledge they will abandon one of the 13 felony counts against the Austin Democrat over an investigator’s error.

Dukes was indicted in January on charges she falsified travel vouchers to collect a $61.50 per diem 13 different times on days when she did not work at the Capitol.

But in a recent court filing, the Travis County district attorney’s office indicated a crime analyst with the Texas Department of Public Safety examined the wrong date when looking into Dukes’ cellphone activity to determine her whereabouts related to a travel reimbursement voucher she submitted in 2013. The mistake resulted in a felony count that erroneously stated Dukes turned in a falsified voucher for Dec. 22, 2013.

Justin Wood, the lead prosecutor on the case, declined to comment for this story. In the filing, he asserted that if the case goes to trial he will “move to waive or abandon Count IV of the indictment.” The dropped charge effectively brings Dukes’ maximum jail sentence from 28 years to 26 years if convicted on all charges, which include two misdemeanors.

“I question the motivation and the haste of their prosecution of Rep. Dukes,” her attorney, Matthew Shrum, said. “That they can’t see the sloppiness of the investigator that led to the abandoned felony count is just puzzling.”

The rest of the felony charges are also in doubt.

Dukes’ attorneys released a bombshell in September in the form of a sworn statement from a House official who said Dukes had to work from Austin — and not necessarily the Capitol — to qualify for reimbursement. That blindsided prosecutors, who had believed that witness, Steven Adrian, executive director of the House Business Office, would testify that Dukes had to be at the Capitol to collect the money. Three of Adrian’s employees signed declarations affirming what he said to Dukes’ attorneys.

Soon after, District Attorney Margaret Moore announced she would put the felony charges on hold, but at a hearing last month state District Judge Brad Urrutia set the Oct. 30 deadline, telling prosecutors to “fish or cut bait.”

All told, prosecutors had alleged that Dukes scammed the government out of $799.50. That total with the dropped charge is $738.

According to court records regarding the charge that will be dropped, Elizabeth Buhay, a crime analyst with the DPS telecommunications research analysis center, discovered on Oct. 2 that she mistakenly used cellphone data from Oct. 22, 2013, instead of Dec. 22, 2013, when she mapped Dukes’ cellphone activity. After realizing her error, Buhay analyzed the correct date and found activity near downtown Austin, which puts Dukes “within range of the Capitol building,” the document states.

Prosecutors were required by law to turn over documents detailing the error to Dukes’ attorneys.

Buhay’s mistake happened in the early stages of the case, as did the confusion over Adrian’s interpretation of voucher reimbursement rules. The lead prosecutor at that time was Susan Oswalt, who retired this summer and handed over the case to Wood.

It is unclear how prosecutors, DPS investigators and Texas Rangers failed to notice these holes in the case during an investigation that spanned more than 18 months. Oswalt declined to comment when reached by phone.

Moore has not indicated which way her office is leaning ahead of the Oct. 30 deadline. If prosecutors continue with the case, they must show Adrian’s reading of the reimbursement rules is wrong, or that Dukes was not in Austin on the dates in question.

In a related development, Dukes’ attorneys dispute an assertion by prosecutors that Dukes hid a cellphone from investigators. A list of 19 extraneous acts that prosecutors filed last month states Dukes responded to a search warrant for her cellphone by providing investigators a phone that did not match the identification number of the model they requested.

But Shrum said he personally turned over the correct phone to investigators.

“I do not have any idea where the DA’s office is coming from when they say she turned over the wrong phone,” he said. “It’s out of the blue.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Judge: Greg Kelley should be declared innocent in sex assault case
Judge: Greg Kelley should be declared innocent in sex assault case

State District Judge Donna King has ruled that the conviction of Greg Kelley, a former high school football star sent to prison on child sexual assault charges, should be overturned and that he meets the state’s legal threshold to be declared innocent, Kelley’s lawyer said. Under Texas law, a defendant meets the standard for &ldquo...
Once homeless teen receives laptop for school, needs more help
Once homeless teen receives laptop for school, needs more help

Lyric Wardlow didn’t have much of a childhood. The 19-year-old Austin woman spent most of her time caring for her mother, who had mental illness and hoarding problems. Wardlow didn’t have toys or friends to play with. She entertained herself by singing in the park. Life got much harder when Wardlow was 9 years old after she and her mother...
JUST IN: Austin police ID officer, stabbing suspect shot on Sunday
JUST IN: Austin police ID officer, stabbing suspect shot on Sunday

Austin police have identified a man suspected of stabbing a person in Northwest Austin on Sunday and the officer who shot him. Officers responded Sunday morning to a home in Northwest Hills, where they say 59-year-old Quinton Wiles stabbed another man multiple times. Police said Wiles is being charged with aggravated assault and was booked into the...
Namesake of Jack Brown Cleaners dies at 89

Jack Brown, the namesake of the ubiquitous Central Texas dry cleaning operation, has died. An obituary in Monday’s American-Statesman said Brown died Friday in the presence of his family. He was 89. A 1949 University of Texas graduate, Brown worked as a civil engineer for the Texas Highway Department before joining his father in the laundry business...
Austin among districts piloting a new way to rate schools
Austin among districts piloting a new way to rate schools

The Austin school district is one of 20 districts and charter systems chosen to participate in a pilot program to develop its own system of grading itself. The pilot was established under a new law House Bill 22, which also scaled back the A-F accountability system, unpopular among school district officials. READ: Austin district calls on lawmakers...
More Stories