Excessive force suit against Round Rock cops returns to court


Highlights

A judge reinstated on Tuesday a suit against the City of Round Rock and four of its officers.

Lionel Alexander says the officers pulled him out of his car, threw him to the ground and injured him in 2013.

An excessive force lawsuit against several Round Rock police officers is back in court after it was initially dismissed.

A judge ruled Tuesday to reinstate three parts of a 2015 lawsuit in which the plaintiff, Lionel Alexander, had sued the city of Round Rock and four named Round Rock police officers.

A district court had previously granted the City of Round Rock’s request to dismiss all of Alexander’s claims. The U.S. Court of Appeals ruled Tuesday to reverse that dismissal. The case will now return to district court to be decided.

Alexander is accusing the officers of using excessive force and violating his rights as laid out in the Texas Constitution when they arrested him in September 2013.

Alexander has said he had stopped in a hotel parking lot to try to feed a stray cat when he encountered Round Rock police officer Marciano Garza and three others, who were curious about his activities. Alexander alleges that officers pulled him out of his car, threw him to the ground and injured his mouth before being taken to Williamson County Jail.

Alexander was initially charged with resisting arrest but was never prosecuted, according to Williamson County court records.

“On the facts alleged, we conclude that the officers’ use of force was objectively unreasonable,” the appeals court wrote. “Nothing in Alexander’s statements or actions indicated that he posed any risk of harm to the officers. Nor did he pose any flight risk – indeed, he stayed in his vehicle and made no attempt to leave while Garza awaited backup. Perhaps Alexander’s refusal to exit his vehicle on Garza’s command warranted physical removal from the car, but it did not warrant throwing Alexander onto the ground, kneeing him in the back and pushing his face into the concrete.”

When the case returns to court, the court may ultimately conclude that Alexander’s constitutional rights were not violated, the appeals court wrote. But, based on the facts alleged, the case should not be automatically dismissed, the ruling said.

“We have only heard one side of the story,” the appeals court wrote. “After discovery is complete, the district court may well correctly determine that none of Alexander’s claims can survive summary judgment.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Chick-fil-A comes to rescue during Atlanta airport's power outage
Chick-fil-A comes to rescue during Atlanta airport's power outage

It could be a first for Atlanta's favorite fried chicken sandwich restaurant -- Chick-fil-A opened up its hearts and its fryers to help the stranded travelers at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport. Chick-fil-A is traditionally closed on Sundays but because of the massive power outage at the airport, restaurant employees came to the...
FORECAST: Dense fog possible until 9 a.m.; cloudy, small chance of rain Monday
FORECAST: Dense fog possible until 9 a.m.; cloudy, small chance of rain Monday

Monday forecast for Austin: A dense fog advisory is in effect until 9 a.m. throughout the Austin metro area – including Travis, Hays, Williamson, Bastrop and Caldwell counties – the National Weather Service says. If you are driving, you should slow down and leave plenty of distance in front of your vehicle because visibility will be reduced...
Texas family's Christmas light show pays tribute to Selena
Texas family's Christmas light show pays tribute to Selena

A Texas family is paying tribute to the late singer Selena with a light show set to one of her songs, WFAA reported. Beto Hinojosa of Boerne has been doing light shows in front of his home for four years. This year, he decided to add the Selena song, “Bidi Bidi Bom Bom.” Hinojosa, a principal in the Boerne school district, said he...
Sarah Palin's oldest son arrested on domestic violence charges
Sarah Palin's oldest son arrested on domestic violence charges

Track Palin, the oldest son of former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, was arraigned Sunday on domestic violence charges, according to online court records. Palin was arraigned on charges of felony burglary, assault in the fourth degree and criminal mischief for causing property damage in Wasilla, Alaska, according to court records. The criminal mischief charge...
California father continues Christmas tradition to honor late daughter
California father continues Christmas tradition to honor late daughter

For 19 years, a California man has decorated his home for Christmas and has invited community members to visit. The holiday display is a tribute to a daughter he lost in a plane crash. Bob Taylor oldest daughter died in the plane crash. “She loved Christmas,” Taylor told KRON. ” I mean, that was her favorite time of the year...
More Stories