Despite growing reliance on forensics, crime lab regulation is thin


Highlights

Just 13 percent of forensic examiners in Texas public labs have certification, a 2013 survey showed

Lab audits are up to the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors Lab Accreditation Board

Critics say the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors is not up to the task of accrediting crime labs

Despite their high-stakes work for the criminal justice system — from convicting the guilty to exonerating the innocent — forensic labs are surprisingly underregulated.

While the Scientific Working Group on DNA Analysis Methods recommends best practices and protocols, neither it nor the National Institute of Standards and Technology can enforce them. The FBI ensures labs handle data correctly to access the agency’s vast DNA identification database, but it doesn’t check technical lab work. Texas requires public forensic labs to be accredited for their findings to be used in court, but beyond that demands no standards.

Though many forensic examiners can be certified, it is voluntary. A 2013 survey of Texas public labs found 13 percent had obtained the certification. For DNA examiners, it was only 5 percent. (Texas will require state licensure for several of the disciplines starting in 2019.)

RELATED: Austin crime lab bucked DNA standard for years, yet still got passing grades

Accreditation requires lab analysts to pass regular proficiency tests, but there is no rule on how demanding the tests are, says John Butler, a forensic science expert at national standards institute. Techs often are asked only to demonstrate the most basic skills, says Erin Murphy, a New York University law professor and author of “Inside the Cell: The Dark Side of Forensic DNA.”

Once a lab hires a forensic examiner, it can take a year to fully train him or her. In some cases, deficiencies have been overlooked in the name of cost and production.

Technician Jonathan Salvador was caught faking a result in the Department of Public Safety’s forensic lab in Houston in 2012. Texas Forensic Science Commission examiners later discovered he’d been promoted despite “struggl(ing) with corrections and an overall understanding of the chemistry, especially in difficult cases.” Supervisors hesitated to remove him because it would mean others would have to pick up his work.

That leaves accreditation audits up to the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors Lab Accreditation Board, which critics say is inadequate for the task. The organization doesn’t test the quality of a lab’s work — only that it has protocols and that they are followed, Butler said. The examinations aren’t random or unannounced either, said Murphy, which makes them less rigorous than, say, spot inspections at restaurants.

The accreditation board’s vice president, Pamela Sale, didn’t respond to phone or email messages seeking comment. She recently told the Texas Forensic Science Commission newer audits would provide a thorough scientific review of lab’s analysis methods.

The Austin lab’s 2010 accreditation report hints at problems only in retrospect. Auditors noted several lab workers and supervisors didn’t have the recommended education — a deficiency identified in earlier audits.

Yet that didn’t hinder the facility’s accreditation, which in turn appears to have favorably predisposed others. Austin examiners testified in court the rigorous audit process guaranteed accuracy. Other organizations besides the lab accreditation board surveyed Austin’s work in recent years; none noted the flaws in its methods.

“It was readily apparent that the laboratory and its staff upheld the high standards of accreditation,” the Major Cities Chiefs Association reported after a February 2016 visit — three months before a visit by the Texas Forensic Science Commission revealed fundamental flaws.

Former Austin Police Chief Art Acevedo, who became Houston’s police chief in November, said he depended on the outside reviews to identify and correct concerns he’d received about the facility. That the reviews came back clean, he said, leaves him skeptical of the oversight.

“The systems in place that were fully utilized by people who were trying to do their due diligence by having numerous audits didn’t identify any issues,” the former chief said in an interview. “My question is: What should they have found, and why wasn’t it found?”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

BREAKING: Boil water notice issued near Cedar Creek, Red Rock in Bastrop County
BREAKING: Boil water notice issued near Cedar Creek, Red Rock in Bastrop County

A boil water notice has been issued for an area of Bastrop County that is near Cedar Creek and Red Rock, according to the Aqua Water Supply Corp. Around 6:00 p.m. Wednesday, portions of the Aqua Water Supply system experienced low pressure as a result of a water-main break, which may have allowed harmful microbes into the water system, Aqua Water...
Judge permanently bars Texas from enforcing ‘discriminatory’ ID law
Judge permanently bars Texas from enforcing ‘discriminatory’ ID law

A federal judge Wednesday tossed out the Texas voter ID law, saying changes recently adopted by the Legislature fell short of fixing a law that was drafted to intentionally discriminate against minority voters. U.S. District Judge Nelva Gonzales Ramos of Corpus Christi issued an injunction permanently barring Texas from enforcing its voter ID requirements...
Family: Man killed Wednesday was second brother shot dead in Austin
Family: Man killed Wednesday was second brother shot dead in Austin

A man who died from gunshot wounds Wednesday afternoon in North Austin is the second brother in his family to be shot and killed, according to his older brothers. Police declined to confirm the victim’s identity Wednesday, but two people at the scene identified him as their brother, 30-year-old Benson Briseño. Police got a 911 call about...
Suspect shot, ran over victim in North Austin homicide, police say

Austin police on Wednesday named a suspect in a weekend homicide — in which the victim was shot in the face and run over — but they think he fled to Mexico. Authorities have issued an arrest warrant for Gustavo Linan, 28, on a charge of first-degree murder in the death of 35-year-old Valente Garcia-Hernandez, with bail set at $1 million...
DA appeals Kleinert police shooting case to U.S. Supreme Court
DA appeals Kleinert police shooting case to U.S. Supreme Court

Exercising its final legal option, the Travis County district attorney’s office on Wednesday filed a writ of certiorari to the U.S. Supreme Court to appeal Charles Kleinert’s police-involved shooting case from 2013. Wanting to bring criminal charges against Kleinert for killing Larry Jackson — an unarmed black man who was trying to...
More Stories