Clarification sought on release of police body cam videos in Texas


Senator seeks answers on whether police body camera videos can be withheld from public, officials.

Can police decline to release footage if they believe it would hamper an investigation or prosecution?

Trying to make sense of an emerging area of law, a state senator has asked Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton to determine whether certain footage from police body cameras could be withheld — not just from the public, but from civilian supervisors of a law enforcement agency as well.

Specifically, Sen. Eddie Lucio Jr., D-Brownsville, wanted to know if state open record laws give a police chief or sheriff the discretion to withhold body camera footage if they determine that viewing the video could interfere with the “detection, investigation or prosecution of crime.”

Lucio’s request for an attorney general’s opinion, made public Tuesday, also asked whether a city manager, city council member or a civilian with police oversight has an “inherent right of access” to body camera footage as part of their official duties. And if such a right exists, Lucio asked, could police officials still withhold the footage if they believed its release could jeopardize an investigation or prosecution?

The concern, said Charley Wilkison, head of the Combined Law Enforcement Associations of Texas, is over politicians or other officials who would seek to influence an investigation or inject themselves into a controversy involving police.

“That’s one where we’re always deeply concerned,” he said.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

Like video taken from cameras mounted on a police cruiser’s dashboard, footage from body-worn cameras is prized for offering an objective look at interactions between officers and the public.

Questions about who should have access to body camera footage, however, are still being worked out, even as more police agencies adopt the technology — Austin, for example, recently announced that an additional 660 patrol officers will be fitted with cameras in the coming months.

Under state law, agencies that use body cameras must develop guidelines for public access to footage — if those making the request know the approximate time and exact place the recording was made, and can name at least one person in the video.

However, the Texas Public Information Act lets agencies withhold video if its release would jeopardize an investigation or prosecution — an exception that can delay release for months or years.

Video documenting deadly force by an officer, or showing events leading to an investigation of an officer’s conduct, also cannot be released to the public “until all criminal matters have been finally adjudicated” and all internal investigations are complete.

However, such videos can be made public if police officials determine that transparency “furthers a law enforcement purpose,” the law says.

Attorney general opinions are not binding but can help guide the policies of affected agencies.

But because Paxton’s office enforces open records laws, and determines what information can and cannot be withheld from the public, his opinion on the matter will be persuasive.

Paxton’s office has 180 days to issue a written opinion on the questions.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

‘Horns up’ in the Children’s Hospital
‘Horns up’ in the Children’s Hospital

University of Texas football players Tim Yoder, Michael Wilson and Kendall Moore get their “horns up” with future Longhorn Dylan Martinez at St. David’s Children’s Hospital. The football players visited sick children and their families to lift their spirits.
Poll: 49% of Texans disapprove of Trump, but GOP support strong

Nearly half of Texans disapprove of Donald Trump’s performance as president, but Republicans overwhelmingly support him, according to a University of Texas/Texas Tribune poll released Thursday. Among Republicans, 79 percent said they approved of Trump’s performance, while 15 percent disapprove. The rest of the GOP respondents said they...
DPS: Driver, 18, dies in crash after police chase near Granite Shoals

BURNET COUNTY Police chase ends with fatal crash A police chase ended with the death of an 18-year-old driver near Granite Shoals early Thursday, authorities said. According to a Texas Department of Public Safety statement, a preliminary investigation found that Cruz Grimaldo Suarez was fleeing from police around 3:30 a.m. in Burnet County. He was...
Austin man accused of killing girlfriend disappears ahead of trial
Austin man accused of killing girlfriend disappears ahead of trial

A Travis County murder defendant who is set to go to trial next week has disappeared after he failed to report to a pretrial hearing on Thursday. Authorities issued an arrest warrant for Kevin Michael Waguespack, who was out of jail on $250,000 bond. He is accused of killing his girlfriend Catherine Dyer, 31, in November 2015 in the home they shared...
Appeals court halts, for now, abortion for teen immigrant in Texas
Appeals court halts, for now, abortion for teen immigrant in Texas

One day after a federal judge ordered the Trump administration to allow a teenage immigrant in the country without authorization to have an abortion in Texas, an appeals court temporarily blocked the order and set oral arguments for Friday morning on whether to allow the procedure to occur. The order by the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District...
More Stories