AUSTIN SCHOOL BOND FORUM: Questions of segregation, inequity addressed


Highlights

School, community leaders debated equity in the district’s $1.1 billion bond.

Proponents say the bond is needed to help maintain, and even boost, the district’s enrollment.

Opponents say it will worsen segregation and disproportionately benefit students from the city’s west side.

School and community leaders Wednesday night debated whether the Austin school district’s $1.1 billion bond measure would benefit students equally across the district, and raised issues such as the bond’s tax impact, segregation in the schools and how to address underenrolled schools.

Trustee Ted Gordon said that while he has concerns with aspects of the bond, its failure would leave the school district in a dire financial situation.

He said that voting for the bond does not equate to voting for the closure of underenrolled schools, an argument some opponents have made. Campus closures and consolidations might be on the table regardless of whether the bond passes, he said.

“I’m not in favor of closing down any schools,” Gordon said. “I would rather have $25 million in the bond in case the decision is made to close the schools so that we can build something better on one of those sites.”

READ: Austin district is banking on bond to boost enrollment, turn around schools

Wednesday’s forum, hosted by the East Austin Coalition for Quality Education at Austin’s Huston-Tillotson University, came about two weeks before early voting will start on the bond. Election Day is Nov. 7. Proponents say the bond, which aims to construct new or rebuild schools and make hundreds of improvements, is needed to help maintain, and even boost, the district’s dwindling enrollment.

But a recently formed political action group, among other opponents, says it will worsen segregation and disproportionately benefit students from the city’s west side.

Peggy Vasquez, representing the anti-bond Save East Austin Schools PAC, recalled historical segregation in the district and said she is fighting against further segregation that would be caused by moving the Liberal Arts and Science Academy and Eastside Memorial High School. Under the bond proposal, Eastside Memorial would relocate from its current home on the former Johnston High School campus to the original Anderson High School, making room for the LASA to expand as a stand-alone campus in the Johnston location.

As for changing school boundaries to add more students to underenrolled campuses, both Gordon and former Trustee Paul Saldaña said it’s not even a consideration.

READ: Bond plan calls for LASA to move south, grow

“The political power, where it lies in Austin, Texas, is perfectly happy to leave school boundaries as they are,” Gordon said. “So even tinkering with the school boundaries is basically a no-no. It would take a monumental mobilization of political power, political and economic power, in this city to get those school boundaries drawn back to zero and rebuilt in an equitable way. Because Austin, despite the fact that it’s a progressive city, is not equitable. People have interests that they are bound to protect, and some of those interests have to do with where those school boundaries are constructed.”

Tam Hawkins, president and CEO of the Greater Austin Black Chamber of Commerce, said arguments could be made for redrawing boundaries or modernizing and building new schools, but “at the end of the day, it’s about the students.”

“If our students are not given the support that they need to be successful and eradicate some disparity outcomes for black and brown students, none of this will matter,” Hawkins said, noting that business community members supported passage of the bond but must continue to fight to ensure inequities aren’t passed on. “I don’t care what line we draw. For me it’s a moot point.”

Trustee Jayme Mathias said the LASA-Eastside Memorial shift offers another solution, giving the chronically underenrolled Eastside Memorial a brand new-facility, while providing LASA room to grow.

But Saldaña said he continues to have lingering concerns, including that the LASA and Eastside Memorial moves worsen segregation in Gordon’s area.

“I do not support initiatives that perpetuate inequities, racism, segregation and classism,” he said. “I’m really struggling with the bond package because there’s some inequities.”

POLITIFACT: Austin school bond claim is silent on increased costs to taxpayers

During the forum, the panelists also weighed in on the tax impact of the bond package. Among the selling points for the bond, Mathias said the district can cover the costs of the bond projects without raising the tax rate. Critics, however, have been quick to point out that taxes would continue to climb, as property values rise.

Hawkins said most people don’t mind paying the tax, but they mind not getting a good product for that tax.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

With in-depth report, Austin mulls pros, cons of 8 sites for MLS use
With in-depth report, Austin mulls pros, cons of 8 sites for MLS use

The Austin City Council postponed action regarding the potential future home of a Major League Soccer club this week, but there is plenty to discuss after eight publicly owned sites were unveiled as possibilities earlier this week. The city released a detailed report Thursday, providing more information about the sites identified as having the potential...
Texas cancels no-bid contract for special education analysis
Texas cancels no-bid contract for special education analysis

The Texas Education Agency has canceled its contract with a technology company charged with analyzing special education programs. The TEA had contracted with SPEDx, a Georgia-based company, to look for trends and patterns in special education records. But the $4.4 million project incurred the ire of advocacy groups and parents, who said they worried...
20 arrested after Taylor-based cocaine trafficking operation
20 arrested after Taylor-based cocaine trafficking operation

Federal and state authorities arrested 20 people and charged them with having a role in a narcotics distribution ring operating in the Taylor area, U.S. Department of Justice officials said Friday.  Among those arrested is 42-year-old Horace Caruther, a man federal officials said is the “ringleader” of the drug ring. From July...
Trump inauguration riot trial goes to the jury
Trump inauguration riot trial goes to the jury

The first trial of nearly 200 Inauguration Day protesters charged with rioting, conspiracy to riot and destruction of property went to a jury Friday afternoon, a month after it began. Freelance photojournalist Alexei Wood of San Antonio and five other defendants could receive more than 50 years in prison and thousands of dollars in fines if convicted...
UT System Chancellor Bill McRaven to step down, citing health concerns
UT System Chancellor Bill McRaven to step down, citing health concerns

Bill McRaven, chancellor of the University of Texas System, is planning to step down at the end of the academic year in May because of health issues he has been facing, he told the UT System Board of Regents on Friday afternoon. McRaven’s decision was not completely unexpected, given that he was briefly hospitalized in November for what he described...
More Stories