Appeals court reinstates a Texas immigration law


Highlights

U.S. appeals court says Texas can enforce state law against harboring unauthorized immigrants.

The law, included in sweeping 2015 border legislation, was blocked by a lower court judge in April.

A federal appeals court ruled Thursday that Texas can once again enforce a 2015 state law that added criminal penalties for “harboring” or concealing immigrants who are in the United States illegally.

Ten months ago, Senior U.S. District Judge David Alan Ezra blocked Texas from enforcing the anti-harboring provision, which was part of a sweeping border security law known as House Bill 11.

Texas officials had long argued that the law created a new criminal offense that applied only to human traffickers and smugglers.

Ezra, however, said the law improperly placed a wider array of Texans at risk of jail time, including those who sued to block the harboring provision — two landlords, a homeless shelter in Brownsville and a legal-aid organization that serves Central and South Texas families who are in the country illegally.

TEXAS POLITICS DELIVERED EVERY DAY: Sign up for our Texas Politics email

On Thursday, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned Ezra’s ruling and dismissed the lawsuit, saying those who sued “cannot demonstrate a credible threat of prosecution.”

“Because there is no reasonable interpretation by which merely renting housing or providing social services to an illegal alien constitutes ‘harboring … that person from detection,’ we reverse the injunction,” Judge Jerry Smith wrote for the three-judge panel.

The Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, which sued to challenge the harboring provision, was cautiously pleased with the ruling, even if it led to the lawsuit’s dismissal.

“The court ruled that our clients are not harboring the undocumented immigrants that they serve,” said Nina Perales, the organization’s vice president for litigation.

“The 5th Circuit provided us with a narrow definition of harboring that will prevent Texas law enforcement officers from arresting humanitarian workers and landlords for simply providing shelter and conducting business with undocumented immigrants,” Perales said.

“In these days of increased concern that state and local police will take up the duties of federal immigration agents, today’s ruling restricts Texas to only the most limited enforcement of the harboring statute,” she said.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

Thursday’s ruling will allow Texas to enforce an HB 11 provision that made it a crime to encourage somebody to enter or remain in the country illegally by harboring or shielding them “with the intent to obtain a pecuniary benefit.”

By charging rent without verifying the immigration status of tenants, the landlords feared the law would apply to them. Likewise, the homeless shelter and legal-aid organization, which operates two temporary shelters, feared running afoul of the “pecuniary benefit” restriction because they rely on residents to cook, clean and provide maintenance in exchange for housing.

In its ruling, the appeals court said that, while the term “harbor” can be ambiguous, the law also requires immigrants to be shielded from detection.

“It requires some level of covertness well beyond merely renting or providing a place to live,” the court said.

The appeals court also noted that Steve McCraw, director of the Texas Department of Public Safety, testified that his agency wouldn’t investigate, file charges or enforce the anti-harboring provision against landlords, social services agencies and similar organizations.

Although McCraw’s assurances aren’t binding on local police and prosecutors, the court acknowledged, “DPS has a major role in the administration of HB 11, and testimony from its head … carries some weight.”

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton praised the ruling, saying it “will allow the state to fight the smuggling of humans and illegal contraband by transnational gangs and perpetrators of organized crime, not just on the border, but throughout Texas.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

WEATHER: Scattered rain, storms possible across Austin today
WEATHER: Scattered rain, storms possible across Austin today

Monday forecast for Austin: Scattered storms are expected across the Austin area today, with a 60 percent chance of rain throughout the day, which will drop to 40 percent this evening, the National Weather Service says. However, once again the worst of the rain will be focused in West Texas, out in the Edwards Plateau. The Austin area is only...
Proposed MoPac settlement terms to become public Tuesday
Proposed MoPac settlement terms to become public Tuesday

Details of a settlement between the MoPac toll project’s government overseer and its tardy contractor should emerge this morning, when the Central Texas Regional Mobility Authority board is scheduled to discuss the deal in closed session and then vote on it in public. Officials could announce, as well, the opening date of the next section of...
Court backs, for now, Ken Paxton prosecutors in fight over payment
Court backs, for now, Ken Paxton prosecutors in fight over payment

The state’s highest criminal court late Monday temporarily halted a lower-court order that had blocked payments to prosecutors in the criminal case against Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals gave Collin County — which had sued to halt the payments, saying they were based on an excessive $300 rate &mdash...
Sheriff will enforce immigration detentions after SB 4 court ruling
Sheriff will enforce immigration detentions after SB 4 court ruling

Travis County Sheriff Sally Hernandez ordered her office to start honoring all federal immigration detention requests placed on local jail inmates after a federal appeals court ruling Monday allowed parts of Senate Bill 4, the controversial “sanctuary cities” ban, to go into effect. The appellate court’s order essentially undoes Hernandez&rsquo...
Judge to rule on DA’s request to put hold on Rep. Dukes’ felony charges
Judge to rule on DA’s request to put hold on Rep. Dukes’ felony charges

After admitting they were caught off guard by a flip-flopping witness in state Rep. Dawnna Dukes’ corruption case, Travis County prosecutors are asking a judge to grant a trial delay so they can have more time to prove 13 felony charges. The outcome of a hearing Tuesday afternoon will determine whether the district attorney’s office gets...
More Stories