The bright (and not-so-bright) side of making Jell-O cookies


Jell-O and cookies are two super kid-friendly desserts, but what happens when you combine them?

A few weeks ago, a reader emailed about Jell-O cookies she’d seen in an Arizona newspaper that she thought me and my boys might like to try for a summer project. I picked up some Jell-O on a slow weekend day and we set out to try this somewhat weird combination.

The recipe is a simple sugar cookie recipe, but some of the sugar is replaced with the Jell-O. The original recipe said you could halve the recipe to make different colors, so that’s what I did, but I made the mistake of using the whole package of Jell-O in each. I was just trying not to waste half a pack of Jell-O, but looking back, I should have just tossed that extra 1 1/2 ounces because the resulting cookies — though cute — were too tart and sour to really enjoy. The cookies do need that extra 1/2 cup of granulated sugar and even the decorative sugar (or, in our case, Skittles) to sweeten the treats.

Otherwise, this was a fun cookie to make! The dough has a nice texture to it that’s easy to roll and cut with the cookie cutters. The bright red color of the cherry Jell-O was more eye-popping than the grape flavor, and even though we didn’t like that first batch (because of my error), I’m going to try again with the lime Jell-O, just to see how the green turns out. You can just use food coloring to brighten up your sugar cookie dough.

Jell-O Cookies

3/4 cup butter, slightly softened

1/2 cup granulated sugar

1 (3-ounce) package Jell-O or flavored gelatin powder (not sugar-free)

2 large eggs, room temperature

1 teaspoon salt

1 1/2 teaspoons baking powder

2 1/2 cups flour, or slightly more if batter is too sticky

Food coloring, if desired for more color

In a mixing bowl, cream together butter, sugar and Jell-O until well blended. Add eggs, and cream well. Add salt, baking powder and flour, mixing well. Add food coloring if desired.

Scoop dough into a bowl, cover and refrigerate for 1 to 2 hours to harden. When ready to bake, heat oven to 350 degrees. On a lightly floured surface, roll out dough 1/4- to 1/2-inch thick. Use cookie cutters to cut out patterns. Sprinkle with decorative sugar.

Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Place cookies on baking sheet about 1 inch apart. Bake for 12 to 15 minutes or until done. Let cool on baking rack and then store in airtight container.

— Adapted from a recipe by Jan D’Atri



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Austin360 Eats

Austin360 On The Record: KGSR Broadcasts, Gary Clark Jr., Sour Notes, more
Austin360 On The Record: KGSR Broadcasts, Gary Clark Jr., Sour Notes, more

OUT THIS WEEK KSGR Broadcasts Vol. 25. This annual fundraising collection of live tracks from the award-winning local radio station reaches the quarter-century mark this year. Everything comes from 2017 on-air sessions recorded either at the station or at its satellite festival broadcasts. Most of the 30 tracks...
David Cassidy’s younger brother Shaun offers touching tribute on Twitter
David Cassidy’s younger brother Shaun offers touching tribute on Twitter

Teenage heartthrobs run in the Cassidy family. David Cassidy’s younger brother, Shaun Cassidy, who was also a teen idol and singer in the 1970s, remembered his late brother with a touching tribute on Twitter after the pop culture icon’s death Tuesday from organ failure. “When I was a little boy and my big brother would come to visit...
Of Cassidys, Partridges and Cowsills: An Austin tie to family tales
Of Cassidys, Partridges and Cowsills: An Austin tie to family tales

Partridge Family and Cowsills records from the late 1960s and early 1970s. Billy Cowsill is seated at the center on the Cowsills cover (just to the left of the clown). The news hit hard for many fans on Tuesday that David Cassidy, the former teen idol who starred in the early-1970s TV show “The Partridge Family,&rdquo...
6 easy side dishes anyone can make for Thanksgiving Day
6 easy side dishes anyone can make for Thanksgiving Day

Although the turkey will surely take center stage at your Thanksgiving table, a few unforgettable side dishes can't hurt. These simple Thanksgiving sides won't take very much time or effort to pull together, but look (and taste) like a million bucks. This Thanksgiving Day, give your family a feast they won't forget by including a few of these easy-to-make...
Here are the Austin theaters showing Pixar’s ‘Coco’ dubbed into Spanish
Here are the Austin theaters showing Pixar’s ‘Coco’ dubbed into Spanish

“Coco,” the new film from Disney Pixar, concerns young Miguel Rivera, a Mexican boy from a family of shoemakers who loves music, contrary to his family’s dislike of the stuff. Naturally, he ends up in the land of the dead to address the problem at hand. (And yes, there’s more plot than that.) Already the all-time highest...
More Stories