How to make your own Philly cheesesteaks for the Super Bowl

It’s Super Bowl time, which means we get to try our hand at foods that we don’t make so often ’round these parts. With the Philadelphia Eagles taking on the New England Patriots this weekend, we have a clear favorite when it comes to food: The Philly cheesesteak.

I’ve had the real thing from Pat’s in Philadelphia, and this homemade version I tried last week made for a hearty homemade weeknight sandwich that hit the spot. Next time, I’ll use even more provolone and maybe some shredded mozzarella and make a little beef broth au jus on the side. Bolillo bread, which is what I used, is the easiest option for sandwiches like this, but they can be a little dry.

Philly Cheesesteak

The Philly cheesesteak recipe is from Gabrielle Langholtz’s “America: The Cookbook” (Phaidon, $49.95), a thick, stately volume with every regional dish you could conjure, from Yankee pot roast to Baja fish tacos, which will come in handy for every Super Bowl and World Series and maybe even an Iowa caucus. From Texas, you’ll find recipes for Hatch apple pie and cornbread, barbacoa, margaritas, migas and South Texas antelope with prickly pear glaze. For this recipe, don’t skip the freezing of the meat, and you’ll need a sharp knife to get the slices paper thin. Your fingers will get cold, so use a kitchen towel to help grip the steak.

3/4 pound beef sirloin, ribeye or eye of round

2 tablespoons olive oil

1 large onion, sliced into very thin rings

1/2 cup sliced mushrooms (optional)

Salt and freshly ground black pepper

4 slices provolone cheese, or more to taste

2 hoagie buns, sub or hero rolls, split lengthwise

Dill pickles, for serving

Place the beef in the freezer for 1 hour. Slice the beef paper thin, then into 1-inch pieces. In a large frying pan, heat the oil over high heat until almost at the smoking point. Reduce the heat to medium, add the onion and mushrooms (if using) and cook, stirring occasionally, until the onion is wilted and the mushrooms have browned, about 5 minutes. Add the “chipped” steak and cook for 3 minutes, stirring. Season to taste with salt and pepper. Still in the pan, divide the meat mixture into 2 mounds. Top each mound with the provolone and melt the cheese, then transfer to the rolls. Serve with a dill pickle.

— From “America: The Cookbook” by Gabrielle Langholtz (Phaidon, $49.95)

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Austin360 Eats

Diabetes Quick Fix: Scaloppine al Marsala with Penne alla Siciliana

Succulent veal with a sweet Marsala wine sauce and pasta brings a touch of Sicily to your table. Marsala wine is a sweet fortified wine that is produced in Sicily by families who have owned their vineyards for many generations.  — Sherry can be used instead of Marsala.   — Boneless skinless chicken breasts can be substituted...
This 20-minute lemony shrimp dish is a weeknight hero
This 20-minute lemony shrimp dish is a weeknight hero

Shrimp wins as America's favorite seafood in polls year after year; you know those scenes in the film "Forrest Gump" where Pvt. Bubba Blue rambles through all the ways it can be prepared? I think I've had them all. This 20-minute dish ranks high on my list. I could eat it once a week, warm or as cold leftovers. It starts with a bag of frozen...
'Home of Sliced Bread': Small Missouri town champions its greatest thing
'Home of Sliced Bread': Small Missouri town champions its greatest thing

U.S. Route 36 stretches for 200 miles across the flat farmland of northern Missouri, connecting Kansas to Illinois. At one end is the Pony Express Bridge in St. Joseph and at the other is the Mark Twain Memorial Bridge in Hannibal. The route is called "The Way of American Genius" because some of the nation's best-known innovators, creative...
A bean stew that is far from ordinary
A bean stew that is far from ordinary

Many Americans fall in love with the food of Georgia (the country, not the state) after sampling khachapuri, a savory cheese-stuffed bread often served with a runny egg on top. For others, it’s a plateful of handmade khinkali, the country’s meaty version of soup dumplings. For me, the obsession started with a humble bean stew called lobio...
These tasty enchiladas take only 5 minutes in the microwave
These tasty enchiladas take only 5 minutes in the microwave

Enjoy this Mexican-inspired turkey and refried bean enchiladas dish that takes 5 minutes to make using a microwave oven. It’s topped with a spicy tomato sauce.  Esquites, or fried corn, is a typical Mexican side dish. Using diced onion and green peppers found in the produce department and frozen corn kernels, it takes only minutes to prepare...
More Stories