breaking news

BREAKING: Officer-involved shooting in Central Austin

‘Gifted’ is heartfelt but a little too good to be true


It often seems that Hollywood filmmaking trends too often to the “more is more” philosophy: more special effects, more stars, more spectacle. Alternatively, there’s the micro budget “less is more” of the indie scene. Like Goldilocks, you might be looking for something not more or less, but “just right.” “Gifted” is a rare example of the kind of mid-budget family dramedies that used to populate movie theaters but are now hard to come by. It even stars the class president of cinematic spectacle, Captain America himself.

Chris Evans, putting down the star-emblazoned shield, demonstrates his chops beyond the “Avengers” universe in this exceedingly pleasant tale of a young prodigy and the uncle who encourages her to just be a kid. The story is an amalgamation of familiar story tropes and character types — the custodial courtroom drama, the precocious whiz-kid, the odd couple, unconventional parent-child relationship. It executes all of these elements very well, with a distinct sense of wry sweetness throughout, thanks to director Marc Webb, known for “(500) Days of Summer.”

Evans anchors the film as Frank, opposite the preternaturally talented Mckenna Grace, already an industry vet at age 10, as his niece Mary. They share a cheerfully relaxed shaggy dog existence in Tampa, Fla., replete with boat trips, a one-eyed cat named Fred and a beloved neighbor, Roberta (Octavia Spencer). When Frank sends Mary to school, Roberta throws a fit. She’s worried that Mary will be discovered, and taken away.

Mary’s not a mutant, but a math genius, which the film presents as a genetic gift from her mother, Diane. After Diane’s unfortunate demise, Frank has taken it upon himself to give his niece a real childhood, with friends and public school and pets, something Diane was denied by their overbearing and brilliant mathematician mother Evelyn (Lindsay Duncan), projecting her own unrealized dreams on her progeny.

The ensuing custody battle reveals the ways in which each character’s motivations come from their own desires to do things right the second time around, to finally solve the problem of correctly raising a genius. Mary just happens to be incidental to all that.

The emotions are heartfelt and genuine, and Evans displays electric chemistry with every woman in his orbit on screen. He’s playful with the scrappy, sarcastic Mary, who has learned her sardonic attitude from her uncle. He engages with brittle banter with his mother, while Roberta doles out the tough love, and sparks fly between Frank and Mary’s teacher Bonnie, played by the winsome Jenny Slate.

Despite its relaxed charms, “Gifted” is hampered by a tendency toward the overwrought and unrealistic in the realm of the courtroom drama. The characters become entangled in impossible personal and ethical choices, and the script relies on last minute Hail Marys to erase all those over-complications. It’s pulpy, melodramatic and drags down what initially seems to be an intellectual and empathetic exploration about how to nurture genius.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Movies & TV

In 1998, ‘The Simpsons’ predicted Disney would buy Fox
In 1998, ‘The Simpsons’ predicted Disney would buy Fox

Doh! Another prediction comes true on the long-running “The Simpsons” animated sitcom. In 1998, the sitcom predicted that The Walt Disney Company would buy 21st Century Fox. In other episodes, the show also has forecasted the presidency of Donald Trump and a Super Bowl halftime show featuring Lady Gaga. NBC News reported...
A spinach lasagna worthy of a holiday feast
A spinach lasagna worthy of a holiday feast

Some pasta dishes are a breeze to make. Lasagna is not, and there is no getting around it. But it is absolutely worth the effort. Having a companion in the kitchen makes the process go much faster. That said, this particular lasagna can be achieved more quickly than some of the more elaborate and traditional ones made with a meaty Bolognese ragù...
Still sippin' on Courvoisier? It's time to try a brandy from closer to home.
Still sippin' on Courvoisier? It's time to try a brandy from closer to home.

Rachel Cole Gardner was working on her grandmother's farm in Upstate New York when she noticed some gangly apple trees around the property, trees that hadn't been pruned in years, adorned with tiny green bulbs. Curious, she tasted a few. "They were very bitter, very tart - blech! - but I ended up pulling down 10 to 15 pounds of them and bringing...
The top 10 New York dishes of 2017
The top 10 New York dishes of 2017

The following items — eight dishes, one pastry and a cocktail — all reside in New York establishments that did not make the list of my favorite new restaurants of the year for one reason or another. Some come from places that aren’t eligible because they’re too old, or that were nudged out by other new restaurants I was more...
When it comes to choosing pie, apple is a flavor we can all agree on
When it comes to choosing pie, apple is a flavor we can all agree on

Apple first. That’s our policy. Special interests may back pumpkin, pecan or mincemeat. But citizens across the political spectrum agree on apple. That’s good news at the holidays, when we gather at one big table. ———  Prep: 1 hour, 15 minutes, plus time to cool  Bake: 1 hour  Makes: One 9-inch pie (serves...
More Stories