‘Fantastic Beasts’ could use a more fantastic plot


New characters operating in a fictional universe the ins and outs of which we thought we knew; magic and combat working much more efficiently than we’ve seen them before; new cities and settings overstuffed with CGI buildings and creatures. … It is hard to watch “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them” and not think of “The Phantom Menace” (with better dialogue).

A prequel to the “Harry Potter” stories set in 1926 New York, “Fantastic Beasts”-the-movie is extrapolated from a book of the same name that Potter and his pals run into at Hogwarts written by a wizard named Newt Scamander; a real-world paper version was published in 2001. The movie tells us one of the stories about the writing of said book.

Scamander (Eddie Redmayne, doing that head-half-tilted and looking-up-from-under-his-eyebrows thing someone clearly once told him was cute) is a strange man, a taxonomer of magical creatures who arrives in New York for a brief stop before continuing his journey across the United States.

A former Auror named Tina Goldstein (Katherine Waterston, weirdly miscast) finds Scamander and hauls him in to the Magical Congress of the United States of America (MACUSA) for failing to announce his presence (or something).

Add in one charmingly goofy Muggle named Kowalski (good job, Dan Fogler), Tina’s zany sister, Queenie (Alison Sudol) and a classic, screwball comedy briefcase mix-up and suddenly fantastic beasts are taking over New York, which is a place we learn is far less progressive than one would hope.

Indeed, hardcore Potter nerds will enjoy the world-building that goes into “Fantastic Beasts.” Unlike the kids in “Harry Potter” who are just learning to use their powers, everyone here is a pro-grade wizard. They point their wands and stuff happens, they teleport without a second thought, they read minds at will.

And yes, England finds America’s wizarding community a bit backwards. We have a habit of killing our magical creatures, you see, rather than repatriating a particularly large one to Arizona, as Scamander intends for one of his beasts. And we have rather draconian laws against intermarrying with Muggles (which are called “No-Majes” in the States, short for “non-magic,” because we are nothing if not pragmatic with our language.)

There’s even an anti-magic group calling itself the Second-Salemers, headed up by Mary Lou (Samantha Morton), dedicated to the exposure and eradication of witches, which seems … off. Wait, don’t wizards go out of their way to make sure Muggles never know of them? (Eh, don’t think too hard about that one.)

Then there’s Percival Graves (Colin Farrell, complete with lawful evil haircut), head of MACUSA, who has kind of had it with all these No-Majes, quite frankly.

Even with a script by J. K .Rowling herself, veteran “Potter” helmer David Yates can’t quite recapture the wonder, charm or emotional scope of the original series.

Which he wasn’t obligated to, of course, but when this much money is on screen ($180 million, reportedly), one expects some of it to go into, say, coherent plotting, not just endless CGI eye-candy — a giant smog monster thing here, a thieving platypus there.

And then, as the big bad is revealed, it dawns on you that the disease that has plagued every superhero movie of recent times has come to the Potter-verse: “Fantastic Beasts,” all two hours-plus of it, was mostly setup for the next spate of movies.

Ah, well. I wonder if “Attack of the Clones” will be better.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Movies & TV

Bill Cosby makes surprise return to the stage as sexual assault retrial looms
Bill Cosby makes surprise return to the stage as sexual assault retrial looms

Bill Cosby returned to the stage for the first time since he was accused of sexual assault. The veteran comedian appeared for a “special performance” in honor of jazz musician Tony Williams at the LaRose Jazz Club in Philadelphia on Monday. The appearance was his first time back in front of an audience since 2015. >> Read...
How to pair wine: Bottles with good acidity match tequila-poached chicken
How to pair wine: Bottles with good acidity match tequila-poached chicken

A dish with a lot of upfront acidity, like this one, needs a wine that is equally assertive in that category. These three — a Champagne, an albarino from western Spain and a riesling from northern Italy — bring the acidity, along with bright fruit and aromatic notes all their own.  ———   Slide 8 boneless...
Only you know your sweet spot for sweet and sour
Only you know your sweet spot for sweet and sour

Here's the truth about sweet-and-sour dishes: One cook's sweet is another cook's sour. That is, the balance between the two is highly subjective. Take lemonade, the most beloved sweet-and-sour beverage that comes to mind. I prefer it on the tart side, with barely enough sugar to take the edge off. My fiance, on the other hand, once said to me, "...
Mushrooms are a 'powerhouse of nutrition'
Mushrooms are a 'powerhouse of nutrition'

A: Mushrooms may lack the deep green or brilliant red hues consumers have come to associate with nutrient-rich fruits and vegetables, but they are a “powerhouse of nutrition” and not a white food to be avoided, said Angela Lemond, a registered dietitian nutritionist and spokeswoman for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. Low in calories...
After the apologies, restaurants struggle to change
After the apologies, restaurants struggle to change

The first act of the drama was loud and public: Reporters exposed pervasive sexual harassment at a handful of high-profile restaurant groups around the country. Accused chefs and restaurateurs issued apologies and vowed to step away from daily operations. The second act is playing out much more quietly, as customers consider whether they should eat...
More Stories