What House tax plan could mean for Texas taxpayers


Highlights

One part of the GOP plan would cap the federal deduction of local property tax payments at $10,000.

A second part of the plan would eliminate the state income tax deduction on federal returns.

It would take days – and more than a few attorneys – to figure out how the new House tax bill would affect specific individual or corporate taxpayers, but the plan includes some obvious pluses and minuses for Texas taxpayers.

Of the proposals included in the bill, two might stand out for Texas residents. The first would cap the federal deduction of local property tax payments at $10,000. A second proposal would eliminate the state income tax deduction on federal returns, a provision that could make Texas a more attractive destination for people who live in states that levy income taxes.

The bill, unveiled by House Republican leadership Thursday, almost certainly will change. Senate leaders already have said they intend to write their own version. But the broad strokes laid out in the House proposal provoked a lot of rapid analysis around the state.

“I’m still wrapping my head around most of it myself,” said Jamie Katzen, a director and an estate and tax attorney at Coats Rose’s office in Dallas.

The bill reflects the GOP’s interest in reducing federal tax rates, particularly for corporations, Katzen said, a philosophy that meshes well with the general corporate and political sensibilities in Texas.

“We have a very strong corporate culture, so to lower the corporate income tax rates significantly could be a huge boon to business in Texas,” he said.

For individual taxpayers, the bill’s provision to reduce and ultimately eliminate the estate tax might also play well in the state, he said, noting that Texas has “a rich history of complex estate planning as far back as there’s been an estate tax.”

But it also includes a variety of trade-offs. Provisions that might cost Texans more on the federal returns might be offset by other factors, including the bill’s proposal to double the standard deduction to $24,000.

“It could be that most Texans wouldn’t be itemizing at all,” Katzen said, so they wouldn’t be worried about changes to the mortgage interest deduction or the lower limit on the property taxes one could deduct.

Still, if those proposals remain, many Texans could take a hit or enjoy a gain. For example, the state’s reliance on property taxes could cost wealthier homeowners more on their federal returns. The bill would cap property tax deductions at $10,000.

Locally, about 45,000 properties with homestead exemptions – or 21 percent of about 214,000 properties with homestead exemptions – have tax bills above $10,000 for 2017, according to data from the Travis Central Appraisal District. But those 45,000 properties pay about 46 percent of taxes charged to properties with homestead exemptions.

Meanwhile, the elimination of the federal deduction for state income taxes could benefit states like Texas that don’t have income taxes because it could make them even more attractive to people and businesses from a tax standpoint. But some economists don’t think the impact would be significant.

Bernard Weinstein, an economist and Southern Methodist University professor, said few individuals or corporations relocate solely to avoid state income taxes. Still, Texas and other states that don’t have state income taxes will use elimination of the federal deduction as a selling point when trying to attract new development, he said.

“We love to brag about the fact that we don’t have an income tax, so it’s great PR for the state,” Weinstein said.

But if the proposal to eliminate the deduction were to be enacted, he said, it likely would rein in rate increases by the states that do level income taxes.

Proponents of increasing state income taxes routinely “argue that the feds are going to pay part of it” through the deduction, Weinstein said. So “this will have a restraining effect on high-income states that tax income. It will cause them to think twice about hiking taxes.”

Other provisions include a proposal that would make mandatory a tax on corporate profits that multinational companies hold overseas. The bill proposes a 12 percent tax on earnings held in cash and a 5 percent levy on profits reinvested in other, more permanent assets, such as buildings and equipment.

Dell Technologies, for example, retains billions of dollars of profits it generates from overseas sales in various foreign jurisdictions. For its most recent fiscal year, which ended Feb. 3, the company said keeping or investing foreign profits in those jurisdictions knocked 4.9 percentage points off the statutory 35 percent corporate tax rate in the U.S. However, the House bill would offer something of an out, proposing a tax holiday for companies that repatriate earnings to the U.S.

A spokesman for Dell Technologies couldn’t be immediately reached for comment.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Visa joins other credit cards in getting rid of signature requirement
Visa joins other credit cards in getting rid of signature requirement

The days of signing the receipt after a credit card purchase are numbered. Visa, the largest U.S. credit card issuer, became the last of the major credit card companies to announce its plan to make signatures optional. Visa announced it will get rid of its signature requirement for cards with EMV chips starting in April. EMV — which stands for...
A sampling of then newest technologies being rolled out for consumers
A sampling of then newest technologies being rolled out for consumers

With 2.754 million square feet of showroom floor space just about everything imaginable was on display at the recent Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas. It’s an impossible task to see it all but here’s a sampling of new, useful products of the thousand or so I saw on display, ——— Hanwha Techwin America showed off the...
Wearables get smaller and smarter
Wearables get smaller and smarter

First there were fitness wearables. Then the focus turned to fashionable wearables. The latest evolution, seen throughout this year’s CES in Las Vegas: more functional, futuristic — and sometimes far-fetched — wearables. Wrist-worn wearables were a huge hit at the trade show four years ago, as tech makers showed off fitness trackers...
AI programs beat humans in a Stanford reading test
AI programs beat humans in a Stanford reading test

First, they beat us at chess. Then it was Go. Now it’s basic reading comprehension. The robots are coming. Two artificial intelligence programs created by Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba and Microsoft beat humans on a Stanford University reading comprehension test, Alibaba said recently. Alibaba took the honors as creator of the first program...
‘Gorogoa’ is as much a work of art as it is a puzzle game
‘Gorogoa’ is as much a work of art as it is a puzzle game

Part of what makes a good puzzle game is the inevitable “ah-ha” moment, the sense of accomplishment you get as you fit all the pieces together. “Gorogoa” is replete with these satisfying moments, enhanced by gorgeous hand-drawn visuals that pull you into its surreal world. “Gorogoa” is a tile-based puzzle game developed...
More Stories