Showdown brews in Legislature over business tax cut


The Texas Senate and House have both made clear they want to eliminate the state’s main business tax, but a showdown appears to be brewing over how to accomplish it.

One potential plan to end the franchise tax — outlined in House Bill 28 and approved by the full House three weeks ago — was taken up Friday morning by the powerful Senate Finance Committee. But committee members quickly swapped it out for their own version, Senate Bill 17, that the full Senate approved in March.

The outcome could be that the bill ends up in a conference committee, where lawmakers from both chambers would attempt to reconcile their differences with little more than a week left in the legislative session.

Both bills would phase out the franchise tax over a period of years, but they use different formulas to do so and SB 17 is widely viewed as less abrupt. The franchise tax, also known as the margins tax, is Texas’ main business tax and brings in an estimated $8 billion to state coffers every two-year budget cycle — making it the third-largest source of state revenue.

State Sen. Jane Nelson, R-Flower Mound, who chairs the Senate Finance Committee, introduced HB 28 in the committee on Friday but immediately presented a substitute for it, describing the substitute as “the exact same” as SB 17, which she originally sponsored. The finance committee previously approved SB 17 on a 12-2 vote, and the full Senate approved it 23-7.

Dick Lavine, senior fiscal analyst with the liberal-leaning Center for Public Policy Priorities and the only member of the public to testify in person on the issue Friday, said either plan is a bad idea.

The franchise tax is “a very important source of revenue, and I think we should hang onto it,” Lavine said. “Tax cuts do not pay for themselves” through increased economic growth.

Lavine and other critics of scrapping the franchise tax say the state can’t afford to eliminate a major source of revenue without a plan to replace it, particularly at a time when lawmakers already are faced with making cuts to services in the upcoming 2018-19 budget. Past reductions to the franchise tax have contributed to the current financial difficulties.

But many industry groups have advocated getting rid of the tax, saying it’s too complicated and that it’s unfair because, as a tax on gross receipts, some businesses have to pay it even in years when they make little or no profit.

SB 17 would dedicate half of any state revenue growth above 5 percent to cutting franchise tax rates, until they reached zero. According to the Legislative Budget Board, which advises lawmakers on the potential fiscal impact of proposed legislation, SB 17 wouldn’t reduce state revenue in the upcoming 2018-19 cycle, but would cost the state about $1.1 billion in the 2020-21 cycle.

HB 28, sponsored by state Rep. Dennis Bonnen, R-Angleton, would allocate up to $3.5 billion of the ending balances in state general-revenue funds each two-year budget cycle to reduce the state franchise tax. The tax rate would be lowered each cycle to account for the ending balances, until the rates approached zero and the tax was eliminated.

The Legislative Budget Board has said in a fiscal note on HB 28 that “the maximum biennial franchise tax reduction of $3.5 billion would be triggered” during a typical two-year budget cycle — meaning that’s how much it would reduce state revenue — based on an average ending balance in state general-revenue funds of about $4 billion over the last 10 cycles.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

How to win an argument at work - or stop one before it starts
How to win an argument at work - or stop one before it starts

No one expects to navigate the work world without the occasional argument. And it's nice to "win" when you're in the right. »RELATED: Does birth order affect you in the workplace? But what really matters more than besting your manager or co-workers in an argument is how you handle the conflicts that are an inevitable part of work, ...
Wintry weather tests Austin’s telecommuting abilities
Wintry weather tests Austin’s telecommuting abilities

As Tuesday’s wintry weather hit, a number of Central Texas workers heeded warnings to stay off icy, slick roads and remain at home – but that didn’t mean they all got the day off from work. In today’s high-tech, always-connected world, telecommuting is a viable option for workers in many fields. In fact, in the Austin technology...
8 easy, money-making side gigs for teens 
8 easy, money-making side gigs for teens 

Whether it's the teen who'd like extra money for things like clothes or gas or a parent who'd like to see their high school or college-aged child get off the couch when school’s out, a part-time job can be a wonderful thing. »RELATED: Apple hiring for work from home positions Of course, child labor laws dictate how young is too young...
Austin’s USA Compression Partners plans $1.8 billion acquisition
Austin’s USA Compression Partners plans $1.8 billion acquisition

Austin-based oilfield services company USA Compression Partners plans to buy the compression business from Dallas-based Energy Transfer Partners in a $1.8 billion deal, the companies said Tuesday. The deal “expands USA Compression’s geographic reach into active basins, including Eagle Ford Shale, Gulf Coast, Rockies and Permian Basin,&rdquo...
USA Compression Partners plans $1.8 billion acquisition

USA Compression Partners on Tuesday announced the acquisition of a key rival in a complex, $1.8 billion deal that will make the Austin-based company one of the country’s largest providers of the horsepower that pushes natural gas through pipelines. USA Compression said it will acquire CDM Resource Management and CDM Environmental and Technical...
More Stories