Judge rules against Austin Board of Realtors in election fight


Court: ABoR must hold election for seven directors’ seats

Plaintiffs call ruling a “huge win”

The Austin Board of Realtors has lost a court battle over the terms of its upcoming board election.

As part of a lawsuit filed by two of the organization’s members, State District Judge Jan Soifer has ordered the Board of Realtors to include seven open seats on its board of directors in this month’s election, rather than the five seats the board had maintained were open. The two additional seats are those vacated when Austin real estate agents Cord Shiflet and Brian Talley were ousted as directors Aug. 2.

The lawsuit — filed by Shiflet and Jonathan Boatwright, another member of the organization — is part of a wider internal fight over the operations of the Austin Board of Realtors.

Shiflet called the ruling “a huge win” for he and other Austin Board of Realtors members, including Boatwright and Talley, who have waged a public battle with other members of the organization’s leadership. Shiflet and other agents have accused the group’s board of directors of putting the agency’s interests ahead of those of the 12,000 members in the real estate trade association.

In a written statement, the Austin Board of Realtors said: “We are disappointed in the outcome of the hearing and the board will be evaluating the options moving forward. Regardless of today’s decision we will move forward continuing to focus on serving our members.”

A trial date for the lawsuit has been set for Dec. 4.

In granting the temporary injunction, Soifer ruled that the organization must “desist and refrain from issuing ballots for or otherwise holding the 2017 annual election” without including the candidates for seven positions, including Shiflet’s and Talley’s seats, which have been filled with board-selected appointees. The group has 16 seats on its board of directors.

Shiflet and seven other agents had been petitioning Austin Board of Realtors members to get their names on the ballot to run against the candidates put forth by the board’s nominating committee. The lawsuit contends that the board is violating its bylaws in refusing to hold an election for the seven seats, saying it is another indication of “a troubling pattern of recent action by the Austin Board of Realtors leadership to perpetuate their terms and hinder fresh ideas and active member involvement.”

Shiflet said that in light of Soifer’s ruling, “hopefully now we have the momentum to go in and do what needs to be done. I’m excited for our members, that we fought to let our voice and our rights be upheld and a judge took absolutely no time to rule in our favor.”

“Today we forced the board to allow members to vote,” Shiflet said. “I’m incredibly proud to have helped make that happen… I hope to be elected back to the board and have a chance to get in there and work hard to make things better for our members.”

On July 19, the board censured Shiflet and Talley “for openly communicating with members” about Austin Board of Realtors business, the lawsuit says. The censure stemmed from Shiflet and Talley soliciting members’ input about a board proposal to mandate the use of an app that provides services for showing their residential listings.

The two also sought members’ feedback about a possible merger with the San Antonio Board of Realtors. They said the board had discussed the idea behind closed doors “without wanting input or consultation from members and without some board of directors having transparency,” even though it “may be the biggest and most impactful decision ABoR has ever explored,” Shiflet wrote on Facebook.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Business

5 things to consider before starting a career in a new city
5 things to consider before starting a career in a new city

Sometimes climbing the corporate ladder means a change of venue. But before packing off to a brand-new city, it's important to do some research and check off a few essential tasks from your to-go list. According to Joyce H. Vasser, a retired government human resources manager, failing to prepare properly before a move can cost you personally and professionally...
5 ways you can stand out from the crowd at a career fair
5 ways you can stand out from the crowd at a career fair

Career fairs are held as a way to attract lots of applicants to help fill open positions, but they can often feel like a cattle call. Though it may seem like you're not getting enough meaningful time with potential employers to make a positive impression, there are ways to rise above the crowd. Don't just wander around asking recruiters what positions...
Austin’s Amplify Snack Brands being sold to Hershey for $1.6 billion
Austin’s Amplify Snack Brands being sold to Hershey for $1.6 billion

Amplify Snack Brands, an Austin company best known for its SkinnyPop popcorn, is being bought by The Hershey Co. in a $1.6 billion deal that the maker of chocolate Kisses and candy bars is billing as its largest acquisition ever as it launches a major push into the market for salty snacks. Shares of Amplify, which had been down about 21 percent for...
Up the Ladder

Finance Banker’s Toolbox has named Max Thoene chief operating officer. Government The Texas County & District Retirement System has named Casey Wolf chief investment officer. Health care The Austin Healthcare Council has named Mini Kahlon board chair and Charles Barnett board vice chair. Technology SecureLink has named Chip Pate chief financial...
Top Local Business Stories of the Week
Top Local Business Stories of the Week

3M DEAL 3M to sell Austin unit to Corning in its latest local downsizing: Industrial and consumer products company 3M continues to reduce its Austin footprint, announcing plans to shed a unit based here that makes bandwidth and optical fiber devices for the telecommunications sector — six months after it reached a separate deal to sell its main...
More Stories