Book explores the shadows over Austin’s development


Austin’s business and real-estate community don’t hold an unusually strong influence on the region’s evolution, according to the author of a new book on the city’s development.

If anything, said Eliot Tretter, the vast volumes of urban, social and economic research suggest that the powerful influence of business on urban development is very much the norm.

Yet over the years, Austin has featured two unusual factors in its development, Tretter argues in his newly released book, “Shadows of a Sunbelt City.” The first is the influence of the University of Texas at Austin, which more than most universities has brought federal, state and local funding and interests to bear on its place in the city.

For an example, look no further than the cranes that rise above the new Dell Medical School and the early plans for an innovation district to go along with it.

The effort to get the school established, spearheaded by Sen. Kirk Watson, was nothing if not fully upfront about its efforts to draw public revenue in support of the project. And Travis County voters ultimately voted for an increase in their own property taxes to indirectly fund the school.

“There’s a long precedent for the university to connect its own desires for growth … to what the local government and the local business community is doing,” said Tretter, a former University of Texas lecturer and researcher who now is a professor at the University of Calgary.

The other phenomenon, Tretter said, is a general ignorance of how deeply ingrained business and developer interests have become in the region.

“What is impressive to me about Austin is just the complete kind of denial of the ways the business community, through its various principal organizations, is able to control power,” he said.

That doesn’t reveal itself in an outright dominance over city and county leaders, he said. In fact, Greater Austin Chamber of Commerce officials noted last week that they haven’t brought a single corporate subsidies package to the Austin City Council in two years, mainly because of the city’s tighter restrictions on such incentives.

That powerfuly influence moves in more indirect ways, Tretter said, such as bond elections, the rewriting of the city’s land-use codes and other avenues. Government leaders adopt policies that never quite come to fruition, he said, and rather than recognizing the business community’s sway in that, residents tend to blame the council as ineffective.

“There’s a weird way in which the left and the right have a unified position, an anti-government position,” he said. “So what ends up happening is you always end up blaming the political leaders for the failure of certain policies to mature, rather than looking at how the power structure in the city organizes itself to succeed in certain agendas.”

State law inhibits many inclusionary initiatives that Austin might otherwise use, both in zoning and other policies. But the city also has few examples of a coalesced, countervailing force that can rival the business and development community.

In Austin, Tretter notes in his book, one of the few examples of a broader, community-based response against developers came from Save Our Springs and the fight to limit development over the Edwards Aquifer.

But ultimately, he writes, even those efforts were pulled into an odd sort of alliance with the development community. Environmental concerns came to include only the non-human environment, with less consideration given to other, disadvantaged communities in the city.

And in that sense, Tretter argues, a co-opted environmentalist was integrated into the broader, established interests that hold sway over much of the region’s development. Efforts to build equity and inclusion remained one-off battles outside the mainstream.

“Something like growth is sort of seen as this endless continuum of good, where these little fights are seen as little skirmishes,” he said last week. “If you have a bigger picture of that bigger process, then it begins to fit into a narrative of affordability, inclusion and the types of development we want or don’t want.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Austin-area home sales, prices hit record highs in 2017
Austin-area home sales, prices hit record highs in 2017

Last year was another record-breaker for Central Texas’ housing market, the newest numbers show. And some local real estate agents and housing market experts predict 2018 will look a lot like 2017, with the market staying strong yet concerns about affordability lingering as prices continue their anticipated climb. The Austin Board of Realtors...
Austin-area home sales, prices surge to record highs in 2017
Austin-area home sales, prices surge to record highs in 2017

Last year was another record-breaker for Central Texas’ housing market, the latest numbers show. And some local real estate agents and housing market experts predict 2018 will look a lot like 2017, with the market staying strong even as concerns about affordability linger as prices continue to climb. The Austin Board of Realtors said Thursday...
Gold’s Gym ending 24-hour operations at 4 Austin-area locations
Gold’s Gym ending 24-hour operations at 4 Austin-area locations

Better squeeze in those late-night workouts while you can. Four Central Texas Gold’s Gym locations that are currently open 24 hours will scale back their operating hours starting next month, the chain confirmed Thursday. The affected gyms are: 9101 Research Blvd., Austin 4404 W. William Cannon Drive, Austin ...
Companies turn your Facebook friends into a sales force
Companies turn your Facebook friends into a sales force

Betsy Stover was 17 when her mother asked her to help fax strangers, hawking a service that had the markings of a pyramid scheme. “I always felt like a creep sending unsolicited faxes,” said Stover, who hated the chore, but knew the work required cold calls to succeed. Stover, now a 38-year-old comedian based in Los Angeles, had largely...
Best gifts for the home chef
Best gifts for the home chef

There are all sorts of new gizmos for people whose relationship with food comes in all forms. Here are four of our favorite new devices for the cook and the kitchen. ——— Amazon Dash Wand Product Review: https://www.cnet.com/products/amazon-dash-wand-with-alexa-2017/review/#ftag=CAD187281f CNET rating: 4.0 stars out of 5 (Excellent)...
More Stories